Attilio’s is a bit nostalgic. It reminds me of when my kids were young and we would grab a fast, hearty dinner before tennis during the week. The food is pretty good, I especially like the puttanesca sauce on rigatoni or their garlic and oil pasta.
The Sicilian slice goes so hard you have to get this slice when you come here. Dough is crispy but airy and not tough to chew. Sauce is top tier. Solid cheese & seasoning. 10/10 every slice is awesome.Their entrees are also incredible, juicy chicken, not over cooked, and the chicken murphy is over the top awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
R H
It wasn't what I expected. I ordered a cheese steak and it came wrong to me I didn't notice it until I bit it. It ended up having mayo on it. I called and told them that they messed up my order they told me to just come and they will make me a new one. After the new one was made they rang me up and told me I had to pay for the new one. I won't be going back to them so if I could give them no stars I would but I had to give one in order to leave a review
Nice, clean & spacious place. The only thing is Food is way to overpriced for the quality.Parking: It’s in a strip mall
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Nolan Lamson
Sunday at 9 when they close at 9:30 they cooked my pizza half as long as they should out of laziness. I went to a different pizza place right before this and they said they were closed even though it said they closed at 9:30… I live in a suburb in Denver and our restaurants close at 10 at the earliest. It’s peak season here in jersey and you can’t get a decent slice at 9:30 when we are an hour from NYC, pathetic. Pizza seems like it would be very good but it was look warm. This town is pathetic. Jersey, I know you can do better. Step it the F up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Gavin Eng
Great food. Specials are great ?And includes a salad.Good bread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
George Schults
Worst Floppy Pizza I ever had in my life ! And I ordered "Well Done" ! -10 on the one bite scale !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
JACOBO MOSQUERA
Crazy this place has 3.9 stars… one of the best slices of pizza I’ve had. 5/5
Leo P
The front desk Spanish dude with glasses must’ve been having a bad day and tbh he’s lucky I didn’t say anything and cause a scene because honestly if he don’t wanna work there don’t work there but don’t make people not want to come back into Atilios over a attitude because you hate your job!!!!!!
The Sicilian slice goes so hard you have to get this slice when you come here. Dough is crispy but airy and not tough to chew. Sauce is top tier. Solid cheese & seasoning. 10/10 every slice is awesome.
King T F.
Went to dine in and was served well after other people came after We did that was completely obvious and I'll never eat there again it's a shame people still have hatred for poc in the 21st century prior to that I would go there to eat almost every other weekend with my girl who's a life long resident of longbranch 30 plus years after we witnessed that kinda crap we decided never again go to atillios ever again we won't dine where we're not welcomed
Angel L.
I ordered the special cheesesteak that comes with onions, peppers, and mushrooms and let me tell you what a delight it was. Bread and steak hugged perfectly, cheese held it together like a perfect matrimony, toppings piled on just right -- ohh baby! Makes my taste buds water up just thinking of that night lol. I got a plain slice that was not to warm but it was tasty 100%. They don't take Apple Pay as of the last time I went but that wasn't an issue for me. Anyway go check it out they a staple in the neighborhood!! Peace and eats
Marc L.
Very good pizza. I ordered a hot peppers and mushroom pie and thoroughly enjoyed it. Sauce is not sweet, which made me extremely happy as many pizzerias have turned up the sugar lately. I can't stand when that happens. So a traditional pie was quite welcome for my taste buds. I would definitely order from Attilio's again in the future.
GAUTAM KHANNA
Nice vege pasta pizaOne should try thisBit expensive for just 1 slice at 4.40$ but its good
Attilio’s is a bit nostalgic. It reminds me of when my kids were young and we would grab a fast, hearty dinner before tennis during the week. The food is pretty good, I especially like the puttanesca sauce on rigatoni or their garlic and oil pasta.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Garlic Knots, Cold Antipasto Salad
The Sicilian slice goes so hard you have to get this slice when you come here. Dough is crispy but airy and not tough to chew. Sauce is top tier. Solid cheese & seasoning. 10/10 every slice is awesome.Their entrees are also incredible, juicy chicken, not over cooked, and the chicken murphy is over the top awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It wasn't what I expected. I ordered a cheese steak and it came wrong to me I didn't notice it until I bit it. It ended up having mayo on it. I called and told them that they messed up my order they told me to just come and they will make me a new one. After the new one was made they rang me up and told me I had to pay for the new one. I won't be going back to them so if I could give them no stars I would but I had to give one in order to leave a review
Atmosphere: 1
Excellent pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Cheese Steak Pizza
Nice, clean & spacious place. The only thing is Food is way to overpriced for the quality.Parking: It’s in a strip mall
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Sunday at 9 when they close at 9:30 they cooked my pizza half as long as they should out of laziness. I went to a different pizza place right before this and they said they were closed even though it said they closed at 9:30… I live in a suburb in Denver and our restaurants close at 10 at the earliest. It’s peak season here in jersey and you can’t get a decent slice at 9:30 when we are an hour from NYC, pathetic. Pizza seems like it would be very good but it was look warm. This town is pathetic. Jersey, I know you can do better. Step it the F up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Great food. Specials are great ?And includes a salad.Good bread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worst Floppy Pizza I ever had in my life ! And I ordered "Well Done" ! -10 on the one bite scale !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Crazy this place has 3.9 stars… one of the best slices of pizza I’ve had. 5/5
The front desk Spanish dude with glasses must’ve been having a bad day and tbh he’s lucky I didn’t say anything and cause a scene because honestly if he don’t wanna work there don’t work there but don’t make people not want to come back into Atilios over a attitude because you hate your job!!!!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
The Sicilian slice goes so hard you have to get this slice when you come here. Dough is crispy but airy and not tough to chew. Sauce is top tier. Solid cheese & seasoning. 10/10 every slice is awesome.
Went to dine in and was served well after other people came after We did that was completely obvious and I'll never eat there again it's a shame people still have hatred for poc in the 21st century prior to that I would go there to eat almost every other weekend with my girl who's a life long resident of longbranch 30 plus years after we witnessed that kinda crap we decided never again go to atillios ever again we won't dine where we're not welcomed
I ordered the special cheesesteak that comes with onions, peppers, and mushrooms and let me tell you what a delight it was. Bread and steak hugged perfectly, cheese held it together like a perfect matrimony, toppings piled on just right -- ohh baby! Makes my taste buds water up just thinking of that night lol. I got a plain slice that was not to warm but it was tasty 100%. They don't take Apple Pay as of the last time I went but that wasn't an issue for me. Anyway go check it out they a staple in the neighborhood!! Peace and eats
Very good pizza. I ordered a hot peppers and mushroom pie and thoroughly enjoyed it. Sauce is not sweet, which made me extremely happy as many pizzerias have turned up the sugar lately. I can't stand when that happens. So a traditional pie was quite welcome for my taste buds. I would definitely order from Attilio's again in the future.
Nice vege pasta pizaOne should try thisBit expensive for just 1 slice at 4.40$ but its good