American Whiskey Newark

51 Edison Pl, Newark
(973) 795-4499

Recent Reviews

Pablo Uriol Prieto

We went there for some food and drinks before a concert at Prudential Center, and they have the best atmosphere for that purpose. Good music, friendly service and wide whiskey menu. Perfect place for a before and after Prudential show!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger, Pepperoni Pizza

Juan pablo Raigoza quintero

This place is amazing, amazing service, the bartender Veronica & Valentina is so kind and friendly beautiful and nice place ❤️

Nia Taniel

Food was DISGUSTING!!! The calamari was hard, looked like onion rings taste like NOTHING!!! The fish tacos I’m really not even sure what that was….. it was freezer fish with a bunch of coleslaw thrown on top that also had zero taste to it. We was served a cheese burger w NO CHEESE!!! The music was extremely loud you couldn’t even hear the waiter. I really think this location needs a major do over chef, management etc…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Peter Joffe

I’ll add to the 1 star reviews. Beware and look at your check. They automatically add 20% gratuity on party of 4 and then they add the tax based off the food plus gratuity. The manager tried to play dumb and not understand how its setup in their computer. Luckily I just paid in cash minus’ing the extra tax they tried to collect fraudulently.

Canadian Yorker

The chocolate cake was bangingly delicious, I enjoyed the chipotle chicken sandwich that was tantalizing for my tastes. The sprite was smooth, silky and popping in my throat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Poet

Came for a few drinks and an appetizer. It was Thursday night at 730 pm. There were 5 bartenders. 8 pm strikes and 4 bartenders leave. There was 25 feet of bar for 1 person. Felt bad for the lone bartender. Nachos were great. Only issue was they did charge a 20% gratuity even though I got 3 cocktails and 1 appetizer.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Peter Topham

Excellent atmosphere. Barman is the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

Carola Hernandez

I went to a concert and when I left I had a couple of beers at the time I just paid and I left the next day I saw my account statement and it came out triple I called to get my receipt and to this day I'm still waiting for it and I see that It didn't just happen to me, it's sad that they have to go to such extremes!!!

juliet pitre

Got three drinks at the Zach Bryan concert on 3/14 was charged $34. Once the drinks got posted on my card the charge was $35 and some change. Checked today and the charged was updated to $41 and some change. I can’t even dispute it because they don’t provide you with a copy of your receipt when you purchase at their little bar stand. Never again, this is a highly unprofessional establishment, will never recommend anyone to purchase from this place.

Charles Russo

It's a bar with food next to the Pru...but better than usual. Staff is very

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Fried Calamari

Hunter Weiman

Amari gets 5 stars for on his first day, on the first time being asked, brought us our beer after fifty minutes. Three other employees were asked to look into where our drinks were, and never came back. We had to go up to the bar ourselves to buy our first round of drinks after being ignored by other employees. We finished our main courses before we got the drinks we ordered at the table. Second time here with a bad experience, and it will definitely be my last. May be better on a day in which there is no event at the Prudential Center. Godspeed.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

M A

Expensive microwave food. Easily one of the worst places I’ve ever eaten at ?

Food: 1

Sylvain Villeneuve

All the waiters looked at us without coming to see us. We had to call them out otherwise we would never have been served. Food, really average for the price. I didn't like my experience at all. The sound was way too loud. Not able to talk to each other.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

Beatriz Daza Echeverri

Is a really good place, it has everything the best bartenders it’s music, servers, I love it ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jose Mateo

Honestly, it's a bar located across the street from prudential center. Will it be packed on game day, yes. I propped up at the bar, ordered a glenlivet on the rocks and a pizza. It was a generous pour and the pizza was delicious. The waitresses were attentive and always made sure i was good. Once gametime started the place emptied quickly. I've been here a few times to pregame, and postgame and I work nearby. Patrons are always friendly and never had an issue.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More