The Prospect Tavern

14 Prospect St, Madison
(973) 295-6255

Recent Reviews

Joseph De Los Santos

Gotta admit I had very slow service and I was hoping for idk something better for the French opinion soup. So was having a bummer time. But this burger is the bomb. For real so freaking good. Great medium. And the fries tbh looking small portion. But that bite omg wow. Get the burgers and fries here. No lie delicious. Get that brownie at the end. Solid comes with ice cream.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Maven Kouture

Better than what I expected the food was definitely delicious the French onion was superb. The drinks were definitely good. No I did not ask for my espresso martini but I was pleasantly delighted with the offerings they had. Service was good, our waiter was attentive and accommodating. If only they could had made me a Patty melt that would have been even better...ooh wellz til the next venture. Oooh and the fries were great .

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jennifer Hapke

I used to come to the Tavern almost every weekend! We had some great food there and even better party nights :)Sadly i moved back to germany so i wont be able to go there as much as I used to :

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Victor Schilling

Went to have some beers with some friends, sat outside because it was sunny. Staff very attentive and helpful to have us well served.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

John Cooper

I'm former law enforcement and also a Chef. The Service was absolutely horrendous and this came directly from the owner herself Carol. The attitude she displays towards customers is pathetic and insulting. She doesn't know how to communicate properly towards the customers like myself who had a terrible experience firsthand with her. Not only is the food terrible so is the atmosphere. I blame this solely on the nastiness of the owner herself Carol. She'll never get another dime from me or anybody I know.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Karan Sethi

Fun environment and good service. The Cajun sandwich is a good try.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeffrey H.

Perfect place for informal meal. Attentive service, good pub style food. Capable of handling large parties.

James Tancredi

Enjoyed a nice

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Justyna B.

Cool bar, no complaints. We were here on a Tuesday night for trivia and it was a lot of fun! Our bartender was very nice. I got the French onion soup and it was really tasty. A lot of cheese which I love.

George L

Karaoke on Friday nights!

George L

Outdoor Seating and Karaoke

Jenna S.

Came here for lunch with my family. It was terrible from the beginning to the end. The place smells like the floral disinfectant they use. My son got the Mac and cheese which we sent back because it was dripping in oil. My husband got the Ruben and without exaggeration, he could not bite through the corned beef. This place has clearly gone down hill and I will never return

Caitlin F.

This is the perfect place to get some good food and casual drinks. The servers and bartenders are always super friendly to top it off. The shrimp tacos are awesome and the elderflower fizz is a must. Perfect after work drink spot.

N A

loooooove this place. was here last night n the bartender was on it! food was great. drinks awesome. and service was quick n friendly. will def be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

John C. Fusi

Nice local pub. Great service. Inspired chef. Reasonable prices. Definitely a winning combination. Only downside...indoors it can be a little loud.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pork Dumplings, Tavern Burger

Load More