Visiting from Seattle, WA, and Coniglio’s was absolutely amazing! Pablo and team took great care of our table of 10 and the pizzas we ordered were amazing! No doubt some of the best we’ve ever had and the desserts were excellent! Very much a family atmosphere here.. First class service and we will 100% be back here next time we are in town!
This place is amazing. The food was ?. Even had a cold slice this morning before coffee lol. They’re salads are amazing as well. And such a cool environment!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Ricotta
Hector H. Rivera Vaca
Pizzas….AWESOME!!!! pastries breathtaking. Definitely are the best pizzas I ever had!!!. If you are nearby Coniglio’s is a MUST!, you don wanna miss it. The most I liked was the basil on pizzas. We ordered three whole pizzas for 3 people and was absolutely worth it!.Will come back, no doubt.
I just moved to Chatham after living in Brooklyn for many years. Being in NYC I had quick access to amazing pizza. I’d trade all the pizza in NY for the pizza at Coniglio’s. It is the best pizza I’ve ever had. What else is there to say. It’s the best. Super friendly staff as well. I look forward to many more meals here. Heck, I think I’ll go for lunch tomorrow. Why wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Josephina's Grandma Pie
Michael Cammarato
Went to Coniglio’s for dinner on a Wednesday night. It was very busy but we were sat quickly. The grandma pie, pasta, and bread were fresh and delicious. Highly recommend if you’re looking for quality food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Josephina's Grandma Pie
David Jorge
If you’re looking for something different than the regular eggs and bacon Coniglios is the place to be. Breakfast lunch and dinner you’ll love it! ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marina Kalpouzos
Seriously delicious pizza! Tried the Josephina Square Pie and all of the components were spot on - especially the sauce. Absolutely amazing flavor that I immediately saved the spot as a favorite. It’s a top contender on my quest to find the best pizza.Restaurant has an interesting and diverse set up. You order at the register making it feel like a to-go spot, but they have ample seating to dine-in. Also, has some good looking baked goods/bread. Can’t wait to come back and try more off the menu.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steph A
This pizza is phenomenal!!! After reading the reviews, I had to try this spot and it has been our top place to pick up from ever since ? I've had the vodka stracciatella and the upside down grandma pies so far- both are out of this world. Unlike any pizza around.Personally, I think the vodka stracciatella is the stand-out item- it's just unbelievable. I've always liked vodka pizzas and typically order them whenever I see them on a menu...I've never tasted anything like this ?The desserts and sandwiches and pastas are incredible too! It seems like everything they do here, they do WELL
Food: 5
John Zucchero
My wife and I read an article in NJ Monthly magazine about this guy who keeps winning awards for pizza and that he opened a pizzeria in Morristown, so we decided to give it a try.The place is called Coniglio’s Old-Fashioned (coniglio is Italian for “rabbit”) and it has an inviting atmosphere with cute bunny pictures all over the place.When it comes to pizzas, my wife and I consider ourselves pizza “snobs”…we love a good pizza and dislike mediocre. Let me tell you, this is a good pizza, which truly is an understatement! This is one of the best, if not the best, pizza that we have ever eaten. The crust, sauce, and cheese were all just perfect, if not magical. We ordered the 18” round pie, and there was no way we could finish it (that’s what air fryers are for…leftover pizza). We just could not believe how good it was!But then there was a 2nd surprise. This place also bakes breads, bagels, croissants, brioches, Danish (including (bombolone), and chocolate chip cookies, etc. We took home a loaf of sourdough, a cookie, and some danishes. They were all as delicious as the pizza…and that is saying a lot. The sourdough bread could rival anything from San Francisco. The chocolate chip cookie would make Ruth Wakefield (creator of the original Toll House chocolate chip) proud.The gentleman behind the register truly added the whole experience with how friendly and welcoming he was. When he heard that another guest was visiting Morristown, he quickly opened a box and gave him some baked goods to take back to his hotel. How thoughtful is that?We can’t wait to go back, this place is just a true gem. Highly, highly recommend!
We ordered the Brooklyn pie with sausage, it was seriously the best pizza we ever had. The shaved fennel salad was out of this world and served 3 of us. The fusilli with mushrooms was perfectly al dente, delicious comfort food on a chilly night. Our service was fantastic, from placing the order to when we realized that we had bought too many Brooklyn seltzers (delicious by the way) and needed to get our bill corrected. The presentation of all the dishes we ordered was very pleasing as well. To top it off we enjoyed 3 different loaves of bread, freshly sliced and which made delicious sandwiches and toast next day. The fruit and nut was my personal favorite. I am here visiting a friend for a few days but I am planning to take a pie home to the Boston area when I leave. It seriously challenges the two Italian pizza rivals in our Italian North end… I can’t wait for my husband to true it. All in all 5 stars for everything, food, service and atmosphere!! Charming and cozy decor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jay Donda
Vodka Pizza are the best among the other best pizzas! Sourdough bread is to die for ! Amazing quality amazing food extremely friendly and helpful staff. No reservations required first come first serve ! Definitely one the best pizzas in New Jersey ! A must visit place for pizza lovers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Pizza, Josephina's Grandma Pie, Nonna's Spinach Pie
George Twill
I went to coniglio’s for a work lunch and it was very good, as I had heard it to be. I wasn’t sure if the Tommy Devito hype outpaced the food but I had a vodka parm chicken sandwich that was delicious, the bread was light and soft which is good for a parm sandwich, the cheese was fresh and the sandwich tasted great.. i have heard the pizza is good too and although I didn’t have it when I went for lunch I saw some people who had ordered the square pies and they looked delicious so I would come back to try the pizza.. I learned coniglio is Italian for rabbit which is why there’s pictures of rabbits all over the walls.
Brian Baldwin
One of my favorite places in Morristown.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Radhika Patel
Stumbled here last weekend while looking at houses in the area. My husband and I live right outside the city with great pizza options so we weren't expecting much when we came in. Boy were we wrong! The pizza was so good! We got the vodka pie and it is amazing! The sauce is perfect, not too tart, not too sweet, somehow the stracciatella added the perfect amount of creaminess without making it too rich, and the sourdough crust was crisp yet soft and SO good! Definitely stop by if you're in the area! The pastries looked amazing but we'll have to come back for them!
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visiting from Seattle, WA, and Coniglio’s was absolutely amazing! Pablo and team took great care of our table of 10 and the pizzas we ordered were amazing! No doubt some of the best we’ve ever had and the desserts were excellent! Very much a family atmosphere here.. First class service and we will 100% be back here next time we are in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nutella Stuffed Croissant, Pepperoni Pizza, Raspberry Bombolone
This place is amazing. The food was ?. Even had a cold slice this morning before coffee lol. They’re salads are amazing as well. And such a cool environment!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Ricotta
Pizzas….AWESOME!!!! pastries breathtaking. Definitely are the best pizzas I ever had!!!. If you are nearby Coniglio’s is a MUST!, you don wanna miss it. The most I liked was the basil on pizzas. We ordered three whole pizzas for 3 people and was absolutely worth it!.Will come back, no doubt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Pizza, Meatballs, Pepperoni Pizza
I just moved to Chatham after living in Brooklyn for many years. Being in NYC I had quick access to amazing pizza. I’d trade all the pizza in NY for the pizza at Coniglio’s. It is the best pizza I’ve ever had. What else is there to say. It’s the best. Super friendly staff as well. I look forward to many more meals here. Heck, I think I’ll go for lunch tomorrow. Why wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Josephina's Grandma Pie
Went to Coniglio’s for dinner on a Wednesday night. It was very busy but we were sat quickly. The grandma pie, pasta, and bread were fresh and delicious. Highly recommend if you’re looking for quality food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Josephina's Grandma Pie
If you’re looking for something different than the regular eggs and bacon Coniglios is the place to be. Breakfast lunch and dinner you’ll love it! ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Seriously delicious pizza! Tried the Josephina Square Pie and all of the components were spot on - especially the sauce. Absolutely amazing flavor that I immediately saved the spot as a favorite. It’s a top contender on my quest to find the best pizza.Restaurant has an interesting and diverse set up. You order at the register making it feel like a to-go spot, but they have ample seating to dine-in. Also, has some good looking baked goods/bread. Can’t wait to come back and try more off the menu.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
This pizza is phenomenal!!! After reading the reviews, I had to try this spot and it has been our top place to pick up from ever since ? I've had the vodka stracciatella and the upside down grandma pies so far- both are out of this world. Unlike any pizza around.Personally, I think the vodka stracciatella is the stand-out item- it's just unbelievable. I've always liked vodka pizzas and typically order them whenever I see them on a menu...I've never tasted anything like this ?The desserts and sandwiches and pastas are incredible too! It seems like everything they do here, they do WELL
Food: 5
My wife and I read an article in NJ Monthly magazine about this guy who keeps winning awards for pizza and that he opened a pizzeria in Morristown, so we decided to give it a try.The place is called Coniglio’s Old-Fashioned (coniglio is Italian for “rabbit”) and it has an inviting atmosphere with cute bunny pictures all over the place.When it comes to pizzas, my wife and I consider ourselves pizza “snobs”…we love a good pizza and dislike mediocre. Let me tell you, this is a good pizza, which truly is an understatement! This is one of the best, if not the best, pizza that we have ever eaten. The crust, sauce, and cheese were all just perfect, if not magical. We ordered the 18” round pie, and there was no way we could finish it (that’s what air fryers are for…leftover pizza). We just could not believe how good it was!But then there was a 2nd surprise. This place also bakes breads, bagels, croissants, brioches, Danish (including (bombolone), and chocolate chip cookies, etc. We took home a loaf of sourdough, a cookie, and some danishes. They were all as delicious as the pizza…and that is saying a lot. The sourdough bread could rival anything from San Francisco. The chocolate chip cookie would make Ruth Wakefield (creator of the original Toll House chocolate chip) proud.The gentleman behind the register truly added the whole experience with how friendly and welcoming he was. When he heard that another guest was visiting Morristown, he quickly opened a box and gave him some baked goods to take back to his hotel. How thoughtful is that?We can’t wait to go back, this place is just a true gem. Highly, highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Josephina's Grandma Pie, Breakfast Donuts and Pastries, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Raspberry Bombolone
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered the Brooklyn pie with sausage, it was seriously the best pizza we ever had. The shaved fennel salad was out of this world and served 3 of us. The fusilli with mushrooms was perfectly al dente, delicious comfort food on a chilly night. Our service was fantastic, from placing the order to when we realized that we had bought too many Brooklyn seltzers (delicious by the way) and needed to get our bill corrected. The presentation of all the dishes we ordered was very pleasing as well. To top it off we enjoyed 3 different loaves of bread, freshly sliced and which made delicious sandwiches and toast next day. The fruit and nut was my personal favorite. I am here visiting a friend for a few days but I am planning to take a pie home to the Boston area when I leave. It seriously challenges the two Italian pizza rivals in our Italian North end… I can’t wait for my husband to true it. All in all 5 stars for everything, food, service and atmosphere!! Charming and cozy decor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vodka Pizza are the best among the other best pizzas! Sourdough bread is to die for ! Amazing quality amazing food extremely friendly and helpful staff. No reservations required first come first serve ! Definitely one the best pizzas in New Jersey ! A must visit place for pizza lovers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Pizza, Josephina's Grandma Pie, Nonna's Spinach Pie
I went to coniglio’s for a work lunch and it was very good, as I had heard it to be. I wasn’t sure if the Tommy Devito hype outpaced the food but I had a vodka parm chicken sandwich that was delicious, the bread was light and soft which is good for a parm sandwich, the cheese was fresh and the sandwich tasted great.. i have heard the pizza is good too and although I didn’t have it when I went for lunch I saw some people who had ordered the square pies and they looked delicious so I would come back to try the pizza.. I learned coniglio is Italian for rabbit which is why there’s pictures of rabbits all over the walls.
One of my favorite places in Morristown.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stumbled here last weekend while looking at houses in the area. My husband and I live right outside the city with great pizza options so we weren't expecting much when we came in. Boy were we wrong! The pizza was so good! We got the vodka pie and it is amazing! The sauce is perfect, not too tart, not too sweet, somehow the stracciatella added the perfect amount of creaminess without making it too rich, and the sourdough crust was crisp yet soft and SO good! Definitely stop by if you're in the area! The pastries looked amazing but we'll have to come back for them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5