Pasquale's Pizzeria III

147 Cherry Tree Farm Rd, Middletown
(732) 615-9800

Recent Reviews

Paul Gormezano

Guy is rude at front desk

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jason Ruppert

This is the 2nd time I've ordered from them,and the 2nd time I've been burned. The 1st time I ordered a large pie with extra cheese(which was $3.99) and pepperoni. The cheese was barely the regular amount one would get. This time I tried getting Tortellini Alfredo. Well,it is like liquid with the Tortellini,it doesn't have to be soooo thick,but not like it's half full of milk. I tried.

Jason Pauxtis

We’ve been ordering take out and delivery from Pasquale’s for years. They have a vast and delicious vegan menu, ranging from pizzas to apps to dinners. Everything we’ve had from here, both vegan and not, is a winner. Easy to order online through the Toast app. Pick up is quick, although sometimes their quoted pick up times have been 15-20 min off. Delivery is always speedy!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vegan Pizza

Michele Tara Anderocci

I ordered a chicken franchise pizza for delivery. The delivery driver was on time polite and super nice. He is the only thing about this experience that gets a star. Not one to the restaurant or food. I’d give negative stars!!!The pizza isn’t cooked but rather raw dough. And it’s on their menu. Not a special order. A menu item they perhaps have never made before?? The dough is raw and it’s soaking wet! Like soaked and not cooked with raw gooey dough. Super disgusting.I called the restaurant and was dismissed by the first man and then dismissed by the second. No apology. Do these people understand how to make a pizza? Customer service? Basic English ?? Bc they didn’t even understand my broken Italian / Spanish.I was told next time I get 10% off. Lmao. I replied; There won’t be a next time! What a waste! Its not edible. Disgusting waste of food lack of customer service basic skills professionalism and come on!?! How hard is it to make a pizza!???Gross.

Scott R

The worst pizza I ever had. Even worse was the guy at the counter. I got 5 plain slices it came to $18.56. He swiped my card and was magically $19:53. He never told me there was an extra fee. $1 credit card fee for an $18 purchase. 5 plain slices was almost $20. I think there is a problem here. Either reach back to me or I'm calling my credit card company. Such rude employee.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

A R

Love this place and bonus points for vegan options. Thank you!

lyss

The vegan vodka pie never disappoints!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Ma Bell

So many fantastic vegan options! I'd eat here every day if I lived nearby ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Jonathan Gonzalez

I was out hanging with a buddy of mine when he mentioned ordering from here. Mentioned they made a garlic knot crust and I was intrigued. The pizza was good but I felt like the bottom crust could have been thicker to hold the toppings better because when I grabbed it almost everything fell off of it. The garlic knots were amazing though. If you are in the area check this place out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Eric Lupardi

Ordered a pizza and rice ball. Food took an hour and half to arrive. Was cold. The delivery driver was nice, but never again again will i order from here. I know it’s a Friday but my phone number was on the order. Pick up the phone and let me know, or also, don’t deliver a cold pie.

Food: 1

Finn Allen

This place has a great vegan menu! My boyfriend and I have eaten here 3 times and really enjoy it.

Patrick K

Food is pretty good. Delivery driver is great. The place needs to be updated inside. It's more of a take out kind of place.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 3

Rachel Oglensky

i was charged $68 for two large pizzas even though when i was rung up they said it was $50 something. they told me to sign something and i didn’t sign off on a tip or any extra charge. the pizza was fine but definitely not worth almost $70.

rachel may

i was charged $68 for two large pizzas even though when i was rung up they said it was $50 something. they told me to sign something and i didn’t sign off on a tip or any extra charge. the pizza was fine but definitely not worth almost $70.

Sarge Johnson

Ordered 2 pies to be delivered and was told 50 min. Called back after hour and fifteen min told it's on its way.. 2 hours I called again and was told it will be on its way. Canceled the delivery and better not be charged the $50+ for 2 pies. Unreal!!!

Load More