Ordered Two. One for me, one for my mother. Hers were a nice mix of cookies with some special ones. Mine had three rainbow, a lace and one choc covered coconut. Under that a bunch of crumbling butter cookies in colors that were plain and all crumbs. Not holding up. Two different quality levels in the two tins in the same order. Emailed them on the website but no reply. They have some good cookies but QC is a crapshoot. I think they do high volume and you may or may not get fresh.
Rosemary Smith
It's a takeout bakery with the best cookies, rugalah, biscotti & mini pastries around. Also sugar-free cookies. All Kosher. Lovely, polite, customer-focused employees. Delicious! I bring to my doctors & staff at hospital/rehab. Everyone loves them. My personal fav is choc covered mocha cream on vanilla cookie.Dietary restrictions: Sugar-free cookies are quite tasty & I don't seem to notice much differenceParking: A few street spots
I just buy the marzipan in park slope when our supermarket has it in stock, they don't always have it but I dropl when I see these rainbow marzipans in their pastry corner. I just checked the brand name to write a review for them. Amazing rich Marzipan. Thank you from Brooklyn!
Stephanie McDonald
Their the best cookies ever. The owner is extremely nice and his staff is very helpful and professional. Their prices are also very good. I recommend taking a trip there for the best cookies you will ever eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Cookies 1lb Tray, 1lb Biscotti Tray
Daniel Duarte
I’ve heard from employees this place is dirty and often fails cleaning inspection. I don’t recommend it.
Tammy Tillman
Great cookie bakery!
Candace K.
First of all these cookies are amazing! I needed a treat for a work meeting to provide for my clients and this hit the spot! I ordered the 4lb assortment cookies! It was already on a tray and the cookies came in different colors and shapes. They not only looked great but everyone kept raving about how good they tasted and asking where they were from. I paired them with coffee as a treat. I was able to call in my order and pick up same day in ample time. Loved that I could support a local business and share these delicious treats and they look and tasted amazing! I will be back!
Lisa Russo
Great assortment of buttery cookies!
Keith conty
I haven’t been to Continental Cookies but I recently went to a bakery and ordered a tray of cookies for my mothers memorial. I gave rave reviews to the other bakery as every guest was asking about the cookies and I gave them the bakery’s name, so I went to the bakery to thank them and they informed me that couldn’t take the credit as they were from Continental Cookies. I want to thank Continental for helping make the day. I got the new address
Stephanie M.
Besides being the best cookies ever. I've been a customer for over 30 years. Everyone on staff is wonderful. Recently I spoke with Kathy absolutely wonderful she is an asset to your company. Thank you.
Next time I will be more adventurous and try some new cookies too, they all looked delicious. I will be back
Angelica N
Holy crow these cookies are AMAZING. The most delicious cookie assortment ever. I purchased their kosher cookie assortment at Shoprite for a friend’s passover Cedar and they were a hit. So so delicious!!! Made with love!
Tracy K
Ordered Two. One for me, one for my mother. Hers were a nice mix of cookies with some special ones. Mine had three rainbow, a lace and one choc covered coconut. Under that a bunch of crumbling butter cookies in colors that were plain and all crumbs. Not holding up. Two different quality levels in the two tins in the same order. Emailed them on the website but no reply. They have some good cookies but QC is a crapshoot.
Lucy Esteves Llancul
the best cookies i've ever eat
Erik L.
I am visiting relatives in North Carolina and saw these cookies in a Lowe's grocery store. I love love love rainbow cookies and was instantly filled with giddy excitement, as I laid my eyes on these colorful morsels. I couldn't wait to get them home and out of the package and into my tummy. As soon as we got in the door, I tore into them and popped a full cookie into my mouth. The big smile on my face quickly turned into a disappointed scowl, which then morphed into a disgusted grimace, as the flavor profile was overwhelmingly reminiscent of a chemical you would use to control an unwelcome insect population in your kitchen, which was also where I was eating this cookie, which was also where the trash was, which was convenient because that's where these went right after I tried one. After contemplating what could've caused the extremely unsavory taste, I surmised that it had to be way too much almond extract in the marzipan. To make sure it wasn't just my taste buds bugging out, I had my wife and sister-in-law try them too, without providing any details as to what I was tasting. My wife said it tasted very bitter and like chemicals and in addition to too much extract, she felt that there might be too much food coloring as well. My sister-in-law had a similar review.As previously mentioned, I love rainbow cookies so much. Easily in my top three cookies all time and definitely my number one holiday cookie. I was sad that these were so far off the mark. Maybe it was a bad batch, or maybe they are better fresh from the bakery. But this package that I bought at Lowe's on a fateful day in late November of 2022, were 100% inedible.
Ordered Two. One for me, one for my mother. Hers were a nice mix of cookies with some special ones. Mine had three rainbow, a lace and one choc covered coconut. Under that a bunch of crumbling butter cookies in colors that were plain and all crumbs. Not holding up. Two different quality levels in the two tins in the same order. Emailed them on the website but no reply. They have some good cookies but QC is a crapshoot. I think they do high volume and you may or may not get fresh.
It's a takeout bakery with the best cookies, rugalah, biscotti & mini pastries around. Also sugar-free cookies. All Kosher. Lovely, polite, customer-focused employees. Delicious! I bring to my doctors & staff at hospital/rehab. Everyone loves them. My personal fav is choc covered mocha cream on vanilla cookie.Dietary restrictions: Sugar-free cookies are quite tasty & I don't seem to notice much differenceParking: A few street spots
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gourmet Assorted Cookie Tins, Cookie, Rugelach Tray, Handmade Assorted Sugar Free Gourmet Assorted Trays, Biscotti Trays, Assorted Ruggalah Trays, Cookie Boxes, Cookies 1lb Box, 1lb Rugelach Tray, Cookies 1lb Tray, 1lb Biscotti Tray, Handmade Gourmet Cookie Trays, 1lb Kolacky Tray
I just buy the marzipan in park slope when our supermarket has it in stock, they don't always have it but I dropl when I see these rainbow marzipans in their pastry corner. I just checked the brand name to write a review for them. Amazing rich Marzipan. Thank you from Brooklyn!
Their the best cookies ever. The owner is extremely nice and his staff is very helpful and professional. Their prices are also very good. I recommend taking a trip there for the best cookies you will ever eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Cookies 1lb Tray, 1lb Biscotti Tray
I’ve heard from employees this place is dirty and often fails cleaning inspection. I don’t recommend it.
Great cookie bakery!
First of all these cookies are amazing! I needed a treat for a work meeting to provide for my clients and this hit the spot! I ordered the 4lb assortment cookies! It was already on a tray and the cookies came in different colors and shapes. They not only looked great but everyone kept raving about how good they tasted and asking where they were from. I paired them with coffee as a treat. I was able to call in my order and pick up same day in ample time. Loved that I could support a local business and share these delicious treats and they look and tasted amazing! I will be back!
Great assortment of buttery cookies!
I haven’t been to Continental Cookies but I recently went to a bakery and ordered a tray of cookies for my mothers memorial. I gave rave reviews to the other bakery as every guest was asking about the cookies and I gave them the bakery’s name, so I went to the bakery to thank them and they informed me that couldn’t take the credit as they were from Continental Cookies. I want to thank Continental for helping make the day. I got the new address
Besides being the best cookies ever. I've been a customer for over 30 years. Everyone on staff is wonderful. Recently I spoke with Kathy absolutely wonderful she is an asset to your company. Thank you.
Restaurantji Recommends
Next time I will be more adventurous and try some new cookies too, they all looked delicious. I will be back
Holy crow these cookies are AMAZING. The most delicious cookie assortment ever. I purchased their kosher cookie assortment at Shoprite for a friend’s passover Cedar and they were a hit. So so delicious!!! Made with love!
Ordered Two. One for me, one for my mother. Hers were a nice mix of cookies with some special ones. Mine had three rainbow, a lace and one choc covered coconut. Under that a bunch of crumbling butter cookies in colors that were plain and all crumbs. Not holding up. Two different quality levels in the two tins in the same order. Emailed them on the website but no reply. They have some good cookies but QC is a crapshoot.
the best cookies i've ever eat
I am visiting relatives in North Carolina and saw these cookies in a Lowe's grocery store. I love love love rainbow cookies and was instantly filled with giddy excitement, as I laid my eyes on these colorful morsels. I couldn't wait to get them home and out of the package and into my tummy. As soon as we got in the door, I tore into them and popped a full cookie into my mouth. The big smile on my face quickly turned into a disappointed scowl, which then morphed into a disgusted grimace, as the flavor profile was overwhelmingly reminiscent of a chemical you would use to control an unwelcome insect population in your kitchen, which was also where I was eating this cookie, which was also where the trash was, which was convenient because that's where these went right after I tried one. After contemplating what could've caused the extremely unsavory taste, I surmised that it had to be way too much almond extract in the marzipan. To make sure it wasn't just my taste buds bugging out, I had my wife and sister-in-law try them too, without providing any details as to what I was tasting. My wife said it tasted very bitter and like chemicals and in addition to too much extract, she felt that there might be too much food coloring as well. My sister-in-law had a similar review.As previously mentioned, I love rainbow cookies so much. Easily in my top three cookies all time and definitely my number one holiday cookie. I was sad that these were so far off the mark. Maybe it was a bad batch, or maybe they are better fresh from the bakery. But this package that I bought at Lowe's on a fateful day in late November of 2022, were 100% inedible.