Cold Stone Creamery

1930 NJ-57 Ste 2, Hackettstown
(908) 850-9901

Recent Reviews

Matt bruno

They are listed they close at 10pm on Friday. Yet we get there at 9:40pm with the open sign on and the open sign on yet the doors are locked. SMH.

Maria Guzman

Love coming here its always very welcoming.. and the service is always the best. Melanie is so helpful and is willing to help out with any orders or questions. Thank you so much for your services. I will definitely come back again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Endangered Species

Have to LOVE the time they put into the chalk wall!! Melanie was very sweet!! This place has FANTASTIC energy! I just love this Cold Stone!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ayla Lopez

Great ice cream and excellent customer

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah DeSanto

I love this place! Best ice cream shop in the area by far. The costumer service is top tier, I especially appreciate the mangers Melanie and Elena you can tell they love what they do and love working with people. Will be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Madeline Rodríguez

amazing customer service, will definitely be coming back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Liliya Shpolyansky

Make sure you “read” the menu properly there, after being told asking for lucky charms cereal ice cream with just the “marshmallows “ is a common mistake… I was then told we should have read the menu since there are two types of marshmallows. To make it right they were only willing to give me a size 1/5 th of the size purchased.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dakota Morillo

best customer service i’ve experienced in a very long time . everyone was very accommodating and made me feel very welcome. 10/10 would recommend coming here !!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Meigan Lupack

Outstanding service!!! A pleasant experience and a sweet treat

anthony peña

The worst service that can be given they close earlier and give attitude to the customer when they don't want to do things after being inside the place and attending another person in front of me they began to tell me that they were closed with customers and it was only 9 pm Saturday, February 10

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Ralph Drake

my family loves their ice cream cake... I do tooit's what we think of when we think of birthdaythe workers are always helpful and they know what their job isand I can't say enough good about them all .had a bad experience once when the owner got involved,he got everything wrongbut he seems to be involved over his head and other placeswhere I'm sure he gets everything wrongso I only saw him once or twice and he was not cordialbut the ice cream is worth it and the workers are very nice I buy 5 birthday cakes the family loves the product.I recommend it

FridayNightRoblox “James”

My boyfriend tried to order the trick or treat. Got oreos and she moved onto the next order. I tried to order a trick or treat in a waffle bowl. She said okay and then handed me a trick or treat in a normal bowl. its too loud in there and she was trying to close a half hour early. Not worth my time.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Juice

I visited Cold Stone creamy today after a very long day, hoping to treat myself to some delicious ice cream. From the moment we walked into the store, we were greeted with warm smiles by the staff members, instantly making us feel right at home. Their genuine happiness and welcoming attitude gave off the vibe that we were more than just customers – it felt like we were among friends. The staff's friendliness truly added to the overall experience, making our visit to Cold Stone Ice Cream a memorable and delightful one.The ice cream were so delicious.I highly recommend stopping at this Cold Stone location if you’re in the area.

Amy W.

Ice cream was good but very expensive. They we're having a freezer problem the day we went so ice cream was melting. Staff was friendly but would not take my coupon off the app becuse they couldn't find the right code (they said the owner doesn't let them manually do it) Store isnt eco friendly. Apples looked like they were sitting around for aw

Jacob Wise

A small "Like it" sized ice cream is $8 with tax. Do I need to say anything more?The floors are so sticky your shoes literally stick to them and make noises as you walk.Was not greeted upon walking in. Stood in line for 10 minutes without being helped. One associate seemed to be assisting a man ordering an ice cream cake, but no other workers in sight. When it's summer and 85 degrees outside you should have not anybody working by themselves.Walked out and left. Take your money elsewhere!

Load More