Papa Johns Pizza

742 Lyons Ave, Irvington
(973) 375-7272

Recent Reviews

Robert Christie

Short of being in Compton, this was a very authentic neighbourhood. The service was prompt and accurate, thanks guys!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Donald Preston

On February 10, 2024 , I entered this location to make several purchases, the customer service is non existent the employees are not friendly or welcoming. The young lady putting the dough through the machine totally ignored me standing there trying to order, her bare hands handling the dough hands nasty and filthy.Finally a gentleman came out the back and greeted me with a what you need I asked him for a menu and he informed me we ain't got none look on line.This is the treatment you get trying to support the community, no thank you so I took my business elsewhere and placed a $65.00 order and was treated very well.I will be calling the health department in regards to the food handling violations and the general nastiness of the store.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Brooklyn Bulle

I've been binging on the West Wing, and Papa John's came in clutch. Delivery was quick, pizza was still hot and fresh upon delivery.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Isis W.

very rude hung up on me the food is very good the service is very bad and Idk what ambiance is but I will n order from the again

Sanai Dozier

This place is so rudeeee! They took forever to deliver my food and when I called they had a bad attitude! Do better!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The Bros

The girl that was at the front counter on my visit yesterday, Sunday, July 9th 2023 was rude shs was taking an order over the phone, there was a customer in front of me, so once the girl was done on the phone she just went and got the other customers order, but she never said i'll be right with you or anything!To me that's bad customer service and very rude! That particular employee needs to have better customer service etiquette!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

King ReeF

Not the best place to find parking but the restaurant is good.

Sharif Williams

Not the best place to find parking but the restaurant is good.

Tonyia Jenkins

The person that took and made my order was arguing with the delivery person, I wanted my money back. First time and last

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Sonia Galvao

Every time I go to pick up the attendants don't come to the counter, it looks like a ghost has entered. In particular, the short, white, curly and blonde attendant is always rude and left me waiting for almost 20 minutes for an order that had already been ready for 5 minutes, all I say every time she answers me is very rude, I believe she hates working at Papa John's. Another attendant who ended my service. I'm an immigrant, the next time I'm mistreated by this attendant I'm going to call the police, is this because I'm an immigrant?

La Megane

Be careful. These people are a rip off. Each time I call it’s an Indian guy. How come a small cheesy Alfredo pizza cost over $16 and a medium one is above $17 with nothing special added to it? No thanks!!

Leslie Thomas

This Papa Johns is a well oiled machine. My order is always on point and ready by the time I get there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Prince Dwood

I ordered stuffed crust parm pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese but I got pepperoni and cheese pizza smh.???

Ayezeisha Bethel

They over charged me for a lrg pizza, wings and 2 liter soda.

Selena Anderson

Always good. I usually do delivery, but I did pick up and loved it even more because it was piping hot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Load More