Ordered tails for superbowl this past weekend. Got mild and hot tails. The mild was almost at hot level. The hot was nuclear. I like hot stuff so it wasn't that big a deal to me but my wife could barely eat the mild so beware if you get the hot. Also we ordered for pickup at 345. The tails were barely warm when we got them and had obviously been made well ahead of time. Not a big deal they were still good but I'd rather have them hot and fresh when i pick them up and not have to reheat at home.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
paul gras
Food is good but I'm trying to figure out who came up with the bleu cheese ratio? I ordered 24 tails a you only get 2 small bleu cheese. Then want to charge for extra. Does not make sense. The 24 should come with a pint, but you charge additional instead.
Robert Gardner
Best wings around! Also love their poppers...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ed Jewell
Great place for a quick slice of pizza or an awesome sandwich. Bottled soda available, but the fountain has been out of service for a while.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve H.
Disappointed! Tonight Costello's would not serve me a slice with a topping. You want toppings you need to orderOnly a whole pie. They have severed slices with toppings before. This place is now out in my book! Plenty of other options on the like Ninos. We opted for just 1 slice of plain and found out they now charge you 3% for a credit card. Not sure if $3.50 a plain slice is worth it here anymore!
yaneyri serrata
I loved!! The young woman at the cashier, super friendly and was also very specific in the details of my order, also offered me other options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kim D.
worst pizza I ever had hardly any sauce rubbery cheese & very salty would not recommend or ever go back
Mary Kate mcCormick
Canceled order kept getting delayed 2 hours past order time, never again.
This might the worst food in Hammonton. The pizza tastes like it’s from a convenience store and the bacon cheeseburger was a low quality frozen beef patty with cheese-whiz dumped all over it. No lettuce, tomato, onion. Just whiz and cheap meat. Had to throw it out after first bite. If you want to do better Costello’s, buy quality ingredients and make good fresh food.
Food: 1
She Text
Honestly not an inviting place, plus im almost positive the bacon I was given was too old. walk inside you’ll
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Hec love 609
My place I got for salads and garlic knots oh my God is delicious.
Ray Z
Love the vegetable ?!!! I can't way any more. We ordered ahead so it can be ready. When we arrived it was ready. Thanks! After sitting down someone noticed our ? and asked for a slice but was told it was for someone else. That's me! I suggest making this ? to sell by the slice. It is needed in your regular menu daily!!
Morgan Singleton
Pizza’s good, but I’m never paying almost $15.00 for 3 slices of pepperoni ever again. I should have just gone for a whole pie at that point. Someone should look at that pricing again. That’s disgusting.
Fast, friendly service and excellent food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered tails for superbowl this past weekend. Got mild and hot tails. The mild was almost at hot level. The hot was nuclear. I like hot stuff so it wasn't that big a deal to me but my wife could barely eat the mild so beware if you get the hot. Also we ordered for pickup at 345. The tails were barely warm when we got them and had obviously been made well ahead of time. Not a big deal they were still good but I'd rather have them hot and fresh when i pick them up and not have to reheat at home.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Food is good but I'm trying to figure out who came up with the bleu cheese ratio? I ordered 24 tails a you only get 2 small bleu cheese. Then want to charge for extra. Does not make sense. The 24 should come with a pint, but you charge additional instead.
Best wings around! Also love their poppers...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for a quick slice of pizza or an awesome sandwich. Bottled soda available, but the fountain has been out of service for a while.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Disappointed! Tonight Costello's would not serve me a slice with a topping. You want toppings you need to orderOnly a whole pie. They have severed slices with toppings before. This place is now out in my book! Plenty of other options on the like Ninos. We opted for just 1 slice of plain and found out they now charge you 3% for a credit card. Not sure if $3.50 a plain slice is worth it here anymore!
I loved!! The young woman at the cashier, super friendly and was also very specific in the details of my order, also offered me other options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
worst pizza I ever had hardly any sauce rubbery cheese & very salty would not recommend or ever go back
Canceled order kept getting delayed 2 hours past order time, never again.
Best buffalo tails ever hands down!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Tails, Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
This might the worst food in Hammonton. The pizza tastes like it’s from a convenience store and the bacon cheeseburger was a low quality frozen beef patty with cheese-whiz dumped all over it. No lettuce, tomato, onion. Just whiz and cheap meat. Had to throw it out after first bite. If you want to do better Costello’s, buy quality ingredients and make good fresh food.
Food: 1
Honestly not an inviting place, plus im almost positive the bacon I was given was too old. walk inside you’ll
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My place I got for salads and garlic knots oh my God is delicious.
Love the vegetable ?!!! I can't way any more. We ordered ahead so it can be ready. When we arrived it was ready. Thanks! After sitting down someone noticed our ? and asked for a slice but was told it was for someone else. That's me! I suggest making this ? to sell by the slice. It is needed in your regular menu daily!!
Pizza’s good, but I’m never paying almost $15.00 for 3 slices of pepperoni ever again. I should have just gone for a whole pie at that point. Someone should look at that pricing again. That’s disgusting.