The pizza is amazing!! Everyone was very friendly and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alan Stouffer
Pizza Bianca for the win!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
RAVI_P_S_CHAUHAN
Went there as it gave a retro feeling, but the look and feel of the place as well as the food was not good. The toppings are put sparingly if you get a fresh one made.
Thomas G.
Ordered delivery, very quick service but our cheese pizza was oblong and underdone and the garlic knots were ironically burnt to a crisp. I'd be more than willing to wait longer for a pizza if it means it would be cooked all the way through. There's so many other better pizza joints in Paulus hook, don't bother
Caroline K
Wings are awful. Very dry, sauces taste like they’re from store bought bottles. Do not recommend.
Food: 1
Johnny Atenco
Great slice, not too greasy and a good size for price.
Aileen Szymaniak
Delicious pizza and amazing service. They went above what they needed to in order to seat our group of 9, plus made sure to let us know what they were working on to get fresh slices out. Really great spot!
Ray M.
Astonished of the aptitude of service and quality of the food. This order was a late night audible for dinner and they did not disappoint. Staff confirmed if I wanted grilled or breaded chicken with the calzone without me asking, very thoughtful. Will be back for more
Nicole F.
Meat calzone was delicious. They did not skimp on the meat and cheese. The owner even threw in a free soda. Only bummer is that prices are a little steep for a pizza place.
Debie L.
TLDR; not worth the price and questionable service. We did a quick stop by this place just past 10pm on a Saturday. We didn't realize that the store closes at 10pm because their sign says "Open" and there are workers standing at the counter and smiling/saying nothing when we walk in. The person (older gentleman) then says, "we were just about to close but you can pay for a pie and we'll give you all the slices" (there are scattered slices of different pies, altogether about 1 pie worth). We declined politely as it was just us 2 looking for a snack, so we didn't want all that much food. Also not a great deal since they were probably going to throw it away anyways (*insert confused meme here*). He then pressured us asking, "what if you get hungry later?" Sometimes you gotta upsell, we get it. We decided to order a Stromboli and a slice of Sicilian. He rings us up for a Stromboli and 2 Sicilians. Luckily my fiancé caught it and asked him for just the one slice. Mayyyybe he just doesn't hear too well so he got the order wrong? Not sure. He then gives us the second slice "for free". However, the prices here are pretty steep and TBH we were disappointed in the quality. The Stromboli was not heated up well and it was too salty/greasy. The Sicilian was pretty small for the price. Good luck to this business, if they're struggling with the pandemic changes, but they may need to work on taking orders better!
Pizza is consistently bad. I'd be happier with a 10/$10 Celeste pizza. Pizza is always undercooked and the bottom is always pale and dusted with raw flour. If you order a pie, you can easily make a whole other pizza by scraping the bottom flour off. Worse than public school cafeteria pizza. I wish my job would stop ordering for catering.
C J.
Ordered delivery on Slice: a medium cheese added roasted garlic, and the focaccia w/ eggplant, peppers, and mozz. What came was hilariously not that: it was a plain cheese pizza, and a side of garlic powder in a plastic cup The "focaccia" was a dollar roll; no mozz. Part of me was annoyed, the other part was like "this is on me for thinking an affordable joint would be fancy." The pizza was simple and fine, but I'm not going to order here again, even knowing what I know now.
Chakeema C.
Sigh. So I ordered/paid online for two Sicilian slices and cheese fries for pickup. I tracked on the app and it stated my order would be ready 10 mins. I was running about 20 mins late. When I got there, the woman at the front had no clue what Sicilian was and said they didn't have it. Instead they offered me three slices of plain. They took about 10-15 mins to make the order. I get back to my office to open the stapled shut bag to see the cheese fries ARE 2 CHEESE SLICES??? I'm hurt and confused. So FYI, don't get the cheese fries unless you want cheese slices. Also- the pizza was average. It was cold.
Meghan C.
Ordered the meat Stromboli--almost inedible--tasted like it had been sitting out all day and was way too cheesy. The Hawaiian pie wasn't terrible, but literally came with 5 medium size chunks of pineapple and was EXTREMELY cheesy. Overall presentation was LACKING. Would not order from here again.
Jordan M.
Ordered a few slices on the slice app- which told us it would be 20-30 minutes. The restaurant called 5 min later to tell us our food was ready! Great experience picking up, felt safe and really really good pizza. Highly recommend !
The pizza is amazing!! Everyone was very friendly and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza Bianca for the win!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went there as it gave a retro feeling, but the look and feel of the place as well as the food was not good. The toppings are put sparingly if you get a fresh one made.
Ordered delivery, very quick service but our cheese pizza was oblong and underdone and the garlic knots were ironically burnt to a crisp. I'd be more than willing to wait longer for a pizza if it means it would be cooked all the way through. There's so many other better pizza joints in Paulus hook, don't bother
Wings are awful. Very dry, sauces taste like they’re from store bought bottles. Do not recommend.
Food: 1
Great slice, not too greasy and a good size for price.
Delicious pizza and amazing service. They went above what they needed to in order to seat our group of 9, plus made sure to let us know what they were working on to get fresh slices out. Really great spot!
Astonished of the aptitude of service and quality of the food. This order was a late night audible for dinner and they did not disappoint. Staff confirmed if I wanted grilled or breaded chicken with the calzone without me asking, very thoughtful. Will be back for more
Meat calzone was delicious. They did not skimp on the meat and cheese. The owner even threw in a free soda. Only bummer is that prices are a little steep for a pizza place.
TLDR; not worth the price and questionable service. We did a quick stop by this place just past 10pm on a Saturday. We didn't realize that the store closes at 10pm because their sign says "Open" and there are workers standing at the counter and smiling/saying nothing when we walk in. The person (older gentleman) then says, "we were just about to close but you can pay for a pie and we'll give you all the slices" (there are scattered slices of different pies, altogether about 1 pie worth). We declined politely as it was just us 2 looking for a snack, so we didn't want all that much food. Also not a great deal since they were probably going to throw it away anyways (*insert confused meme here*). He then pressured us asking, "what if you get hungry later?" Sometimes you gotta upsell, we get it. We decided to order a Stromboli and a slice of Sicilian. He rings us up for a Stromboli and 2 Sicilians. Luckily my fiancé caught it and asked him for just the one slice. Mayyyybe he just doesn't hear too well so he got the order wrong? Not sure. He then gives us the second slice "for free". However, the prices here are pretty steep and TBH we were disappointed in the quality. The Stromboli was not heated up well and it was too salty/greasy. The Sicilian was pretty small for the price. Good luck to this business, if they're struggling with the pandemic changes, but they may need to work on taking orders better!
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is consistently bad. I'd be happier with a 10/$10 Celeste pizza. Pizza is always undercooked and the bottom is always pale and dusted with raw flour. If you order a pie, you can easily make a whole other pizza by scraping the bottom flour off. Worse than public school cafeteria pizza. I wish my job would stop ordering for catering.
Ordered delivery on Slice: a medium cheese added roasted garlic, and the focaccia w/ eggplant, peppers, and mozz. What came was hilariously not that: it was a plain cheese pizza, and a side of garlic powder in a plastic cup The "focaccia" was a dollar roll; no mozz. Part of me was annoyed, the other part was like "this is on me for thinking an affordable joint would be fancy." The pizza was simple and fine, but I'm not going to order here again, even knowing what I know now.
Sigh. So I ordered/paid online for two Sicilian slices and cheese fries for pickup. I tracked on the app and it stated my order would be ready 10 mins. I was running about 20 mins late. When I got there, the woman at the front had no clue what Sicilian was and said they didn't have it. Instead they offered me three slices of plain. They took about 10-15 mins to make the order. I get back to my office to open the stapled shut bag to see the cheese fries ARE 2 CHEESE SLICES??? I'm hurt and confused. So FYI, don't get the cheese fries unless you want cheese slices. Also- the pizza was average. It was cold.
Ordered the meat Stromboli--almost inedible--tasted like it had been sitting out all day and was way too cheesy. The Hawaiian pie wasn't terrible, but literally came with 5 medium size chunks of pineapple and was EXTREMELY cheesy. Overall presentation was LACKING. Would not order from here again.
Ordered a few slices on the slice app- which told us it would be 20-30 minutes. The restaurant called 5 min later to tell us our food was ready! Great experience picking up, felt safe and really really good pizza. Highly recommend !