Tony's Pizza & Restaurant

300 NJ-35, Keyport
(732) 441-3444

Recent Reviews

Cheryl Stanke

We ordered a grandmas pizza today and we got a burnt pizza. We opened the box and realized it was burnt in the bottom and the edges. This is not the first time and we will NOT be ordering pizza from them again. These pies are not cheap and it’s like throwing our money away.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Dawn Handler

The food is delicious they just need more people to be on the register . As well people who answer the phones .

gerard galietti

Call and got a large pie half pepperoni $20 way overcooked not much to the call back told her it was said she would tell the guy thanks won't be going back 5 minutes from my house stop going a while ago now know why why not saying hey the next pizzas on us I wasn't looking for anything but that's the way to do it I won't be going back now I know why I stopped going

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Cars

The girl behind the counter is very very rude. Do to her childish behavior with us,we will not be returning!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Luisito Ch.c

There was something wrong with my pizza I call them and she told me that's how it supposed to be if there was anything else that they can help me She is so rude i when back to the store and switching pizza The guy who attend there really reasonable cool guy Shame on

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Patti Britt

Great food Great service

Gerard Timmons

Charged me $23 for large pie with half green peppers & sausage and other half pepperoni - pretty steep so may have to rethink if it worth going back to !I come to this area where I was brought every year for over 40 now and always look for nice place to eat as well as shop - but I definitely believe the young girl cashier made huge mistake figuring out final cost of a large pizza with a few toppings on only half of the pie no less !

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Chris Donnelly

Prices are higher than what are stated on their website they do not tell you if you pay with a credit there is an additional fee and the main counter person is not customer friendlyParking: Na

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza

Lisa Ferone

Excellent pizza and subs always order take out from them and their delivery is super fast!Parking: On the premises

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza

Micah Williams

I'm leaving this review because you need to have this Bringdat ordering app fixed. 1 it doesn't remember your address. 2 Lately when I try to pay with my credit card the delivery driver shows up asking for COD because it didn't take my payment. And when I ordered just a side order that I want to pick up myself, it still wants a $10 min even for a $8 item. Maybe you should just start using DoorDash.

diana vitale

Ppl...8f you are seriously looking for the old school delicious Brooklyn pizza, god this is the place, took me almost 5 years, many fails to find them.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Abner Sanchez

I love their buffalo pizza is great!!

A R

Placed an order for a half-tray of chicken the night before an event and the worker who took our order calls us up the next day as we're on our way to get it to let us know that he just realized that they didn't prepare our order correctly and that they'd need an extra half-hour we didn't have to get it done right. On top of that they use deceptive marketing with their coupons -- they have a coupon for $39.99 half-trays of chicken parm / francese / marsala that does not indicate that they include smaller portions of meat than when ordering from the full-price dinner menu. The person we spoke to didn't offer us anything for our troubles. Fortunately for us, good pizza spots are a dime-a-dozen around here.

Saradienne Gourgue

They have roaches. This place used to be my favorite until we saw a big roach inside the pizza. Ewww I couldn’t go back there.

P Zyg

2 pies....$37....but can't blame owners because the cost of everything is insane. Nice owners!

Load More

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant

300 NJ-35, Keyport, NJ 07735
(732) 441-3444