Agnello's Cafe

657 E Bay Ave Unit 2, Manahawkin
(609) 207-6491

Recent Reviews

Jo L

Wow! Best latte in the area and that's a strong claim! Strong presence of flavor in the coffee customizations and all the sandwiches, well presented on fresh sourdough. Order bread online, stop in for a turmeric latte or mushroom coffee and kick off your day right with this positive vibe and fresh atmosphere!Parking: Full parking lot. Warm Saturday mornings will have some congestion w Flea Market but that live-music vibe is cool time to go.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs and wide doors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Avocado Toast, Mud wtr, The Cheech, Smoked Salmon Toast

k Shepp

My new favorite hot spot for coffee done perfectly!! Staff super friendly !!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Victoria Duprey

Bangin’ cappuccino and some great products on their shelves too like Wooden Spoon Herbs! The real deal, will definitely be going back!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Ed B

Great food, with very quick service. Clean and organized interior.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeanne M.

Truly delish food. Great atmosphere unique breads , great coffee , perfect place for meeting a friend for a good cuppa Joe, Check online for their menu .

Patricia Henry

Stopped by for a coffee today as it was recommended by a friend and I’m no longer local. I had the honey hazelnut shaken iced espresso. When I told the barista I didn’t like my drinks too sweet, she made it perfectly. She was very nice and helpful as well. Although I didn’t get any of their retail items, the brands and ingredient based items they carry are on the “healthier” side if you try to avoid excess chemicals like I do. These offerings suggested to me that the owners actually care about what they’re putting in their customers bodies. I’ll be back next time I’m in town.

Kate P

Amazing coffee and even better food! Our new go to as we are happy to finally have a great coffee shop on the mainland!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Avocado Toast

Kelly A.

So relieved to finally find good coffee without going to the island and waiting in line for 30+ mins. Agnellos keeps it simple with a small menu & fresh ingredients, and the staff is super friendly. Hoping they do well and continue to focus on quality over quantity.

Rachel Makowski

Recently went here for coffee and they were great! I put a 4 for food since we didn’t get any food, but next time I definitely want to try the ricotta toast!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Ema Croj

There are truly no words that can describe just how incredible Matt Agnello (owner) is. Genuinely such a good person and the nicest man I’ve ever met. The manahawkin shop is a beautiful place with amazing food as well. 5 stars isn’t enough to give to this place, they deserve more . Highly HIGHLY reccomend Agnellos!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Honey Butter Toast

Branden DeOliveira

This is a nice little new cafe in the strip across from the Manahawkin Plaza. The cafe is facing the street (not the parking lot). The ladies behind the counter were very friendly and welcoming. Service was good also (it's not fast food or premade so don't expect to walk in and out in 2 minutes but the atmosphere is nice and relaxing). I had the ricotta toast and pistachio vanilla latte (both are recommended!). There is limited seeing inside and also a handful of outdoor tables and chairs (with umbrellas). I also went with a group of 6 others and everyone enjoyed their toasts/sandwiches and beverages. I recommend giving it a try if you want some fresh bread and flavorful lattes.Vegetarian options: Many optionsParking: Ample parking in lot behind the building

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Avocado Toast

Denise Z.

Welcome to the neighborhood! What a great addition to our shore area! This place is adorable and clean. We got greeted by the owner and the girl working behind the register.So when you go there they have touch screens to order, very modern.They had a great variety of tea's, Mocha,and coffee's.We placed our order and the owner gave us a loaf of his delicious sour dough bread to try and it was amazing and extremely kind of him.My daughter and husband ordered the turkey (Gardenia) sandwich on focasia sour dough you can choose your breads from bagels and all varieties.The turkey and everything on the sandwich was quality, tasted like Boar's Head or better.I enjoy the tuna with cheese also fresh wasn't fishy or too mayonnaisey.My son had the lox and he thoroughly enjoyed it in a minute! I can't wait to go again!!

Jill L.

avocado toast was great! Loved the pickled onions and hot pepper flakes. Would definitely recommend trying it out

Angelo Christiano

Tired of lame food in the area? Come here! Outstanding variety of healthy choices. Easy to order and extremely friendly. If this place was open at 5pm or 6pm I would go at least 2-3 times more. Bread is awesome. Breakfrast flat breads are all perfect texture and taste.

Steve Derion

The owner, Matthew is incredibly welcoming and positive, and the food is amazing. One of the best sandwiches I've had, period. Can't wait to be back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Cheech

Load More