I enjoy chicken lemon w/orzo soup with the Katie's salad and the bread sticks. Staff is very friendly and polite. My only feedback to the restaurant is related to the condition of the restaurant. The plants in the front need some TLC and there is some hanging wiring that doesn't look good on my last visit I felt that the decorative aspect of the restaurant has deteriorated significantly and it is no longer attractive. Please consider some upgrade.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
chris n
The worst Italian food I've had in Long Branch. The alfredo sauce tasted like onion dip and the tomato sauce had absolutely no flavor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Ashley Jose
One of the best pizza’s I’ve had !
Food: 5
Service: 5
jenniferhX6030ZQ
We have been to lezamas many times and order pizza and apps from them every week. We usually have a great experience but it’s really gone down hill recently. The last two times we were there I ordered meals with chicken and forgot the chicken so I had to wait for the chicken and then the meal was cold… tonight we weren’t offered bread we weren’t asked if we needed anything else we were overcharged for something and my husbands meal came without a menu item. We had to get up and get the waitress multiple times who was on her phone. I literally spend $40/week or more at the restaurant so I’m a little annoyed tonight. In addition we were the only people in the entire restaurant so it wasn’t like the waitress was frazzled or overworked.
Jeff Pape
Only gave 4 stars for atmosphere because we always pick up or use delivery, so that may not be fair. Always looks clean. Great pizza! The food shows they really pay attention to detail. Every slice is consistent. Toppings are distributed perfectly evenly. You have to try the big pie. It will never disappoint.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paola Juarez
Worst place ! do yourself a favor and stay away. there was a whole hair in my pizza !!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pritesh Shah
A classic downtown pizzeria with probably one of the best Margarita Pizza I've ever had. We went there recently for dinner on a Sunday night after a beach outing nearby. The ambience is welcoming and they have seating space for may be about 30-40 people. Not too big but spacious enough to enjoy a nice dinner. The margarita pizza that we ate was really flavorful with bursting flavors of fresh tomato sauce with basil and of course mozzarella cheese. The crust was just perfect too. Our server Carolina was super busy but had a smile on her face at all times.I would say, this place is worth a visit even if you are not that close.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jasen Kaplan
Not only are they friendly and fast but my food was INCREDIBLE!! Amazing eggplant parm!! It even came with tasty crispy fries!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roland B
We have ordered from Lezama’s in the past and the food has been good. After today’s experience, we will not be ordering again. Everything went well when placing my order. It went downhill with the delivery guy. First, he quoted me a price that was $8 higher than what I was told on the phone and from was on the printed receipt. I corrected him and showed him the receipt was stapled to the food bag. He did not say anything further. I paid him the correct amount and still tipped him very generously. When I got inside and opened the bag, I realized that one of the items was wrong (the sandwich contained mushrooms and I am very allergic to mushooms). The sandwich I ordered did not come with mushrooms and I was clear with my order. I called and the person who answered the phone readily admitted their mistake and said we would have a replacement in 15 minutes. He did not offer to replace the pizza we had also ordered that would be cold by the time the replacement sandwich arrived. Additionally, the sandwich I ordered was less expensive than the sandwich I was given and paid for. I told my family go ahead and eat the pizza because it would get cold if they waited for me to get my sandwich. My family finished the pizza. I discarded the empty pizza box along with the sandwich. After an hour of waiting, i gave up on ever getting my sandwich. Eventually, I got a call on my cell phone. The delivery guy said he had the new sandwich but would not give it to me until I gave him back the wrong sandwich. That wrong sandwich was already in a garbage bag and already put down the garbage chute along with the empty pizza box. The person on the phone that I spoke to never said that I needed to retain the wrong sandwich. The delivery guy would not give me my food even though it was already paid for. Overall, this was terrible service and poor customer treatment. I should not have been subjected to an attempt to cheat me by the delivery guy, being overcharged for the wrong food, and never getting my food that I already paid for. Lezama’s took my money but I never got my food.
xeni vz
Amazing pizza!! Not too greasy and thin-crust makes it tasty and amazingly good!!! really impressed!! Thank you? we ordered their new Pizza on the menu and the Margherita!
I enjoy your Italian subs quite a bit, probably going to order one right now, always feels like a bang for my buck because of the fries you give. Which are usually crispy and good most of the time but they're crinkle cut so I'm not knocking you.I'll have to try some other stuff soon, I'm just addicted to Italian subs. Ily
Alan Ch
I ordered a slice of Peperoni pizza for my daughter ( toddler) my wife took a piece of Peperoni and the Peperoni came with a stapple in it … we throw that slice of pizza … just be careful when u order from this place
Mel B.
The Brooklyn square thin crust pizza is incredible and all the soups too. I always get delivery here and they're always prompt and friendly. Highly recommend!
Madeline Castro
Last night I came with some friends for dinner. We always received the best service on the weekends when we’ve come here in the past, but last night, the service wasn’t exceptional as always. It was a different waitress than normal and she seemed overwhelmed and slow. After about 20 minutes, I saw our normal waitress come out to help with a few tables. Her tables got their food before we got ours. Hopefully this new waitress isn’t a regular on Friday night, otherwise we will have to dine elsewhere.
Tom H.
Had a Marguerita pie. Great thin crust pizza. My son had the Chicken Scarparelli which he said was tender and "out of this world"! Friendly wait staff. A MUST TRY.....
I enjoy chicken lemon w/orzo soup with the Katie's salad and the bread sticks. Staff is very friendly and polite. My only feedback to the restaurant is related to the condition of the restaurant. The plants in the front need some TLC and there is some hanging wiring that doesn't look good on my last visit I felt that the decorative aspect of the restaurant has deteriorated significantly and it is no longer attractive. Please consider some upgrade.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
The worst Italian food I've had in Long Branch. The alfredo sauce tasted like onion dip and the tomato sauce had absolutely no flavor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
One of the best pizza’s I’ve had !
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been to lezamas many times and order pizza and apps from them every week. We usually have a great experience but it’s really gone down hill recently. The last two times we were there I ordered meals with chicken and forgot the chicken so I had to wait for the chicken and then the meal was cold… tonight we weren’t offered bread we weren’t asked if we needed anything else we were overcharged for something and my husbands meal came without a menu item. We had to get up and get the waitress multiple times who was on her phone. I literally spend $40/week or more at the restaurant so I’m a little annoyed tonight. In addition we were the only people in the entire restaurant so it wasn’t like the waitress was frazzled or overworked.
Only gave 4 stars for atmosphere because we always pick up or use delivery, so that may not be fair. Always looks clean. Great pizza! The food shows they really pay attention to detail. Every slice is consistent. Toppings are distributed perfectly evenly. You have to try the big pie. It will never disappoint.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worst place ! do yourself a favor and stay away. there was a whole hair in my pizza !!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
A classic downtown pizzeria with probably one of the best Margarita Pizza I've ever had. We went there recently for dinner on a Sunday night after a beach outing nearby. The ambience is welcoming and they have seating space for may be about 30-40 people. Not too big but spacious enough to enjoy a nice dinner. The margarita pizza that we ate was really flavorful with bursting flavors of fresh tomato sauce with basil and of course mozzarella cheese. The crust was just perfect too. Our server Carolina was super busy but had a smile on her face at all times.I would say, this place is worth a visit even if you are not that close.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not only are they friendly and fast but my food was INCREDIBLE!! Amazing eggplant parm!! It even came with tasty crispy fries!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have ordered from Lezama’s in the past and the food has been good. After today’s experience, we will not be ordering again. Everything went well when placing my order. It went downhill with the delivery guy. First, he quoted me a price that was $8 higher than what I was told on the phone and from was on the printed receipt. I corrected him and showed him the receipt was stapled to the food bag. He did not say anything further. I paid him the correct amount and still tipped him very generously. When I got inside and opened the bag, I realized that one of the items was wrong (the sandwich contained mushrooms and I am very allergic to mushooms). The sandwich I ordered did not come with mushrooms and I was clear with my order. I called and the person who answered the phone readily admitted their mistake and said we would have a replacement in 15 minutes. He did not offer to replace the pizza we had also ordered that would be cold by the time the replacement sandwich arrived. Additionally, the sandwich I ordered was less expensive than the sandwich I was given and paid for. I told my family go ahead and eat the pizza because it would get cold if they waited for me to get my sandwich. My family finished the pizza. I discarded the empty pizza box along with the sandwich. After an hour of waiting, i gave up on ever getting my sandwich. Eventually, I got a call on my cell phone. The delivery guy said he had the new sandwich but would not give it to me until I gave him back the wrong sandwich. That wrong sandwich was already in a garbage bag and already put down the garbage chute along with the empty pizza box. The person on the phone that I spoke to never said that I needed to retain the wrong sandwich. The delivery guy would not give me my food even though it was already paid for. Overall, this was terrible service and poor customer treatment. I should not have been subjected to an attempt to cheat me by the delivery guy, being overcharged for the wrong food, and never getting my food that I already paid for. Lezama’s took my money but I never got my food.
Amazing pizza!! Not too greasy and thin-crust makes it tasty and amazingly good!!! really impressed!! Thank you? we ordered their new Pizza on the menu and the Margherita!
Restaurantji Recommends
I enjoy your Italian subs quite a bit, probably going to order one right now, always feels like a bang for my buck because of the fries you give. Which are usually crispy and good most of the time but they're crinkle cut so I'm not knocking you.I'll have to try some other stuff soon, I'm just addicted to Italian subs. Ily
I ordered a slice of Peperoni pizza for my daughter ( toddler) my wife took a piece of Peperoni and the Peperoni came with a stapple in it … we throw that slice of pizza … just be careful when u order from this place
The Brooklyn square thin crust pizza is incredible and all the soups too. I always get delivery here and they're always prompt and friendly. Highly recommend!
Last night I came with some friends for dinner. We always received the best service on the weekends when we’ve come here in the past, but last night, the service wasn’t exceptional as always. It was a different waitress than normal and she seemed overwhelmed and slow. After about 20 minutes, I saw our normal waitress come out to help with a few tables. Her tables got their food before we got ours. Hopefully this new waitress isn’t a regular on Friday night, otherwise we will have to dine elsewhere.
Had a Marguerita pie. Great thin crust pizza. My son had the Chicken Scarparelli which he said was tender and "out of this world"! Friendly wait staff. A MUST TRY.....