I'm absolutely obsessed! spent about 30 trying different types of slices. Loved every single slice!!
Carly Luk
We had an absolutely bizarre experience with Tony Boloney's. We ordered a pizza for delivery at a certain time. 45 minutes after that time, we were wondering what happened to the pizza and called to check. They had the wrong phone number so they said they were unable to deliver, although the building has an intercom and they had our correct address. Anyway, we understood the mixup and they told us they were dispatching the pizza right away, so we were satisfied. After another hour, it still didn't show, so we called again- they actually stopped picking up calls from our number! We called 5 times from the original number and each one was ignored. We called from a different number and they picked up immediately, so we know they were ignoring the other number. However, as soon as we mentioned the name the order was under, they put us on hold and never came back. We're disputing the charge with the bank since we had already paid, but I'm still shocked at how this was handled- simply refusing our calls with no explanation is a bizarre way to handle an order. If they could have just told us they were cancelling our order, we could have ordered food elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Zachary G.
honestly a bad experience considering it was so hyped on tiktok pizza had wayyy too much oil one person working but he was alright, super overpriced for mediocre food i honestly was hoping it was going to live up to the expectations. Drink selection wasn't great but the Joe's lemonade was great.
Ezra H.
Ordered here the other night. And it was such a good thing. Was tired of other places around. Looking for something a bit different. So gave them a shot and it's now a favorite of mine. Shaolin Assassin Wings - Boneless. These were so meaty and big. The sauce was perfect. f***ing Gindolune 12 inch pizza. Perfect for 2 people. The shaved steak, the mozzarella and the garlic sauce on the pizza were amazing. Can't wait to try the subs and mozzarella sticks. They sell Home Made Mozzarella balls too! They look amazing.
Brett S.
Awful. They got my drink order wrong and my $18 philly cheesesteak was a mess, the bread was stale and it was inedible.
Carly L.
We had an absolutely bizarre experience with Tony Boloney's. We ordered a pizza for delivery at a certain time. 45 minutes after that time, we were wondering what happened to the pizza and called to check. They had the wrong phone number so they said they were unable to deliver, although the building has an intercom and they had our correct address. Anyway, we understood the mixup and they told us they were dispatching the pizza right away, so we were satisfied. After another hour, it still didn't show, so we called again- they actually stopped picking up calls from our number! We called 5 times from the original number and each one was ignored. We called from a different number and they picked up immediately, so we know they were ignoring the other number. However, as soon as we mentioned the name the order was under, they put us on hold and never came back. We're disputing the charge with the bank since we had already paid, but I'm still shocked at how this was handled- simply refusing our calls with no explanation is a bizarre way to handle an order. If they could have just told us they were cancelling our order, we could have ordered food elsewhere.
Emmy A.
I checked out this place for the first time yesterday and was totally amazed by all the crazy flavor combos. It's like pure genius. I had the "Oh La La" pizza and couldn't stop talking about it. Ended up going back for another slice the very next day!
Romy Bustamante
We were excited to try out their specialty pizzas, little did we know we would get violently sick after eating it. We don't make these accusations easily, it was proven we got sick from there because the first time we got sick we attributed it to another restaurant, then we had the refrigerated leftovers from Tony's and Bam! Got sick again. Eat from here at your own risk.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Eddy G
Tony Boloney's is a place I've been wanting to try for a long time. They have some of the most over-the-top lookin’ food I've ever seen. They are definitely the kind of place that hypes up their food for being "extra" on Instagram. So, I was curious... Do they live up to the hype?The food definitely lives up. Is it extra? Yes. Is it probably bad for your health? Absolutely. Did I enjoy it? For sure. They are a pizza shop primarily, but I feel like their subs are the real star of the show. I think their philly cheesesteak might be one of the best I've ever eaten.The only issues I really have with Tony Boloney's is that they seemed a little short staffed, a lot of things in the restaurant were apparently not functioning properly, and the one guy at the counter was on the phone trying to sort out various things going wrong at the restaurant. Made for kind of a weird ordering experience, but it wasn't the guy's fault. He seemed to be trying his best. Also, with things being short staffed, the tables were a bit dirty.The TLDR though... It's worth the trip from New York over to New Jersey, and the food itself is very extra in the best way. It lives up to the Instagram hype.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Eddy G.
Tony Boloney's is a place I've been wanting to try for a long time. They have some of the most over-the-top lookin' food I've ever seen. They are definitely the kind of place that hypes up their food for being "extra" on Instagram. So, I was curious... Do they live up to the hype? The food definitely lives up. Is it extra? Yes. Is it probably bad for your health? Absolutely. Did I enjoy it? For sure. They are a pizza shop primarily, but I feel like their subs are the real star of the show. I think their philly cheesesteak might be one of the best I've ever eaten. The only issues I really have with Tony Boloney's is that they seemed a little short staffed, a lot of things in the restaurant were apparently not functioning properly, and the one guy at the counter was on the phone trying to sort out various things going wrong at the restaurant. Made for kind of a weird ordering experience, but it wasn't the guy's fault. He seemed to be trying his best. Also, with things being short staffed, the tables were a bit dirty. The TLDR though... It's worth the trip from New York over to New Jersey, and the food itself is very extra in the best way. It lives up to the Instagram hype.
Dough was undercooked and the pizza was drenched in oil, I felt so sick after eating here. In addition, the kid behind the counter wasrude. Could be because he was on his own, and had no help so his frustration was taken on customers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
E3p ceo
I had the taco ? pizza ? which was fire ? it was about $100 for a pie ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Antonio S.
This is by far the best pizza establishment I've ever been to and eaten at. The environment is very chill and the staff and manager are very welcoming and respectful. The pizza here is amazing, BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA IVE EVER HAD! So far the taco taco taco pizza is probably the best here or the showgun shadowboxer or even the fuckin gindolune; either way a lot of great options to choose from and even more. Prices are a bit high but for once it makes sense for the work it must take to make pies like this.. overall I'll be coming here everytime I wanna eat good pizza when I have the budget to splurge on some delicious slices :)
Genia N.
Full disclosure: if you're looking to get a boring plain slice of cheese pizza, this is not the place. I've been going to Tony's pretty much since they opened in Hoboken and I've had the best experience. The flavors are always cool and somehow just work. I always go for Shitfaced or Pancho Franco. Oddly enough, I love the Token Girl salad here too. TB's was my go to treat of the week during lockdown and those guys really worked. My only issue with them is that I doctors would frown upon me eating pizza every day, no matter how tempting. The owner always makes a point to help the community and invests in the brand (cool logo, murals etc.) It is more of a grab a slice/pie and go place but has seating if you're so inclined. Note that weekends nights are WILD here, especially when the kids leave the bars and need to soak up those fireball shots at 2am, but who can blame them.
I'm absolutely obsessed! spent about 30 trying different types of slices. Loved every single slice!!
We had an absolutely bizarre experience with Tony Boloney's. We ordered a pizza for delivery at a certain time. 45 minutes after that time, we were wondering what happened to the pizza and called to check. They had the wrong phone number so they said they were unable to deliver, although the building has an intercom and they had our correct address. Anyway, we understood the mixup and they told us they were dispatching the pizza right away, so we were satisfied. After another hour, it still didn't show, so we called again- they actually stopped picking up calls from our number! We called 5 times from the original number and each one was ignored. We called from a different number and they picked up immediately, so we know they were ignoring the other number. However, as soon as we mentioned the name the order was under, they put us on hold and never came back. We're disputing the charge with the bank since we had already paid, but I'm still shocked at how this was handled- simply refusing our calls with no explanation is a bizarre way to handle an order. If they could have just told us they were cancelling our order, we could have ordered food elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
honestly a bad experience considering it was so hyped on tiktok pizza had wayyy too much oil one person working but he was alright, super overpriced for mediocre food i honestly was hoping it was going to live up to the expectations. Drink selection wasn't great but the Joe's lemonade was great.
Ordered here the other night. And it was such a good thing. Was tired of other places around. Looking for something a bit different. So gave them a shot and it's now a favorite of mine. Shaolin Assassin Wings - Boneless. These were so meaty and big. The sauce was perfect. f***ing Gindolune 12 inch pizza. Perfect for 2 people. The shaved steak, the mozzarella and the garlic sauce on the pizza were amazing. Can't wait to try the subs and mozzarella sticks. They sell Home Made Mozzarella balls too! They look amazing.
Awful. They got my drink order wrong and my $18 philly cheesesteak was a mess, the bread was stale and it was inedible.
We had an absolutely bizarre experience with Tony Boloney's. We ordered a pizza for delivery at a certain time. 45 minutes after that time, we were wondering what happened to the pizza and called to check. They had the wrong phone number so they said they were unable to deliver, although the building has an intercom and they had our correct address. Anyway, we understood the mixup and they told us they were dispatching the pizza right away, so we were satisfied. After another hour, it still didn't show, so we called again- they actually stopped picking up calls from our number! We called 5 times from the original number and each one was ignored. We called from a different number and they picked up immediately, so we know they were ignoring the other number. However, as soon as we mentioned the name the order was under, they put us on hold and never came back. We're disputing the charge with the bank since we had already paid, but I'm still shocked at how this was handled- simply refusing our calls with no explanation is a bizarre way to handle an order. If they could have just told us they were cancelling our order, we could have ordered food elsewhere.
I checked out this place for the first time yesterday and was totally amazed by all the crazy flavor combos. It's like pure genius. I had the "Oh La La" pizza and couldn't stop talking about it. Ended up going back for another slice the very next day!
We were excited to try out their specialty pizzas, little did we know we would get violently sick after eating it. We don't make these accusations easily, it was proven we got sick from there because the first time we got sick we attributed it to another restaurant, then we had the refrigerated leftovers from Tony's and Bam! Got sick again. Eat from here at your own risk.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Tony Boloney's is a place I've been wanting to try for a long time. They have some of the most over-the-top lookin’ food I've ever seen. They are definitely the kind of place that hypes up their food for being "extra" on Instagram. So, I was curious... Do they live up to the hype?The food definitely lives up. Is it extra? Yes. Is it probably bad for your health? Absolutely. Did I enjoy it? For sure. They are a pizza shop primarily, but I feel like their subs are the real star of the show. I think their philly cheesesteak might be one of the best I've ever eaten.The only issues I really have with Tony Boloney's is that they seemed a little short staffed, a lot of things in the restaurant were apparently not functioning properly, and the one guy at the counter was on the phone trying to sort out various things going wrong at the restaurant. Made for kind of a weird ordering experience, but it wasn't the guy's fault. He seemed to be trying his best. Also, with things being short staffed, the tables were a bit dirty.The TLDR though... It's worth the trip from New York over to New Jersey, and the food itself is very extra in the best way. It lives up to the Instagram hype.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tony Boloney's is a place I've been wanting to try for a long time. They have some of the most over-the-top lookin' food I've ever seen. They are definitely the kind of place that hypes up their food for being "extra" on Instagram. So, I was curious... Do they live up to the hype? The food definitely lives up. Is it extra? Yes. Is it probably bad for your health? Absolutely. Did I enjoy it? For sure. They are a pizza shop primarily, but I feel like their subs are the real star of the show. I think their philly cheesesteak might be one of the best I've ever eaten. The only issues I really have with Tony Boloney's is that they seemed a little short staffed, a lot of things in the restaurant were apparently not functioning properly, and the one guy at the counter was on the phone trying to sort out various things going wrong at the restaurant. Made for kind of a weird ordering experience, but it wasn't the guy's fault. He seemed to be trying his best. Also, with things being short staffed, the tables were a bit dirty. The TLDR though... It's worth the trip from New York over to New Jersey, and the food itself is very extra in the best way. It lives up to the Instagram hype.
Restaurantji Recommends
Dough was undercooked and the pizza was drenched in oil, I felt so sick after eating here. In addition, the kid behind the counter wasrude. Could be because he was on his own, and had no help so his frustration was taken on customers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
I had the taco ? pizza ? which was fire ? it was about $100 for a pie ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is by far the best pizza establishment I've ever been to and eaten at. The environment is very chill and the staff and manager are very welcoming and respectful. The pizza here is amazing, BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA IVE EVER HAD! So far the taco taco taco pizza is probably the best here or the showgun shadowboxer or even the fuckin gindolune; either way a lot of great options to choose from and even more. Prices are a bit high but for once it makes sense for the work it must take to make pies like this.. overall I'll be coming here everytime I wanna eat good pizza when I have the budget to splurge on some delicious slices :)
Full disclosure: if you're looking to get a boring plain slice of cheese pizza, this is not the place. I've been going to Tony's pretty much since they opened in Hoboken and I've had the best experience. The flavors are always cool and somehow just work. I always go for Shitfaced or Pancho Franco. Oddly enough, I love the Token Girl salad here too. TB's was my go to treat of the week during lockdown and those guys really worked. My only issue with them is that I doctors would frown upon me eating pizza every day, no matter how tempting. The owner always makes a point to help the community and invests in the brand (cool logo, murals etc.) It is more of a grab a slice/pie and go place but has seating if you're so inclined. Note that weekends nights are WILD here, especially when the kids leave the bars and need to soak up those fireball shots at 2am, but who can blame them.
Amazing place to eat a great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheezy Garlic Bread, Taco Taco Taco Pizza Slice, Winger, Chicken Wings