Cara Mia

194 Essex St, Millburn
(973) 379-8989

Recent Reviews

Carol Ann Mangan

Love everything about this place. Highly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Blackened Red Snapper, Garlic Shrimp, Veal Sorrentino, Fettucini Cara Mia

Jacquelyn Banks

I went to a birthday party. The staff was excellent. The service was great. A d, the food is DELICIOUS! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veal Sorrentino, Bruschetta and Zucchini Chips, Spaghetti Carbonara

Laura B.

We made a 5:45 reservation at this restaurant on a Saturday night anticipating we would have plenty of time to eat and attend the 7:30 show at The Papermill. Service is generally a bit slow here, but our most recent attempt will be our last It was difficult to get our waiter's attention. When we finally placed our order, we had already been sitting at our table for 30 minutes. We did tell the server we were going to a show and had to leave quickly Unfortunately I cannot give you a review of our meal because we had to leave before it arrived. At that point we were hungry and frustrated and did not have time to dine somewhere else before the show The ambiance was noisy and crowded for so early in the evening. I don't know if others were as unhappy as we felt. It seemed that people who had arrived after us got their entrees faster than we did.

John G

Always a wonderful dining experience from the waitstaff to the people bussing the tables.,friendly and polite. The food portions are amazing ad we have uet to finish our meal in one sitting. We usually go there around 5 times a year and have never been disappointed. The waiter Rob is terrific! We recommend this restaurant to all our friends and family. It is a must to go try it!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veal Sorrentino

Cici J

This location is comfy and clean inside so the dine in experience was pleasant. Service was excellent so I never felt neglected, whether it was drinks or placing my order everything was done timely. Salmon, Pasta and Chicken was served up on the lower end of hot meaning it wasn't as hot as I prefer. Everyone found the taste of the food acceptable but for the price I felt like some of the vegetables particularly the broccoli was from a frozen source not farm to table fresh. I think if you are looking for a place to eat this is a decent place to try out.Parking: Paid parking available and some free parking after a certain hour of the day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Jon M

Wait staff is great..historically great food..kinda feel they are slipping a bit..but only small things..like the zucchini chip appetizer used to be served hot..now cold..etc..

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan

Elaine M.

We at dinner there on Tuesday Jan 16 2024. I ended up with food poisoning. I got sick with in 40 minutes of finishing my meal. We never made it home. I ended up in the emergency room. My test results confirmed. I had a conversation with YELP today as they took my first post down. Yelp told me to just state the facts. I also got a call from someone screaming at me. There another review from May. Women had also got food poisoning. Could have been very isolated, but i was very ill. So after 2 blood tests, and a procedure and 2 doctor visits. After 24 days i am feeling better. Now to get my bills paid.

Holly Smith

First time to Cara Mia - Enjoyed a wonderful dinner with my family of 4 last night. Delicious food, amazing service, atmosphere is on point! Can't wait to return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexander Sahlman

Our meal was delicious & the service was excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burrata, Bruschetta and Zucchini Chips

Dennis Quinn

Perfect place for a gathering of friends and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carmelle Suzeline Charles

Great and cozy atmosphere!!

John Westfall-Kwong

Delicious meal tonight. 5 different dishes, all fantastic and looking forward to some great leftovers!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veal Milanese, Bruschetta and Zucchini Chips

Daniel

Great little spot to grab a nice meal. I got the Pesto Gncochi and garlic shrimp appetizer, along with the hazelnut Gelato for dessert. There's a nice little spot next door for wine— it's BYOB.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Gnocchi, Burrata

Marcia Salgado

Delicious food and very good service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Frenchies7

We had dinner there prior to going to the show at the playhouse . The food and the service were exceptional. The portions were huge, the staff kept everything moving. A great place to go

Load More