One of the best Omlet I ever had. Very friendly owner. I am here to do a GrubHub shoot for Red Berry Bowl.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
nancy pica
I ordered my bagels at 12:15 I didn't get them until 1:30 as you can see by the picture I ordered Asiago, cinnamon raisin,2 French toast and a chocolate chip.I received none of the above except for the cinnamon raisin. If it was late in the day because they close at 1pm someone should have called me to tell me what bagels they did have available because I would have canceled my order.Not happy at all I won't order from then again
Food: 1
Insane
Bagels are soo good, really soft easily my favorite bagel
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kara
Second time ordering food from here from door dash. Second time getting a plain bagel instead of Asiago and this time they didn’t put turkey bacon either. Gave them a 2nd chance bc the sandwich was good last time. I put down to be contacted if items weren’t available but received no call. this will be my last time ordering.
Food: 2
Natacha Perez-Mendez
It says $4.25 for a toasted bagel cream cheese and bacon ?. But I got billed $6.00. What type of 7% tax is that. I never went back. It was delicious and everything was fine. Except their math. So I never went back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Bagel I.
Low standard for service and order taking. Poor excuse for bagels. Never follow instructions.
Scott McCarthy
Constantly dissatisfied and annoyed with my orders. Never anything complicated but the three Chances I gave this shop were all bad. Won’t be
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Computer G.
Stopped here on two different mornings during our trip. Excellent bagels and sandwiches! Order ahead because they get swamped on weekend mornings.
Keyanna Myrick
This is the 3rd time I ordered bagels with cream cheese and they barely put enough to even cover 1 side. Bagels are delicious but very cheap with cream cheese. Awful
Sabrina Yock
Bagel was not too good, tasted stale and had a weird flavor other than an everything bagel. I did not want to even finish it. The iced coffee was all milk. I’ll be trying other bagel shops.
Honestly. I don’t know how this place is still in business. I’ve had better bagels from the pre packages section in the grocery store. This is New Jersey I thought we perfected the bagel already. The prices are outrageous as well
Mark Butera
Bagels stay fresh in plastic bags for a week couldn’t believe it
Susan Schafer-Patterson
I’ve ordered many times from All Star and the bagels are always very good and fresh. The sandwiches I order for myself are always excellent. I would give 5 stars if it weren’t for the fact that my husband’s order is consistently made with cheese when he never orders anything with cheese. Perhaps it’s a GrubHub thing, since that’s how I usually order, but there’s no indication on the app that the sandwich comes with cheese, he never selects cheese as an option, and we even leave notes sometimes asking for no cheese. About 70% of the time, though, his sandwich shows up with cheese. It’s just disappointing because when the order is correct, he loves the food.
Matt Garvey
I love bagels so much! On Saturday me and the wife are going on a diet that would exclude bagels so I was wanting to get one last bagel with bacon egg and cheese to put in the gut and go out with a bang…maybe this was the best place to go to so I never want bagels again. The bagel tastes like it was made from scratch a few days ago. Does not have that good soft texture taste…this was more like a little like saw dust indicating that it’s not fresh...also When you go into a bagel place and there’s not a lot of bagels in the bins then most likely the bagels are not going to be fresh. This place had a small amount of bagels in the bins to choose. I was happy to see an egg everything bagel but it’s not good. The egg and the bacon and the cheese on my bagel was good but if you want this place to be the best bagel place you need to make fresh bagels every day. The inside was very clean and well maintained. So check it out and see what you think maybe it’s my taste buds are out of wack.I’m breaking up with with the help of this place“it’s not you it’s me it’s easier this way. We can go both go our separate ways. Im handing back the key to the apartment. Maybe I see you around.”So long bagels it’s now time to eat apples and bananas everyday for the next year…yay??
Debbie Hamm
Had an egg bagel with butter. I liked that I could bite my bagel and butter did not come gushing out of it. Good flavor, nice chew, not overly crusty. Wish they had poppyseed. I will be back.
One of the best Omlet I ever had. Very friendly owner. I am here to do a GrubHub shoot for Red Berry Bowl.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered my bagels at 12:15 I didn't get them until 1:30 as you can see by the picture I ordered Asiago, cinnamon raisin,2 French toast and a chocolate chip.I received none of the above except for the cinnamon raisin. If it was late in the day because they close at 1pm someone should have called me to tell me what bagels they did have available because I would have canceled my order.Not happy at all I won't order from then again
Food: 1
Bagels are soo good, really soft easily my favorite bagel
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Second time ordering food from here from door dash. Second time getting a plain bagel instead of Asiago and this time they didn’t put turkey bacon either. Gave them a 2nd chance bc the sandwich was good last time. I put down to be contacted if items weren’t available but received no call. this will be my last time ordering.
Food: 2
It says $4.25 for a toasted bagel cream cheese and bacon ?. But I got billed $6.00. What type of 7% tax is that. I never went back. It was delicious and everything was fine. Except their math. So I never went back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Low standard for service and order taking. Poor excuse for bagels. Never follow instructions.
Constantly dissatisfied and annoyed with my orders. Never anything complicated but the three Chances I gave this shop were all bad. Won’t be
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Stopped here on two different mornings during our trip. Excellent bagels and sandwiches! Order ahead because they get swamped on weekend mornings.
This is the 3rd time I ordered bagels with cream cheese and they barely put enough to even cover 1 side. Bagels are delicious but very cheap with cream cheese. Awful
Bagel was not too good, tasted stale and had a weird flavor other than an everything bagel. I did not want to even finish it. The iced coffee was all milk. I’ll be trying other bagel shops.
Restaurantji Recommends
Honestly. I don’t know how this place is still in business. I’ve had better bagels from the pre packages section in the grocery store. This is New Jersey I thought we perfected the bagel already. The prices are outrageous as well
Bagels stay fresh in plastic bags for a week couldn’t believe it
I’ve ordered many times from All Star and the bagels are always very good and fresh. The sandwiches I order for myself are always excellent. I would give 5 stars if it weren’t for the fact that my husband’s order is consistently made with cheese when he never orders anything with cheese. Perhaps it’s a GrubHub thing, since that’s how I usually order, but there’s no indication on the app that the sandwich comes with cheese, he never selects cheese as an option, and we even leave notes sometimes asking for no cheese. About 70% of the time, though, his sandwich shows up with cheese. It’s just disappointing because when the order is correct, he loves the food.
I love bagels so much! On Saturday me and the wife are going on a diet that would exclude bagels so I was wanting to get one last bagel with bacon egg and cheese to put in the gut and go out with a bang…maybe this was the best place to go to so I never want bagels again. The bagel tastes like it was made from scratch a few days ago. Does not have that good soft texture taste…this was more like a little like saw dust indicating that it’s not fresh...also When you go into a bagel place and there’s not a lot of bagels in the bins then most likely the bagels are not going to be fresh. This place had a small amount of bagels in the bins to choose. I was happy to see an egg everything bagel but it’s not good. The egg and the bacon and the cheese on my bagel was good but if you want this place to be the best bagel place you need to make fresh bagels every day. The inside was very clean and well maintained. So check it out and see what you think maybe it’s my taste buds are out of wack.I’m breaking up with with the help of this place“it’s not you it’s me it’s easier this way. We can go both go our separate ways. Im handing back the key to the apartment. Maybe I see you around.”So long bagels it’s now time to eat apples and bananas everyday for the next year…yay??
Had an egg bagel with butter. I liked that I could bite my bagel and butter did not come gushing out of it. Good flavor, nice chew, not overly crusty. Wish they had poppyseed. I will be back.