Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

2460 NJ-33, Neptune City
(732) 922-1912

Recent Reviews

Changa Jones

Great service awesome birthday cake shake!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paul Cohen

Always delicious. Watermelon is the best flavor.

Lindsey Gallinari

Mango gelatti is the bomb!!

betty baker

Love their Italian Ice

Tyler Glavocich

Very hard working team here

Jessica Lee

Waited 10 minutes to be served today because the young boy working was talking to his friend who wasn’t even ordering. They were just chatting. The worker finally said to his friend, “let me take this customer.” I told him he could continue talking and I’ll wait on the young lady who was already serving customers. At this point I’ve already been waiting 10 minutes. If you are going to talk to your friends fine but take care of your paying customers first.

A C

Delicious Italian ice cream and frozen custard, refreshing taste after coming out of the beach. A great desert after a meal. Free parking available.

Cactus Jack

This Rita’s is always on point after hitting Bradley Beach. Never disappoints. Bunch of kids running the place? Yes! Aren’t pretty much all Rita’s operated by young kids. They are doing a great job. Keepp up the good work. Again no complaints.

Dee Ramos

Omg!! What a treat!! The ice is sweet and the custard was the smoothest I've ever tasted!!RITAS! Please come to Michigan!

Omar Cedeno

This Rita’s is always on point after hitting Bradley Beach. Never disappoints. Bunch of kids running the place? Yes! Aren’t pretty much all Rita’s operated by young kids. They are doing a great job. Keepp up the good work. Again no complaints.

Vr regan

Good service and tasty custard. The 4 stars is really only about cost. 1 sm cone, 2 small dishes with fudge $20 (with tip). Seems high but was good tasting.

Patricia Seibert

The best Rita's around town.

C G.

Thank you to the workers at Rita's tonight!!! I just moved back to Jersey after years of not being around a Rita's and I'm 6 months pregnant. I've been having a wicked craving for a mango gelati for months now, but we got into the area just minutes after they closed. I'm so so so thankful that the amazing workers were able to serve me ice and a pint of custard so I could make my own gelati at home!!! Thank y'all so much!! Will be back soon (before closing time next time- I promise!!!) I didn't get their names but they were so kind!!!

Kyle Studd

This is a large sunday (see picture)?!?! 2 out of 3 orders in the last two weeks have been completely messed up. The first time we ordered some special named sunday that was supposed to come with sprinkles and gummy bears but it was just plain custard. Come on!

Barbara Whittaker

Great Great I love going there to get my Mango jaloty .

Load More

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

2460 NJ-33, Neptune City, NJ 07753
(732) 922-1912