Dutch's Sandwich Shop

16 Church St, Montclair
(973) 939-5037

Recent Reviews

Gabrielle Porras

Honestly not worth the money, there are so many other places in Montclair where the service matches the price. Paid $18 for a small coffee and an egg white wrap and had to wait 15+ minutes for it in a near empty shop.This is the first breakfast & lunch place I've been to with only one coffee size (small) and zero non dairy creamer options. I can't even speak on the food because they completely messed up my order and I wasn't able to eat it. I called back for a refund the manager was apologetic, but while I appreciate the kindness from the staff I'm not interested in a free sandwich from a place that repeats my order correctly to me 3 separate times and still gets it wrong in the kitchen.Pictured is my coffee with what was supposed to be a wrap with no cheese and an addition of avocado ($3). Wrap is loaded with feta and no avocado

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 1

Carmelo Provenzano

So I went in undecided, all I knew was how hungry I was at the moment. Told the women behind the counter you make me what you think is the best. Damn she delivered. I had a steak sandwich with lettuce tomato and sum on a warm here roll. It was like a chopped cheese but even better. Great job guys! Ill def be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yvannie Salomon

Food was gross. Ordered a steak sand which and it was freezing cold, the sauce was wayyyy too much and made a mess. My friend said their grilled cheese tasted like just butter on bread. And my other friend’s cheesesteak barely had any steak. It also took 40 mins to get our food just for it to be cold. Doesn’t make sense.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

S H

The food is amazing, they have the best sandwiches. I love how creative they get with the names. Overall, if you love sandwiches, this is the place for you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastrami Umami Sandwich, The Dutch Daddy Sandwich

V Franco

Highly recommend. Get the Dutch’s special breakfast sandwich. Cool atmosphere and great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich

David J.

The Dutch daddy might be the best breakfast sandwich I ever had. Which means a lot coming from a jersey boy who loves Taylor ham and bagels

Jess Pochek

I’ve heard about this place from the internet and have been wanting to try it for some time now. The owner greeted us right away and he was so friendly and welcoming! They have breakfast sandwich options too and salads and wraps. The sandwiches we ordered were The Driver and The Rhaenyra. We ordered The Rhaenyra with sriracha mayo instead of balsamic glaze and it was soooooo good. I’m sure it would’ve been great with the balsamic glaze too because it’s similar to an Italian but great if you want extra spice. The Driver was simpler. They make their chicken cutlets in house according to the owner! Great flavors, chicken wasn’t dry, fresh bread. Definitely recommend stopping in for a filling and delicious lunch. I’ll be coming back for sure to try other options as I couldn’t order everything all at once!Vegetarian options: They have a section of the menu that stated vegetarian options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mandy S.

Amazing Avocado toast! Avocado spread was creamy and plentiful with an abundance of fresh tomato on top and a sweet balsamic drizzle. I chose not to include eggs. The seasoning was exceptional. I will definitely get it again!

M M.

Sooooo good! The roll made it outstanding. Soft buttery flavorful!! Definitely will be going back again!

Shawn A.

Yep, this place is legit! Stopped by with a huge order first thing in the morning. Took a bit of time because it was all prepared fresh, but the little wait was so worth it. I heard nothing but praise all around when I got to work and people dug in. We had a collection of about 8 different sandwiches ordered so there was a variety of praise that went around on a bunch of different menu items. I got the Dutch Daddy, which was a great call! The Pastrami was excellent, who doesn't love some bacon slid in there, the Muenster cheese was a unique (and excellent) addition and Dutch's Signature Sauce...sign me up for more! This was so good, how do I move on to something else next time? The brioche roll was outstanding!!! Even the person who self-admittedly got the "boring" egg & cheese sandwich said the bun was fantastic and made the sandwich excellent. Yeah, I'll be back!

g

Just tried the Becky Pollo, SPEECHLESS! Such a delicious sandwich, and I will definitely leave this as the best food i’ve tried! It is such a try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

evie valle

Just tried the Tay Tay, and all I can say is OMG! Best breakfast sandwich i’ve ever tried. Dutch’s is definitely a must when looking for places to grab something to eat in Montclair!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

christoff els

Ordered the “Dutch Daddy” and hands down the best breakfast sandwich I have ever had!These guys know their stuff !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Riley Gardner

Food was so good holy moly….

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: In the Heights

Adam Riccio

Great food, great atmosphere, great staff. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More