The Milford House

92 Water St, Milford
(908) 995-9411

Recent Reviews

Jerry Zemaitis

This popular restaurant has a lot going for it. The kitchen produces quality plates. One offering that is fun is the "chef surprise". Basically the kitchen decided on the small plate they will make for you. One of my dining companions is Jewish. Additionally we were there on the first day of Passover. We told our server that the only restriction was No Ham. Wouldn't you know it-the second small plate to arrive at the table was a ham sandwich! They wouldn't take it back and insisted that we had to announce any restrictions EVERY time we ordered. The waitress was very snarky and tried to place the blame on us. I'd be willing to give this place a second chance.Parking: Their parking lot accommodates fewer cars than available tables.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Freddy Leyton

I’m usually pretty difficult rater. Came here on a Monday which is different menu with small portions. Let me say, food as amazing and very fresh. Oysters were very clean, food presentation was excellent. Def recommend.Usually post photos but food went quick.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Cooper

Over priced.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Bob Priester

Really brought the place back, going to be a regular

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger with Fries

James Michael

Portions are ridiculously small given the price per item.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Chris C.

Seafood is beyond reproach. Service is great! The atmosphere/ambiance is cozy, perfect for date night! Very creative chef and the owners are great people!

T H

New Years Day Brunch was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tim Campbell

Good food, good service, nice atmosphere. The shepherd's pie and salmon entree were outstanding. The meatloaf looked great. Clams and oysters are prominent on their menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathi Varvel

Buck- a - shuck oysters on Monday with a tapas menu. Enjoyable musical entertainment in the dining room of this charming stone inn

Chaz Wang

Great staff and intriguing food choices that often change. Trivia nights are a blast

Lary Range

Had a great time celebrating birthdays for two in our party.Food was excellent and service outstanding.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lars Crooks

Genuinely great folks with inspired and diverse menu options.

Johnny F.

Got sick there twice I don't have much to say, but this review requires 85 letters, so I am just about done with this trait yourself bring toilet paper

Cindy C.

Good food! Always excellent! Wonderful people & great service! Also the ambiance is so lovely! Love it !

John S.

The food really isn't anything "special". Would only go on a Monday, do to $1 oysters. But beware, if you are not there at 5pm, when they open, do not expect to order oysters. They will be gone. Also, Ran out of salmon, and the smash burger. I ordered the "CHEF's CHOICE" special/surprise. SURPRISE! A piece of swordfish approximately, and I am not exaggerating, 1/4 " thick. Really? carpaccio of swordfish, maybe. And again, it wasn't good. Tasted like it was pulled from a freezer in which it founded a home months prior. It was very slow in service, but I do understand. Nice bar to have cocktails and meet prior to going out to dinner at a nearby restaurant. And, it wasn't cheap. 2 stars because I want them to succeed. Been there, done that, for 30 years, 3 restaurants, all 4 Diamond, 4 Star restaurants, because.....I cared and sacrificed to be the best. They may need more time or a turnover in the kitchen.

Load More