Mulberry Street Pizza

258 Mulberry St, Newark
(973) 596-0275

Recent Reviews

R. D.

I ordered fetticini alfredo w chicken and a sausage roll . I decided to get 2 items off the menu bc i read a few bad reviews n wasnt sure if i would like my 1st option (the fetticini) & i really wanted to give this place a chance bc i work nearby and like to order for lunch w local resturants. The menu said the sausage roll is made with onions and peppers. There is absolutely no onions or peppers in this only alot of mozarella n little sausage. The fetticini was absolutely horrid and the sauce tasted like it was made with SPOILED MILK/ heavy cream. I ate maybe 3 or 4 spoonfuls of the pasta and chicken and could NOT continue, it literally made me nauseaus. I decided to eat the sausage roll and was also dissappointed. No onions, no peppers just extra mozarella and litte sausage. DO NOT EAT HERE!!! Absolutely disgusting!!...(ps forgot to take a pic of pasta, it actually didnt look bad but the taste was terrible).

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kevin L.

walked by this spot the pizza read dark hardly and cheese or tomato sauce on it just not good and all

Tamara Abu-Ramadan

Pizza was good and owner was so kind!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Selena Nava

The owner Abraham is wonderful ! Visited from CA. Better wings than Wing Stop & amazing pizza !!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Allison Linares

This place has very good service!I called to make a delivery today and they attended me very well.I order a plain large pizza,Garlic Knots and buffalo wings.The food is okay it can do better but it’s pretty decent.The Garlic knots were dry and could’ve done better but overall All service was amazing and the food as well.When they forgot something for my food they said they would quickly deliver it to me again and I really appreciated that.100% totally recommend.Amazing people and the food also Good ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Kristina Corsino

Pizza was very good and approved by the whole team for lunch. We Ordered a balsamic chicken salad, chicken Alfredo pizza, meat lovers and cheese pizza for delivery through slice App. Great communication reaching out to me when needing to substitute an item ordered. Will order again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pie

Tauri Purdie

Great pizza even better prices love the weekend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James F.

Got pizza and an antipasto salad last night. Food was great, price was right, and people are super friendly. Even after the pizza being in the box for over a 1/2 hour it was still really good. Will be back for sure!

Bill Oas

Nope. Ordered a grandmas pie from here and asked for extra sauce. Showed up with 2 little spoonfuls of sauce total. Greasy garbage pie. Honestly nothing good about it and the customer service

Food: 1

Service: 3

David M.

Good flavor but the crust needs help . Close to the cardboard pizza we used to get out of the grocery store stores.

Kylie Von Glitz

Went to see a show at Prudential Center and kept circling this pizza place. Decided to park and stop in. Wow, glad we did! The service was amazing and may have been one of the best pizza slices I’ve had. 10/10 would recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebecca Garner

It's 10:15 am most likely the first customer. Called to inquire about the pasta of the day, he proceeded to tell me he CAN'T deliver that to me, and that i have to come to the store. So I then order the chicken penne vodka pasta which is $17 he tells me my delivery order has to be over $25 and forces me to buy a drink. THAT I DID NOT WANT! The total ending up being $19..I am at a lost for words. I just wanna eat my dinner for breakfast without any problems ?‍♀️

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

OLASEGUN OLASEGUN

Oily enough to draw a smiley face on the box, nevertheless TASTY!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Rocky Wade

Me and my friends have been going here since college. The pizza is always amazing from this place and the guy behind the counter is sooo nice! He genuinely cares about the food he makes :) It’s very clean inside and lots of places to sit & overall very welcome atmosphere. Try the chicken penne vodka when you go, it’s amazing!!

Matt L.

Ordered pickup - Avery kind man took our large order patiently and we received excellent service and food.

Load More