Pastrami House Delicatessen

1294 Springfield Ave, New Providence
(973) 309-5675

Recent Reviews

Victor Obey

The food is amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sal

Ordered through Uber Eats, who dropped the ball completely. Someone from Pastrami House called us to let us know, and we were able to resolve the issue. The food was excellent! We had the classic pastrami sandwich, turkey pastrami, pickles, pasta salad, and soup. Everything was delicious and the establishment was accommodating and helpful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jack lardiere

Pastrami was fatty and over priced, pickles were terrible.Will not order again

Meg Larmony

Such a nice family owned spot! Food was great! Customer service was 10/10!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matthew Varner

Got a small Ruben, plenty of sandwich but good for a lunch portion. Didn't realize it came with chips, cole slaw, and pickle so that was a bonus. Fries ended up being steak fries which aren't my thing but still pretty tasty. Staff was really polite, I'll for sure be back when I'm in the area

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Paul M.

Very good but with one surprising disappointment. I got a Rueben sandwich and it had a nice amount of meat and all the normal toppings but instead of the sandwich being grilled it seemed like the bread was just lightly toasted and the cheese melted some but the bread ended up being soggy. Maybe this is just how they do a Rueben but I prefer when the bread is buttered and the sandwich grilled such that that bread gets brown and crispy. The place is clean and tidy and they have many deli options that are hard to find these days, but I just could not get over my non grilled sandwich.

Michael Rieger

For a place with pastrami in its name, the pastrami is extremely disappointing. I'd rather go down the street and get a much better sandwich in the next town. I don't think it would have even mattered if it was sliced thick like I asked instead of thin . The flavor just was not there and the meat was way leaner than pastrami should be . The chicken soup was very good however.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Ron P

Stopped in had #4 gold and eggplant sandwich french fries and onion rings amazing food amazing service from Jeff the owner and Juan .first visit will definitely be

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastrami

Alexander Cesare

Just had the best Pastrami sandwich ever from here. The staff was super friendly and the food is out of this world. Definitely my new go to lunch spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastrami Sandwich, Pastrami

Sanjay M.

just great quality food, straightforward and big on flavor. I had a pastrami on rye with the step up pastrami and it was delicious and filling. I don't normally leave reviews but When I saw this in my collection I felt a tug of nostalgia and I've only been there once.

Nick H.

I rarely review anything I order delivered as quality and temperature usually suffer from the delay. This will be an exception. We ordered 2 of the standard sized pastrami on rye and a cheesesteak which I believe was brisket and not the traditional ribeye . All were extremely generous for the price and the quality was amazing. Sandwiches came with a big pickle spear , delicious chips and a way too tiny coleslaw Z I'm saying way too tiny because it was great and I will definitely order as a side next time ! We also had a side of onion rings and had they been eaten immediately when made would qualify as some of the best I've ever had.

Judy N.

My husband and I traveled from the Flemington area to once again get the Sloppy sandwiches! They are so good we had to go back! I was not disappointed! The turkey on my sandwich was sooo moist. What you don't see in the picture was the deliciously crunchy pickle and chips. They were gone immediately!! I even order some extra whole pickles for later! My husband said his sandwich was also delicious. He just thought maybe another slice of corned beef would have made the difference between very good and great. You also are given a card when you order a sandwich that can be stamped toward earning a free sandwich. Despite the temptation I will try the latkes and one of the other dishes! Just one note: I ordered by phone and it was ready quicker than expected , even though it was a Saturday at dinner time!!! You must try!!!!!

Ray B.

Everything was terrible. Pastrami was rubbery. Potato salad had way too much mayo and cheese fries were way

Lisa Bernstein

YOURE FOOD IS TERRIBLE!!! CANT CHEW YOUR PASTRAMI AMD CORNED BEEF AT ALL!!!! HORRIBLE AND INEDIBLE!!!

Food: 1

steve c.

First time customer, ordered Pastrami, a turkey Joe and matzoh ball soup . Absolutely spectacular!!! Thank you I

Load More