Corleone's Old Fashion Tomato Pie & Pizza

1270 S Olden Ave, Hamilton
(609) 689-1270

Recent Reviews

Bree Mckenna

Food was great! Very affordable. They threw in some zeppolis for free as well. Highly recommend!

Gina G

I brought us to the wrong pizza place but it turned out to be great. The cheesteak pizza is a must!! Believe me so refreshing with fresh lettuce topping it off and a sauce that was excellent.. would make the stop back here again for a slice!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

luis fernando Perez

If you want to try a delicious, crunchy pizza, and with the original touch of this variety, I recommend this place, it is almost hidden here in Hamilton, near Route 295 south exit 62a Olden Avenue, 2 or 3 miles away you will find this place, with a varied menu, and excellent service and prices, don't hesitate, you won't regret it and you will leave here satisfied.If you want to try a delicious, crunchy pizza, and with the original touch of this variety, I recommend this place, it is almost hidden here in Hamilton, near Route 295 south exit 62a Olden Avenue, 2 or 3 miles away you will find this place, with a varied menu, and excellent service and prices, don't hesitate, you won't regret it and you will leave here satisfied.Si tu quieres probar una pizza deliciosa,crujiente, y con el toque original de esta variedad, te recomiendo este lugar, está casi e escondido aquí en Hamilton, cerca de la ruta 295 sur salida 62a Olden Avenue a 2 o 3 millas se encuentra este sitio,con un menú variado,y su atención y precios excelentes, no lo duden no se arrepentirán y saldrán satisfechos de aquí.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

yoohoo1616

Got a clam and a tomato. The clam was disgusting (fishy taste, crunchy sand gristle), luckily I didn't get sick. The tomato was ok. On the sweet side. Because of how bad the clams were I will not return.

Food: 2

Wilken Lee

Tried this place from the reviews. Not sure if they had an off night but the tomato pie was overly sweet and salty. The crust on the other hand was very good. My son who loves pizza could only eat a few bites. Better off going to Do Lorenzo, Danny or Special Pizza City. Not going back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Tino G.

Don't know what happened to this place it used to be great now the food and pizza sucks they need better food and services

John Bartlett

It was better than CATS on Broadway and I'm going back again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again hahaha! I love you Daniel!!!!YOU MAKE THE GREATEST PIZZA AND TOMATO PIE IN THE WORLD!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vadim Chechenev

Unprofessional! Avoid this place

Fredy Tay Red

We ordered pizza and other items. We loved

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

John K.

Corleone's always serves the freshest ingredients I've ever had. Flavors are truly amazing and they never fail in providing an awesome dining experience. And that's their take out. Highly recommended

E. Lynn Osborne

Great service and the staff loved the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Don Thompson

Fantastic Pizza. I'm sure everything else is great there as well but I haven't tried it yet but soon will. Great customer service. The owners a great guy. My new favorite spot in town.Parking: Big parking lot.Kid-friendliness: Just a nice friendly atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Old Fashion Tomato Pie

Mia L.

Not all pizza is created equally! I never get tired of their tomato pies and chicken cheesesteaks because they use real chopped chicken (not that crap that many others sell). Customer service is always friendly. Corleone! Your the best

Aqeel N.

I had the pleasure of eating here just a week ago. A week ago I would've told you the pizza was phenomenal, I had been waiting to go back for my next pizza night. Unfortunately; here we are, pizza night and no pizza. I made the same order from the previous week which was a Vodka Pie to now receive said pie with chunks of bacon (prosciutto) in it. Still not an issue, I called to let them know the mix up of this pie from the previous to which I was told, "it's in the sauce". It wasn't in the sauce last week. After checking online I see nothing about Prosciutto being in the sauce. My man must've had a rough day because his initial response was, "What do you want? Because i'm losing money on this" Here's a tip; add it to the slices you're selling individually or have a nice break with your coworkers and share. I have restrictions so I cannot physically have any pork. I would've been cool with a credit but after haggling with him for $10 I was able to get another pizza. Y'all pray for me now because the attitude of this fella might put me in the hospital if he tampers with this new pie. Truthfully, just update your online menu. It could've been avoided, and it was best that I came just to get another one when I could've ate it gone to the hospital and hit this establishment with one of those McDonald's lawsuits. Treat others the way you'd like to be treated. With that being said; Piccolo Trattoria in Pennington has the undisputed Vodka pie. S/O to the cashier lady who listened to me and helped me just get another pie to replace the previous. She was nice. She gets a star. Vodka Pie Vodka Pie Pizza So this is what I received. Yep, my associates and I will be removing this location as a potential food destination.

Matthew Tylutki Jr

Wonderful food including the pizza, Italian Hot Dog, and dessert. Delivery is

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Old Fashion Tomato Pie

Load More

Corleone's Old Fashion Tomato Pie & Pizza

1270 S Olden Ave, Hamilton, NJ 08610
(609) 689-1270