Updating my 5 star review since this business stopped filling the cupcakes. Cake is dry and still the same price for less product.
Caroline F.
These cupcakes are absolutely delicious and the owner is such a sweet lady! Amazing service and quality
Katy Ciampa
Cupcakes were very tasty. Not like the commercial cupcakes you get at stores but about the same size. Limited hours.
T P.
These cupcakes are legit great. My wife is very particular about cupcakes and loves them. Friends come from out of town and forest thing they want is cupcakes from Wish. It's not a huge operation and it's kind of no-nonsense but the product is top notch.
Dr. D.
not impressed. the place is never open and the one time i was able to go there i wasnt impressed with the selection or product! cupcakes we were able to try were somewhat dry and flavorless.
Sara R.
Wonderful place for fresh from scratch cupcakes. So delicious. Amazing cream cheese frosting on the lemon poppy seed cupcake. Will return soon!
Dana Gibson
If I could give 100 stars to cupcake wish I would. I brought them to my son’s birthday party. I had multiple people tell me that the chocolate dipped cupcakes were the best cupcake they’ve ever had. Even people that didn’t typically like cupcakes were raving about them. The owner was lovely and even tossed in a free mega cupcake with a message written on it for my son. He loved it and felt so special. Anyway, great place. Definitively a must for your next gathering.
Elizabeth O.
We were in town for the Dickens festival and came across this little gem of a cupcake shop! I am a s***** for a good cupcake and this place did not disappoint! They had such a large variety of cupcakes and it was almost too hard to pick just 4! The staff was very patient with my super indecisive self. Eventually I made a decision and ended up getting the Peppermint cupcake-- my personal favorite! Eggnog cupcake, Maple Bacon and Tiramisu. Some of them even had a filling which is always a welcomed surprise. Some of the icings on the cupcakes are so nice and light which I really enjoy because I'm not a huge fan of a heavy buttercream. This little cupcake shop is definitely worth the visit if you're nearby or just in for a visit!
Caleb K.
Really good cupcakes! I've tried at least 8 of the flavors so far and have not been disappointed with any of them. Taste is great. Most flavors taste rich enough to savor each bite without being too rich. Cake is very good but the frosting really adds that extra punch. Some of the best frosting I have ever had. It's the perfect in between of buttery and sugary.
Emily Raynor
Wonderful small business, cupcakes are delightful. The pumpkin in particular was fabulous ? the cream cheese frosting was like nothing I have ever had before. Highly recommend, you will not regret it.
Our families go to for delicious cupcakes the employees are super nice and always helpful
Michelle McGlone
These are absolutely the best cupcakes I have ever had. I ordered 4 dozen assorted cupcakes for a family party and they were amazing and a huge hit at the party! I couldn't ask for a better experience from ordering them to serving them to our guests. I highly recommend.
Daniel Hinze
Beautiful cupcakes - mediocre spongeBeautifully decorated cupcakes with different OK flavors. The cupcakes themselves are vanilla or chocolate sponge - nothing special.
Tina G.
It was my mother's birthday and I've been wanting to stop at this place for a while to see how their cupcakes are. I arrived there about an hour and a half before closing and their selections were very disappointing. They must not have back-up cupcakes for when their front stock runs low. The cupcakes were very well-decorated and presentation was nice, but as soon as we tried them, the icing was horrible. We noticed the icing was a whipped texture. There was no butter cream or actual frosting to it. It must be the style of how the owner likes to do their icing, but it was not good. It may look pretty, but it tasted horrible. The cake, itself, was dry and not amusing. It had no filling and tasted like the cake you get at Shop Rite. I purchased 6 cupcakes for $22. It was not worth it. This place can have a lot of potential considering its location and clientele that it attracts. However, they need to revamp their recipe if they want to stay in business.
Tina S.
Very good cupcakes. Lots of different flavorsLoved the frosting not sugary sweet nice and fluffy lightDefinitely will go back & try a jumbo cupcake next
Updating my 5 star review since this business stopped filling the cupcakes. Cake is dry and still the same price for less product.
These cupcakes are absolutely delicious and the owner is such a sweet lady! Amazing service and quality
Cupcakes were very tasty. Not like the commercial cupcakes you get at stores but about the same size. Limited hours.
These cupcakes are legit great. My wife is very particular about cupcakes and loves them. Friends come from out of town and forest thing they want is cupcakes from Wish. It's not a huge operation and it's kind of no-nonsense but the product is top notch.
not impressed. the place is never open and the one time i was able to go there i wasnt impressed with the selection or product! cupcakes we were able to try were somewhat dry and flavorless.
Wonderful place for fresh from scratch cupcakes. So delicious. Amazing cream cheese frosting on the lemon poppy seed cupcake. Will return soon!
If I could give 100 stars to cupcake wish I would. I brought them to my son’s birthday party. I had multiple people tell me that the chocolate dipped cupcakes were the best cupcake they’ve ever had. Even people that didn’t typically like cupcakes were raving about them. The owner was lovely and even tossed in a free mega cupcake with a message written on it for my son. He loved it and felt so special. Anyway, great place. Definitively a must for your next gathering.
We were in town for the Dickens festival and came across this little gem of a cupcake shop! I am a s***** for a good cupcake and this place did not disappoint! They had such a large variety of cupcakes and it was almost too hard to pick just 4! The staff was very patient with my super indecisive self. Eventually I made a decision and ended up getting the Peppermint cupcake-- my personal favorite! Eggnog cupcake, Maple Bacon and Tiramisu. Some of them even had a filling which is always a welcomed surprise. Some of the icings on the cupcakes are so nice and light which I really enjoy because I'm not a huge fan of a heavy buttercream. This little cupcake shop is definitely worth the visit if you're nearby or just in for a visit!
Really good cupcakes! I've tried at least 8 of the flavors so far and have not been disappointed with any of them. Taste is great. Most flavors taste rich enough to savor each bite without being too rich. Cake is very good but the frosting really adds that extra punch. Some of the best frosting I have ever had. It's the perfect in between of buttery and sugary.
Wonderful small business, cupcakes are delightful. The pumpkin in particular was fabulous ? the cream cheese frosting was like nothing I have ever had before. Highly recommend, you will not regret it.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our families go to for delicious cupcakes the employees are super nice and always helpful
These are absolutely the best cupcakes I have ever had. I ordered 4 dozen assorted cupcakes for a family party and they were amazing and a huge hit at the party! I couldn't ask for a better experience from ordering them to serving them to our guests. I highly recommend.
Beautiful cupcakes - mediocre spongeBeautifully decorated cupcakes with different OK flavors. The cupcakes themselves are vanilla or chocolate sponge - nothing special.
It was my mother's birthday and I've been wanting to stop at this place for a while to see how their cupcakes are. I arrived there about an hour and a half before closing and their selections were very disappointing. They must not have back-up cupcakes for when their front stock runs low. The cupcakes were very well-decorated and presentation was nice, but as soon as we tried them, the icing was horrible. We noticed the icing was a whipped texture. There was no butter cream or actual frosting to it. It must be the style of how the owner likes to do their icing, but it was not good. It may look pretty, but it tasted horrible. The cake, itself, was dry and not amusing. It had no filling and tasted like the cake you get at Shop Rite. I purchased 6 cupcakes for $22. It was not worth it. This place can have a lot of potential considering its location and clientele that it attracts. However, they need to revamp their recipe if they want to stay in business.
Very good cupcakes. Lots of different flavorsLoved the frosting not sugary sweet nice and fluffy lightDefinitely will go back & try a jumbo cupcake next