Round Pie Pizza Company

1124 NJ-34, Matawan
(732) 582-0000

Recent Reviews

Jenn

Delicious and crunchy. Love the vodka and margarita pies. So thin! The staff was so welcoming and sweet!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mario Barakat

Best all around cheesesteak thin crust pie and absolutely delicious had it several

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Signature Round Pie

Patrick Cronin

Round Pie is a standout even in an area with several fantastic spots within a mile or so. The Signature Round Pie is the way to go! Pizza is thin, crispy, and tasty!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Max W

Since its a pizza shop, the 4 stars will reflect the pizzaThe 17” signature pizza was really good! Wish it was in the oven for a bit longer.. 8.5/10Buffalo chicken wrap was ok 6/10Jalapeño poppers were ok 5/10The buffalo wings was a no go.. most are pinky sized and dry.. since its so small i guess it gets over fried easily 2/10Stick to the pizza!

Marco Galiano

Amazing pizza. Best tasting pizza in the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pesto Pizza, Stromboli, Buffalo, Hot Honey Roni, Chicken Parm

Anthony Cuchetto

Good tunes. Quiet place to eat. Big slices. Every pie on the shelf looks delicious. Pricing is

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joel Yaccarino

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Rivera

Waited way too long for my order.

Sreeni Herugu

Best pizza in the area!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Signature Round Pie, Margherita, Pesto Slice

Rob M.

If you get the pizza upgrade to signature pie. While more money it's worth it because it tastes much better! All the pies are excellent. And, the non pizza dishes are good as well. Easy to order on the app and pick up efficient.

Jim H.

Absolutely the worst service ever! I went today to pick up an order for around $100 worth of food and the employee Mia who was working the register just completely ignored me while she answered multiple calls for orders. She left me standing there while my order was getting cold. Eager to bring warm food back home to my family I finally interrupted her when she was about to take another call interacting with another employee all the while continuing to ignore me so I simply and politely asked her if she could just turn around and grab my order for me before she does anything else. Instead she gave me a total passive aggressive better than thou attitude scolding me for interrupting her telling me I put the person on hold acting like how dare I interrupt her from taking another phone call. I have been going there for years without a single incident however if this is how they treat loyal customers I would rather give my business to deninos across the street! This is the problem with family business the younger generation get entitled and think they are better than everyone because their older family members put in all of the hard work and they younger generation does not know what respect and hard work is! It was a bad business decision to leave this store in her hands as there were zero adults there to manage the normal flow of business and customers. So after we exchanged some additional dialogue I voiced my resentment that I will now be bringing cold food home to my family she continued to be disrespectful all I wanted her to say was sorry hold on a second instead of just totally ignoring me for something so simple as a ten seconds or less transaction as my order was pre paid! In the end I came home with cold food as this took easily 8-15 minutes from start to finish and I was so upset I didn't even bother to eat my meal definitely not how you should treat a good customer who has been going to this location since the first day the opened always tipping well and ordering for my business and family members and friends! I will be sure to share this experience with everyone I know as often I am asked what is good in this neighborhood I use to recommend round pie now I will be forced to make other recommendations. It's sad really that the manager felt it was ok to leave a bunch of children to run the business on a weekend.

John Powers

We enjoy takeout pizza, Ceasars salad and fried zuchini sticks and have had great experiences. Atmosphere inside is not a priority and ok for a quick bite.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bod W.

very rude staff, and very long wait... wish they work on custome service. I would no recommend coming here

Diana Hernandez

The Hot Honey Roni and Buffalo Wings with the garlic parm side sauce were delicious! The Nutella Filled Zeppoli were so good, as well and generously filled with nutella! I also love the chicken cesar wrap with french fries. I order this at least once a month lol..Both pick up and delivery have been great experiences. Friendly staff!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo

Vanessa W.

The pizza is amazing with its thin crispy crust and the wraps are stuffed and delicious. I am always recommending this place to people.

Load More