Anna Lee's Cookies and Cream

800 NJ-50 E1, Mays Landing
(609) 450-1160

Recent Reviews

The gem Stormtrooper

Love their ice cream! Just ordered a ice cream cake for my son's 14th and it was a hit! The crowd is very picky about their ice cream I might add!

Debbie Martone

Just found this spot last night. The owners are super friendly and extremely client-focused. The place was clean and cheerful. The ice cream was amazing! My husband had the strawberry and said it was probably the best he's ever had. We couldn't leave without some other sweet treats as well! We will definitely be going back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jana Ferrari

I love this place! Had the best peanut butter hot fudge Sundae. My dad got a strawberry milkshake and he has asked to go back everyday since. All their ice cream is homemade and they even have fresh baked cookies and coffee. We will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies, Hot Fudge, Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich, Peanut Butter Lovers Sundae

Matt Spry

Just discovered this place tonight! The owners were fantastic, prices were very reasonable, and the donuts and ice cream were delicious. Plus, they were open till 7 which is a rare find in this area! We can’t wait to come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sio Gon

Clean! Favorable Variety of Deliciousness to Satisfy any Sweet Tooth!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

David Aponte

Never had a banana split in a cup, very uncomfortable. By the time I reached the brim half of it had fallen on the table. It was impossible not to have some drain down the cup making quite a mess. The ice cream was good but again, I like to choose the flavors I mix patiently, not feel forced to eat the pine apple on top before I get to the 2 inches of lonely chocolate in the bottom.The service was ok, not much of a smile at all but ok. Definitely not worth a 12 dollar split banana in a cup.

Michael Guerro

Awesome place cool atmosphere coffee shop, bakery, ice cream parlor all in one and amazing ice cream.

Pete Bender Sr

Great ice cream along with buns and cookies. The owners are very friendly and nice to talk to.

Yury Tsygutkin

Very extensive variety of ice cream and cookies.Serving legendary Bassetts ice cream.Absolutely delicious and must try !Excellent staff !Thank you !

Deborah G

Anna is very friendly, and they have great ice cream flavors. That other ice cream stands don't have.

Kara Zatina

The best donut I’ve eaten in my entire life. Would recommend!

ChoochMom

Nicest owners in the world!! Found this bakery/ice cream parlor on Google maps reviews: and they’re correct. Purchased homemade doughnuts and an ice cream cake (Rocky Road ?). The owner decorated the top of the cake fresh while I waited. All customizable. Top quality and delicious; but the customer service makes it that much sweeter! ?

Serrano Family ocnj

Got a icecream cake for my daughter's 14th birthday. Absolutely amazing!!! Everyone loved it. This will be my cake spot from now on. The owner is really nice and helpful!

Donna X.

Last week was my first visit to Anna Lee's in Mayslanding. I heard they made custom ice cream cakes And had good quality ice cream, beautiful deserts and for the early bird they have gourmet coffee, tons of designer drinks, amazing donuts, muffins , danish and cookies. I had to try them but which one? I showed some restraint and with the help of Anna placed my order for my sons cake. Anyone who goes in will be flooded with sensory overload in the best possible way. I seriously couldn't decide so I picked three flavors to bring home for us to try. I was supposed to pick up the cake on Sunday and was reminded by a phone call from the owner Rebecca. I asked if I could pick it up the following day since I was suffering with a migraine and she explained that they were closed but if I knew what time I wanted to pick it up, her husband Fred will come down and open the shop just so I can pick up my cake. I couldn't believe what a kind and selfless offer. I really appreciated the offer, but I told him I would be in Tuesday and I hope that they enjoyed their day off.Anna Lee's is Veteran/ family owned and operated. It definitely has that family friendly feeling for everyone who comes through the door. You are immediately greeted with a smile and pleasantry from one of the owners.This is the kinda place you go to when you want to do something special for the kids after dinner, a game , a good report card , date night desert after dinner or just because. They will make you feel like old friends within the first few minutes. This is my new favorite go to place. I hope you make it yours. You wont regret it. Thank you, Anna Lee, Rebecca and Fred ! Look forward to our next visit.

frank Brown

Typical ice cream/sweet shop. I see they serve Bassett's ice cream of which I am not a fan. Not too many choices for cake/pastry. What was there looked fresh and tasty. What changed my mind was a couple of fruit flies that came buzzing by. ..I can't deal with bugs.

Load More