Super Duper Bagels

498 S Livingston Ave # 3, Livingston
(973) 533-1703

Recent Reviews

V James

Been coming here for 30 years. Best bagels around.

MariaCristina Garcia

Delicious Cream cheeses

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Person C

Nice having a local kosher bagel place nearby but the bagels are just ok. Because the turnover is low don't expect fresh warm bagels. I think they make 1 big batch early in the morning and then the bagels just sit there all day So good chance it will be cold and hard by the time you get there. Friendly owner though. Prices are a bit higher than other bagel stores.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Lawrence Bobrow

Very good bagels, friendly and quick service. Ample parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lox Cream Cheese Sandwich

Ann J.

I haven't been here in a while and I feel like their prices went up and portions went down. Ordered tuna salad on a bagel and surprised it was almost $10. Picked up the bag and it was super light in weight, opened to find the thinnest layer of tuna I have ever seen from a deli or bagel place. Not worth $10. Unfortunately bagel Noah or Ike's while being similar in pricing feels like more value for the money

Robert “Rob” Struck

Solid bagels and quality. Owner and staff are super friendly. Only complaint is that it’s small to eat in but overall very good.

Pat M.

I first tried stopping in at Super Duper Bagels a few weeks ago, but they were closed for Passover. This afternoon, I had the chance to return. This is a small shop, all takeout. There's a large selection of bagels and other baked goods. The woman working there told me that everything is baked fresh daily. The muffins looked really delicious. I ordered a plain bagel with vegetable cream cheese. Both the bagel and cream cheese were very good. Prices seemed a little high, but the quality was also high. I was concerned about parking since the lot is busy, but there are spaces reserved for the bagel store. A good bagel store that I'll give a thumbs up to!

Maury W.

We ordered platters for our mom's 90th birthday. Everything looked beautiful and tasted delicious. The Israeli salad was expertly prepared with dressing on the side so it didn't get soggy. The fruit salad was the best I've tasted: fresh, sweet with no additives. Our rabbi declared the bagels the best he's had! Just make sure that the invoice is correct and itemized.

Gene Sackman

Unfortunately there was no flavor in these bagels. I tried a poppy and everything bagel.

Nashe Dee

Bagel was absolutely delicious, lox is as fresh as it gets and the service was great! Yum ?

J Z

Overpriced and not really fresh bagels. Don’t know why there’re many good reviews, this place highly is overrated, and they don’t even have a menu with clearly listed prices!!!

loy

Bought two bagels, one with salmon one with tuna paste. Bagels are bit dry, salmon and tuna are not super either, taste just like regular bagels but cost $25. What’s more, the bagels are so small that we are still hungry. We ended up getting another pizza and garlic knots with soda across the street, which costs $11. Not sure why it is called Super Duper Bagels, maybe they missed “expensive” between “Duper” and “Bagels” lol

Elaine Denton

Good bagels that are the appropriate traditional size.

Daniel C.

First, their price is outrageous! $21 for dozen bagels!!! Their bagel is worse than Shop Rite bagel and their price is higher than NYC bagels. I definitely will not recommend this place.

Kimberly DeFilippo

Delicious bagels and fantastic service!

Load More