Little Silver Fish

123 Markham Pl, Little Silver
(732) 530-1123

Recent Reviews

Nicholas Homcy

Great fresh fish. The sushi grade tuna is always amazing

S Cal

This establishment clearly posted the following Thanksgiving holiday open time period on Google.Thursday Thanksgiving Holiday Times 10:30am-3:00pm.I called on the Monday before Thanksgiving to place a Thanksgiving order. I spoke with Eric. The first thing I asked him is if they were still taking orders for Thanksgiving day pick up? He said yes. I give him my order and confirmed that I would pick it up Thursday, Thanksgiving morning between 11-11:30am. He said that's fine.Now, it's Wednesday before Thanksgiving. I get a call at 3:55pm from a rude individual, with a serious attitude problem, asking me where I am, and if I'm picking up my order? I tried to explain that I was told they were open Thanksgiving morning and I was picking it up then. I barely got to say that while he was interrupting me saying they weren't open Thanksgiving. He said, that is a fact, and it's even listed as closed on the internet. Meanwhile as he's ignorantly speaking to me, I'm looking right at Google were it's listed as being open on Thanksgiving. No mention of "holiday hours may differ" for Thursday. Only for Friday after Thanksgiving. I run a business that is internet dependent. So I'm very aware how Google hours can vary according to holidays. This one was specific as to their Thanksgiving hours being open.They screwed up, their worker who took the order screwed up, and the caller continued his arrogant attitude and ignorant statements, instead of trying to resolve the matter as a smart businessman and considerate shop owner. Be careful when placing an order with this place. And be aware of attitude issues from the person that appears to "run the show."As for the quality of their food, I can't attest to that. But to advertise as a fresh seafood market and only have one size of cooked/cleaned shrimp available for the most recognized US based holiday of the year, is unusual.

Ryan F.

GROSS!The fish I picked up wasn't fresh. And the woman who worked there was deliberately coughing all over it without even covering her mouth. Idk what I did to deserve this, but it was almost comedic how unappetizing my experience was. 0/10 stars.

Peter W Miller

Terrific selections. Fair prices. Wonderful, helpful staff.

Janine Melillo

These people know how to run a business! Great food, efficient, clean, friendly & make you feel appreciated as a customer. The last point is so rare these days. Can't wait to go back on our next vacation!

Sabrina Reed

First time trying and definitely a new staple to our list of local businesses we will support regularly! Everything is top quality, fresh, and fairly priced. The business is clean, with a great variety of options. Prepared foods are outstanding and the staff is extremely friendly and generous. Thanks, Marissa, for the hospitality!

Jonathan Pepe

The owner was SO incredibly warm, welcoming, and helpful. Our steamers and ahi tuna were gorgeous-just so clean, fresh, and wonderfully flavorful. I can't say enough nice things about this store. We'll be back.

Regina Cappio Wilson

Great selection. Delicious quality!

William Dorsey

Great fresh fish market. Some items are cooked as well.

Liam Hayden

One of my favorite places to go when visiting friends in Little Silver or Red Bank area. The freshest of seafood and the friendliest of staff and owners. Crab cakes and shrimp salad are my favs!- -Sláinte,-Kristen and Liam Hayden

Duncan

I love fish & they have good fish!

David Schrader

Great local spot, fresh every time, highly recommend

John Paragano

Excellent fish market. Clean, friendly staff. Highly recommended!

Paolozzi Trucking LLC

Great selection and the workers were so nice and polite! Great prices and fresh seafood!

Joan Murphy

Overpriced! We were told one price over the phone $42.00 and then received a bill for $58.00. Bad Business practice, we will not be returning!

Load More