Really good pizza don’t let the old look of the store confuse you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Riordan
Was excited to try this but was very disappointed. Probably one of the worst plain slices I've ever had.
Anthony Manzo
Pizza is delicious and the deep fried calzones are unreal,,, if you haven’t been to Panko go you won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Des KF
I was really excited to try this pizzeria. When I arrived I parked in the plaza lot. I walked in and got the old school vibe. I was greeted and ordered the chicken pie. It was made fresh and came out in about 10 minutes. It looked good! When I dug in, I noticed it was a bit messy with the crust. I found out it was dipped Panko bread crumbs, which was super cool and made it more tasty. I really enjoyed my experience and time.
Danielle MacDonald
The pizza was good got the panko pie with sausage and mushrooms. Definitely needed to be crispier cause the topping made it soggy. Maybe plain or one topping would have been better. The flavor was great nice and garlicky. we also got the side of meatballs and it was only two average sized meatballs for $12.99 very pricey and they were dense with no flavor. I definitely don't recommend them. We will get another pizza and maybe try a dinner or something because the sauce was good. Overall not terrible nothing is gonna be perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Frank B
Sicilian Pizza was just ok. Sauce was really good but got soggy quick. The top part of pizza was cooked nicely but bottom was burnt horribly. Hopefully this does not happen often.
LilxDowney
Pizza was nasty sauce to sweet . Go to Pasquale’s down the road much better . Crust was also really bumpy and unappetizing
Melissa Delvalle
Tried for the 1st timeLoved the breadcrumbs in the crust..its different but like it alot..good flavor too cant wait to try the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
catherine rabas
Myself and a friend had the pleasure of having one of the most deliciousPizza Pies at Basille’s in MiddletownNJ. What caught our attention about their pizza was the fact that you could really taste the delicious sauce and the cheese the same time. So manyPizza places put so much mozzarellaon their pizza pies that it ruins the entire pie. This pizza both the cheese and the sauce were evenly distributed.And to top it all off it was only $9.99.You can’t get a pie like that anywhere for the price. I was really impressed.I had seen the sign outside for $9.99Large Pie. I was also talking to the owners mom about how delicious this pizza was!!!!!!! I will also be going back to taste some of their Italian dishes!!!I think I found my happy place??Catherine Rabas12/22/2023. I give it 5 Stars without a doubtParking: Middletown NJ There’s plenty of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Murf
Always trying different pizzerias and this one didn’t disappoint at all! Tried a slice of Sicilian and a regular one day and it was exactly how I like it, thin crispy crust great taste etc. Went back the following week to get a pie because I know slices when you reheat aren’t the reality of a fresh pie as far as crispy goes and it didn’t disappoint!! Also BTW the price of the pizzas are a bargain for these inflated times!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian, Sicilian Pie, Various Pizza Slices
Been here before and was so sad to see a roache just crawling around out front i can imagine what's in the back. And they don't like customers that wear mask..I will not be returning!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
John Carpenter
I’ve only had take out pizza, but their pizza is incredible! My new favorite pizza hands down!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joel Hofman
I have eaten at this place several times now and can I honestly say it’s one of the most underrated pizza restaurants I’ve ever been to. I have eaten pizza in NY and NJ for over 25 years and am surprised with some of the negative reviews. I’ve not tried the other non-pizza items on the menu but the crust and sauce make this pizza incredible regardless of the toppings that go on it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Various Pizza Slices
Mike W.
I saw a Facebook ad for Basille's and their Sicilian pizza looked good so my wife and I decided to try the place. I got a regular Sicilian and one Voka sauce Sicilian slice. My wife got a regular slice. The weird thing is all of the regular slices in the case were all very well done with burned crust. Not are cup of tea. The Sicilian slice on the other hand were not burned and very good. The weird thing is for beverages there is no Coke or Pepsi but RC Cola! RC Cola??? I didn't even know this was still around! Also my least favorite of all the Colas. Overall not a really satisfying stop. My wife couldn't even finish her one slice.
Really good pizza don’t let the old look of the store confuse you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was excited to try this but was very disappointed. Probably one of the worst plain slices I've ever had.
Pizza is delicious and the deep fried calzones are unreal,,, if you haven’t been to Panko go you won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was really excited to try this pizzeria. When I arrived I parked in the plaza lot. I walked in and got the old school vibe. I was greeted and ordered the chicken pie. It was made fresh and came out in about 10 minutes. It looked good! When I dug in, I noticed it was a bit messy with the crust. I found out it was dipped Panko bread crumbs, which was super cool and made it more tasty. I really enjoyed my experience and time.
The pizza was good got the panko pie with sausage and mushrooms. Definitely needed to be crispier cause the topping made it soggy. Maybe plain or one topping would have been better. The flavor was great nice and garlicky. we also got the side of meatballs and it was only two average sized meatballs for $12.99 very pricey and they were dense with no flavor. I definitely don't recommend them. We will get another pizza and maybe try a dinner or something because the sauce was good. Overall not terrible nothing is gonna be perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Sicilian Pizza was just ok. Sauce was really good but got soggy quick. The top part of pizza was cooked nicely but bottom was burnt horribly. Hopefully this does not happen often.
Pizza was nasty sauce to sweet . Go to Pasquale’s down the road much better . Crust was also really bumpy and unappetizing
Tried for the 1st timeLoved the breadcrumbs in the crust..its different but like it alot..good flavor too cant wait to try the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Myself and a friend had the pleasure of having one of the most deliciousPizza Pies at Basille’s in MiddletownNJ. What caught our attention about their pizza was the fact that you could really taste the delicious sauce and the cheese the same time. So manyPizza places put so much mozzarellaon their pizza pies that it ruins the entire pie. This pizza both the cheese and the sauce were evenly distributed.And to top it all off it was only $9.99.You can’t get a pie like that anywhere for the price. I was really impressed.I had seen the sign outside for $9.99Large Pie. I was also talking to the owners mom about how delicious this pizza was!!!!!!! I will also be going back to taste some of their Italian dishes!!!I think I found my happy place??Catherine Rabas12/22/2023. I give it 5 Stars without a doubtParking: Middletown NJ There’s plenty of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always trying different pizzerias and this one didn’t disappoint at all! Tried a slice of Sicilian and a regular one day and it was exactly how I like it, thin crispy crust great taste etc. Went back the following week to get a pie because I know slices when you reheat aren’t the reality of a fresh pie as far as crispy goes and it didn’t disappoint!! Also BTW the price of the pizzas are a bargain for these inflated times!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian, Sicilian Pie, Various Pizza Slices
Restaurantji Recommends
Really the BEST pizza in Middletown!
Been here before and was so sad to see a roache just crawling around out front i can imagine what's in the back. And they don't like customers that wear mask..I will not be returning!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
I’ve only had take out pizza, but their pizza is incredible! My new favorite pizza hands down!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have eaten at this place several times now and can I honestly say it’s one of the most underrated pizza restaurants I’ve ever been to. I have eaten pizza in NY and NJ for over 25 years and am surprised with some of the negative reviews. I’ve not tried the other non-pizza items on the menu but the crust and sauce make this pizza incredible regardless of the toppings that go on it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Various Pizza Slices
I saw a Facebook ad for Basille's and their Sicilian pizza looked good so my wife and I decided to try the place. I got a regular Sicilian and one Voka sauce Sicilian slice. My wife got a regular slice. The weird thing is all of the regular slices in the case were all very well done with burned crust. Not are cup of tea. The Sicilian slice on the other hand were not burned and very good. The weird thing is for beverages there is no Coke or Pepsi but RC Cola! RC Cola??? I didn't even know this was still around! Also my least favorite of all the Colas. Overall not a really satisfying stop. My wife couldn't even finish her one slice.