Been here twice. The first time, we got bottom of the barrel slices that seemed to be from the day before. Second time, we went to order some specialty pies, and they told us they ran out of cheese (5:30pm on a Saturday night). Maybe the 3rd time will be a charm, but I doubt it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Kay S.
I went here about 2 weeks ago and that's my fault for going when season is dead. It was empty but I got a hot sub and slice of pizza and drink. Bread was stale, chicken tasted old, pizza couldn't have been worse dry and tastes like it had been sitting out all day. Drink was also horrible. Avoid it when it's not busy summer season.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Ameer Payton
Best pizza in Long Branch! We've been coming here for years, food is always hot and ready before we pickup. Danny always has a great attitude and makes sure our food is top quality!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Fries, Plain, Classic Cheese Pizza
Thaddeus K.
What a waste of time. No one picks up the phone, which would have me not making the trip to Pier Village. Wanted to bring their Cheesesteak Ole to a friend for lunch. Drove there, and they told me that there's a new menu coming out the following week and that they'd be only selling pizza from now on. I've had TB's Cheesesteak in AC countless times as well as one time in Hoboken. What gives here? Incompetent staff for one. And I can only presume that they can't handle a menu beyond that of pizza. Speaking of which I had a slice recently and it's subpar and expensive. The Long Branch location is a losing proposition for management with high rent and low sales. Once summer ends what are you going to do to get through the winter? There's so much better around - Sea Bright Pizza, Gigis, Nunzio's, Scalas. I'll never walk into this place again. Sucky service, pizza that's been sitting a day or 2 and no signature dish - their Cheesesteak Ole.
Mike M.
This place has gradually gotten worse over the years. Not sure if the original owners sold it , but the sandwich's are not good. I hate leaving a bad review but I have a hard time believing the original tony boloney owners would be ok with how bad they've gotten at this location
markymarkao1
I understand there were a lot of people and the staff were a bit overwhelmed for Labor Day but there is no need to be rude to your customers. They had a sign up that said that they were closed until 430 & I simply wanted to ask a question in regards to ordering a Taco Pie since I know it takes awhile to make & I was basically kicked out and told they were closed until 430 from there I placed an order on the app & was called in the store before it reopened. If I wasn't there with my my family who was looking forward to trying out this pie which cost over $100 I would have left & took my business elsewhere.
Jon Y.
If you're hungry, it's pizza, it fills you up, any other time you would be disappointed- mission accomplished
Stephen G.
Pizza is waaayyy overpriced. They're too concerned with having a billion toppings options instead of just getting it right from the beginning. They only take cards, not cash, which was an inconvenience for me. Service was not that friendly and the only available table was dirty. Would never return or recommend to anyone!
Stephen Mourad
food wasn’t good, service was terrible, waited 25 minutes for a single slice of pizza, and way
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lydia Walsh
They don’t know how to even reheat their own slices. Guy kept my (expensive) slice in the oven for like a couple minutes. Dead cold and soggy when I went to go eat it. Pointless.
All I can say is! If you can get $9.00 for a slice with a line out the door! God bless you! I must say I had the slice with the word F-in in the name, I forgot the name. It wasn't bad! Worth the 9 bucks?? Maybe 6.
Meaghan G.
$15 for 3 burnt chicken fingers and I didn't even order a drink. The girl at the counter rolled her eyes when I checked on my order (after waiting 30 minutes). It sat under the heat lamps in the back for 25 minutes. All of my chicken was burnt inside and out. The place was not busy enough for this to happen. Certainly not impressed, nor will I be suggesting this place to anyone else. This place does not deserve any stars.
Preeti J.
Very yumm pizzas I m hunger of vegetarian options . They had so many and all tasted delicious. We had 1) cheese 2) max corn3) moonshiner The drinks were interesting too. . Totally recommend
Natasha L.
Last time I ordered online, my order was cancelled after an hour because they never started making it. He same thing happened just now. No one ever started making my order and two Dashers dropped the order. An hour passed before I could cancel the order.
Brittany Erickson
Read the reviews before you go to this place!!! I wish I did. Every bad review says the same thing for a reason. The manager has a terrible attitude, you order food off their menu annd they literally have no idea of what they sell. They told me they don’t offer what I ordered.. Also they’ll be out of an topping and assume you were supposed to know they were out of the product. They’ll still charge you for it though..A refund or an apology wasn’t offered. Just dirty looks.I have two stars because the pizza I did get wasn’t bad. But the service and over paying was.
Been here twice. The first time, we got bottom of the barrel slices that seemed to be from the day before. Second time, we went to order some specialty pies, and they told us they ran out of cheese (5:30pm on a Saturday night). Maybe the 3rd time will be a charm, but I doubt it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
I went here about 2 weeks ago and that's my fault for going when season is dead. It was empty but I got a hot sub and slice of pizza and drink. Bread was stale, chicken tasted old, pizza couldn't have been worse dry and tastes like it had been sitting out all day. Drink was also horrible. Avoid it when it's not busy summer season.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Best pizza in Long Branch! We've been coming here for years, food is always hot and ready before we pickup. Danny always has a great attitude and makes sure our food is top quality!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Fries, Plain, Classic Cheese Pizza
What a waste of time. No one picks up the phone, which would have me not making the trip to Pier Village. Wanted to bring their Cheesesteak Ole to a friend for lunch. Drove there, and they told me that there's a new menu coming out the following week and that they'd be only selling pizza from now on. I've had TB's Cheesesteak in AC countless times as well as one time in Hoboken. What gives here? Incompetent staff for one. And I can only presume that they can't handle a menu beyond that of pizza. Speaking of which I had a slice recently and it's subpar and expensive. The Long Branch location is a losing proposition for management with high rent and low sales. Once summer ends what are you going to do to get through the winter? There's so much better around - Sea Bright Pizza, Gigis, Nunzio's, Scalas. I'll never walk into this place again. Sucky service, pizza that's been sitting a day or 2 and no signature dish - their Cheesesteak Ole.
This place has gradually gotten worse over the years. Not sure if the original owners sold it , but the sandwich's are not good. I hate leaving a bad review but I have a hard time believing the original tony boloney owners would be ok with how bad they've gotten at this location
I understand there were a lot of people and the staff were a bit overwhelmed for Labor Day but there is no need to be rude to your customers. They had a sign up that said that they were closed until 430 & I simply wanted to ask a question in regards to ordering a Taco Pie since I know it takes awhile to make & I was basically kicked out and told they were closed until 430 from there I placed an order on the app & was called in the store before it reopened. If I wasn't there with my my family who was looking forward to trying out this pie which cost over $100 I would have left & took my business elsewhere.
If you're hungry, it's pizza, it fills you up, any other time you would be disappointed- mission accomplished
Pizza is waaayyy overpriced. They're too concerned with having a billion toppings options instead of just getting it right from the beginning. They only take cards, not cash, which was an inconvenience for me. Service was not that friendly and the only available table was dirty. Would never return or recommend to anyone!
food wasn’t good, service was terrible, waited 25 minutes for a single slice of pizza, and way
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
They don’t know how to even reheat their own slices. Guy kept my (expensive) slice in the oven for like a couple minutes. Dead cold and soggy when I went to go eat it. Pointless.
Food: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
All I can say is! If you can get $9.00 for a slice with a line out the door! God bless you! I must say I had the slice with the word F-in in the name, I forgot the name. It wasn't bad! Worth the 9 bucks?? Maybe 6.
$15 for 3 burnt chicken fingers and I didn't even order a drink. The girl at the counter rolled her eyes when I checked on my order (after waiting 30 minutes). It sat under the heat lamps in the back for 25 minutes. All of my chicken was burnt inside and out. The place was not busy enough for this to happen. Certainly not impressed, nor will I be suggesting this place to anyone else. This place does not deserve any stars.
Very yumm pizzas I m hunger of vegetarian options . They had so many and all tasted delicious. We had 1) cheese 2) max corn3) moonshiner The drinks were interesting too. . Totally recommend
Last time I ordered online, my order was cancelled after an hour because they never started making it. He same thing happened just now. No one ever started making my order and two Dashers dropped the order. An hour passed before I could cancel the order.
Read the reviews before you go to this place!!! I wish I did. Every bad review says the same thing for a reason. The manager has a terrible attitude, you order food off their menu annd they literally have no idea of what they sell. They told me they don’t offer what I ordered.. Also they’ll be out of an topping and assume you were supposed to know they were out of the product. They’ll still charge you for it though..A refund or an apology wasn’t offered. Just dirty looks.I have two stars because the pizza I did get wasn’t bad. But the service and over paying was.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: O G Vegan Pizza