All Star Bagel: New Prospect

255 S New Prospect Rd # 4, Jackson
(732) 905-0333

Recent Reviews

Recgaming94

They have the BEST employees here!!! Delicious food too!

Waves Reefs

The bagels here are so soft! Everything I’ve ordered is so delicious. My go to bagel shop in Jackson.

Joe Barina

Customer service is awful can't get orders right even on a remake

Devin Teal

12 bucks for a Snapple and a PEC with 2 skimpy pieces of pork roll

Kelsey B.

Delicious chewy bagels and quick service. Lox was fresh and pork roll sandwich was delicious. Also love their pumpkin bagels!

Kellie Liquori

Love the food and the workers.

Steve Nagy

I picked up a few bagels for my family. Employees were very nice!

gema m.

In Jersey and looking for a quick breakfast place, when we happened upon All Star Bagels and thought "why not?". It was a great choice! Excellent selection of bagels, delicious breakfast sandwiches, and so much more on the menu. Staff was also incredibly friendly! Food was made on the spot, which did take a few minutes but totally worth the wait! We ordered an egg, ham, & cheese on wheat bagel and a egg, sausage, & cheese on wheat and coffees. Both meals were filling and delicious. I'd definitely recommend this place, and if I'm back in the area I'll definitely be stopping by again.

jenny mckenna

Super friendly co-owners/ workers

Jessica Korowaj-Roff

Great service and friendly atmosphere!! Delicious food and super fun people!! We will be getting breakfast here again! Also mails to places that can’t get delicious Jersey bagels! I will be sharing these bagels with my Tennessee friends!!

Aida Mendez

Waited 30 mins for bacon egg and cheese with 3 othere bagels with cream cheese. This place isn't even that busy to be taking this long

Carmen Jerez

Breakfast slider sandwich (French toast bagel) looked great and tasted even better?I also order chicken strips no really my favoriteThe cashier attitude ??But the owner she was so sweet

Martin Mc Manus

Great spot to pick up a great breakfast sandwich. Great bagels.

Jason Varadi

Perfect Pork Roll Egg Cheese, great service, hard working group making sure you get your order the way you want it and on time

Diana Terranova

I must say I’ve been living on this planet for 81 years and never heard of a bagel sandwich with one egg that’s totally lost in the sandwich. Everyone in creation gives two eggs on an egg sandwich with a bagel with sausage and or turkey bacon. This is out of control plus this country store charges $5 dollars for one egg with sausage as if you were living in Beverly Hills. Ridiculous overpriced underserved and poor prepared sandwich

Load More