The food was fine but I had an anaphylaxis response to a cheese steak. As I am not allergic to anything on the menu it leads me to question the sanitary practices of this restaurant? Was the person preparing my food eating their lunch or snacking on a mango while they prepared it? I tried to call but was hung up on before even saying hello.
Andrew Silva
Heavyset delivery driver flirted with my girlfriend. Unprofessional. Cant judge if the food is good or not.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Julia Smith
I'm so happy to have found this place. I've been looking for years for a reliable pizza shop. This one is nearly perfect. A nice, chewy crust, a good amount of cheese and not swimming in sauce or overly seasoned. My only complaint would be that they're stingy with the toppings.I ordered a large pizza that was half mushroom and half extra cheese. There was no difference in the amount of cheese and the mushrooms were disappointingly sparse. I'd guess that they only sliced one mushroom for the pizza. Only 3 slices had any at all and they were sliced too thin. When I order a mushroom pizza, I expect more than 2 slivers of mushroom on each slice.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
alyn Steinberg
Placed an order online.the requirements were written on the order. “Cheese”steak sandwich with fried onions. The person in the store was very busy watching tv. I received a plain steak sandwich which was dry and not worthy of eating. I called and he put me thru to the manager. I told him I want a refund at least for the cheese and onion part of the order. Not too much to fulfill. Nothing received. I would never go here again. Check your food if you pick it up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kendra Jobe
Owner was great !gave great reccomendations and even saved me money?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry N
Damn good cheesesteak. The 17 inch is massive. Fresh roll, tasty meat and just enough cheese. Fries were good too, although maybe an extra few minutes for extra crispy ( I should have told them). Even the fountain Cherry Pepsi tasted really good too, not flat or weird tasting like fountain soda can be sometimes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gaetano
Frosty Xss
One of the biggest rips off ever. Got cheese bacon fries they threw 3 american single slices on top, onions rings tasted like old oil, and meat lover pizza was mid at best. Not worth the $42 what so ever. Spend your money else
Food: 1
Blanca Del Vacchio
Very small serving sizes (I'm talking "pickles & chips on the side" was 2 small pickle rounds and the smallest, lightest bag of Utz imaginable) and the tuna wrap was mid at best, respectfully. It did taste good, though.
Christine
I ordered a chicken cheese steak and fries. The cheese steak would have been great, but it hardly had any cheese. I'm not sure if I'll be ordering from Gaetano's again.
Food: 3
Jesse Shadel
Call ahead of time before 4pm or you will be fighting to get ahold of someone. This only happens because their food is The Best, and their service is very fast, their drivers are the nicest and funniest. I tried everywhere and this is the only place that delivers Real Tarantini Panzerattis as well!! Their bread has amzing crusty crust, and their Cheese steaks are STUFFED with meat, with cheese on the bottom as default so ask for it to be mixed if thats what you prefer.I don't have a bad thing to say about this place other then their so good its hard to get an order in at rush time.
This place aims to please the sandwiches are really good and fair priced not like primos up the street. the comparison to any place nearby is quality and price. if you want to pay a fair price this owner tries his best . the pizza & frries or salads are really good ?. 5 stars for more consistent deals.. Give this place a try you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak
Celeste Luce
Best Cheese Steaks! Came to visit from Florida. Miss these so much ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edward Anton
Food was good ? maybe on the day I was there the rolls were a bit on the hard side . Or stock was running low. .The pizza was really good and the other foods on the menu was just as good when I tried them. The staff was very nice and eager to please if you had a problem they would be make good on it... this place price wise is the best in the area. . Hope it gets a better bread bakery I know it would make it a 5 star place...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak with Mozzarella
Dawid p
Their Buffalo chicken steak sandwich is very good. One of the best I had
Food: 5
Madeline Wilson
BEST chicken cheese steaks. I always get a 7 inch and eat half & save the other half for lunch the next day. So tasty, SO much meat, & crazy delicious! Great deal!
The food was fine but I had an anaphylaxis response to a cheese steak. As I am not allergic to anything on the menu it leads me to question the sanitary practices of this restaurant? Was the person preparing my food eating their lunch or snacking on a mango while they prepared it? I tried to call but was hung up on before even saying hello.
Heavyset delivery driver flirted with my girlfriend. Unprofessional. Cant judge if the food is good or not.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I'm so happy to have found this place. I've been looking for years for a reliable pizza shop. This one is nearly perfect. A nice, chewy crust, a good amount of cheese and not swimming in sauce or overly seasoned. My only complaint would be that they're stingy with the toppings.I ordered a large pizza that was half mushroom and half extra cheese. There was no difference in the amount of cheese and the mushrooms were disappointingly sparse. I'd guess that they only sliced one mushroom for the pizza. Only 3 slices had any at all and they were sliced too thin. When I order a mushroom pizza, I expect more than 2 slivers of mushroom on each slice.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Placed an order online.the requirements were written on the order. “Cheese”steak sandwich with fried onions. The person in the store was very busy watching tv. I received a plain steak sandwich which was dry and not worthy of eating. I called and he put me thru to the manager. I told him I want a refund at least for the cheese and onion part of the order. Not too much to fulfill. Nothing received. I would never go here again. Check your food if you pick it up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Owner was great !gave great reccomendations and even saved me money?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Damn good cheesesteak. The 17 inch is massive. Fresh roll, tasty meat and just enough cheese. Fries were good too, although maybe an extra few minutes for extra crispy ( I should have told them). Even the fountain Cherry Pepsi tasted really good too, not flat or weird tasting like fountain soda can be sometimes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gaetano
One of the biggest rips off ever. Got cheese bacon fries they threw 3 american single slices on top, onions rings tasted like old oil, and meat lover pizza was mid at best. Not worth the $42 what so ever. Spend your money else
Food: 1
Very small serving sizes (I'm talking "pickles & chips on the side" was 2 small pickle rounds and the smallest, lightest bag of Utz imaginable) and the tuna wrap was mid at best, respectfully. It did taste good, though.
I ordered a chicken cheese steak and fries. The cheese steak would have been great, but it hardly had any cheese. I'm not sure if I'll be ordering from Gaetano's again.
Food: 3
Call ahead of time before 4pm or you will be fighting to get ahold of someone. This only happens because their food is The Best, and their service is very fast, their drivers are the nicest and funniest. I tried everywhere and this is the only place that delivers Real Tarantini Panzerattis as well!! Their bread has amzing crusty crust, and their Cheese steaks are STUFFED with meat, with cheese on the bottom as default so ask for it to be mixed if thats what you prefer.I don't have a bad thing to say about this place other then their so good its hard to get an order in at rush time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
This place aims to please the sandwiches are really good and fair priced not like primos up the street. the comparison to any place nearby is quality and price. if you want to pay a fair price this owner tries his best . the pizza & frries or salads are really good ?. 5 stars for more consistent deals.. Give this place a try you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak
Best Cheese Steaks! Came to visit from Florida. Miss these so much ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was good ? maybe on the day I was there the rolls were a bit on the hard side . Or stock was running low. .The pizza was really good and the other foods on the menu was just as good when I tried them. The staff was very nice and eager to please if you had a problem they would be make good on it... this place price wise is the best in the area. . Hope it gets a better bread bakery I know it would make it a 5 star place...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak with Mozzarella
Their Buffalo chicken steak sandwich is very good. One of the best I had
Food: 5
BEST chicken cheese steaks. I always get a 7 inch and eat half & save the other half for lunch the next day. So tasty, SO much meat, & crazy delicious! Great deal!