Pizza is amazing!! I ordered a thin crust pie (well done of course) and it was cooked to perfection. The sauce has a sweet taste to it that some might not like but I think it’s awesome! The crust was crispy, a little flop, a little greasy but not over the top. I would definitely be stopping here whenever I’m in the mood for pizza. I’ve tried the other places in town and I think this might be the best one.Parking: They have a parking lot. Seems like it can get really tight if this place is ever packed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
Darius Anderson
Great tasting pizza, rich sauce, great cheese this is like a real quick bite to eat. Two slices and a soda came up to eight dollars again great pizza don’t do what I do and put your head in the window. They serve pizza out of a shake shack like a window , great pizza great service I’ll be back 5
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Linda Kwiatkowski
Ordered a thin crust pizza that arrived Black totally Burned. Called Amore who advised they are extra extra crispy. Burned is beyond extra crispy. Did not offer to replace the pizza. Will NEVER order from them. BEWARE Many other better pizzas near
Food: 1
Service: 1
melissa rogerio
I have order a regular pie on several occasions, the menu looks great and offers a bunch of different kinds. However, I’ve only got the reg pie…if you were looking for a nice well done pie, this is it. Their sauce is different than any other which makes a statement, it’s slightly sweet like moms Sunday gravy. The cheese is well done not gooey and crust is thin slight crunch to the touch it. Def one of my favs in town at the moment. Also delivery has always been super quick keeping in mind that I usually order weekdays before 5 PM.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Robert Zaragoza
First time, the slice of pizza was small, oily, not enough cheese, all there pizza in thin,
Joseph Catalano
Outstanding- the raider bar pie. The best ingredients they use and the taste of the crust is fantastic!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Price
Our new pizza spot. Going to pick up another order in about 20 minutes. Margherita is the best I’ve had in a long time if you’re into thin crust and crispy pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita
Peter Prochilo
Their Palermo pie is among the best pizza I have ever eaten.
Rodolpho R.
Great pizza but do not get delivery. Back to back times it was soupy and floppy as any pizza I've ever had delivered from anywhere. Lost my delivery business but will be back for pick up
So I’ve been here several times the first time being the best but after that it’s been disappoint after disappointment. Today I went and ordered the Nutley slice and it literally fell apart in my hand. No structure what so ever, no crisp no anything, just a soggy luke warm mess. Even folding to eat the slice wasn’t working or saving this. Also it seems that the pizzas are made differently every time. Sometimes it was a thick pan crust, other times it was thin or even just a regular basic slice but none the less it’s strange because i ask for the same two slices each time. Also they typically only have 3-4 pies out at a time to choose from and seem to more less try to recreate certain slices with what’s already out. I originally had high praise for this establishment but there seems to be a problem with consistency with how their pizza is made.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Stephanie H.
I've been searching for a good pizza spot since I moved here in April and haven't had luck until I passed by this place when I took my daughter to the park nearby. I got 2 slices to go, the Giuseppe and chicken parm, and they were surprisingly delicious! I'm used to the good pizza back in Hoboken, and I have to say this place beats some of the pizza places over there. The crust was thin and crispy yet not droopy. The sauce on the Giuseppe slice was rich and flavorful. They definitely hit the spot, and I'm looking forward to going back again!
Jeffrey N.
Stopped in for a slice (which is apparently is not the way to eat pizza in Nutley). It had all the makings of a great pizza, but it wasn't cooked enough in the first place, and then it wasn't heated enough when I ordered it. The sauce had a great flavor to it. The cheese was high quality - very smooth, rich, melted so evenly, but didn't have much flavor of its own. Despite this, it blended well with the sauce to create a very good flavor, overall. The dough was nice and thin, but not the least bit crispy. It was pale and whitish all around, and the crust was more like bread than a crust. That said, this crust had a good flavor, as well. All in all, I'd give it a 4 for flavor, minus 1 for being undercooked and soft, not crispy.I will give it another try - I'd love to see what this pizza tastes like when it is cooked through.
Jaiden D Guerrero
this pizza is really good and service is great by the way don't go to bell Paese tha place is hot as the owner bipolar and he built like a block
Gerry Pion
The Giuseppe pizza is absolutely amazing, I've never tasted anythiing like it.The variety of the pizzas, location, and parking are plusses.
Nasty greasy
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pizza is amazing!! I ordered a thin crust pie (well done of course) and it was cooked to perfection. The sauce has a sweet taste to it that some might not like but I think it’s awesome! The crust was crispy, a little flop, a little greasy but not over the top. I would definitely be stopping here whenever I’m in the mood for pizza. I’ve tried the other places in town and I think this might be the best one.Parking: They have a parking lot. Seems like it can get really tight if this place is ever packed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
Great tasting pizza, rich sauce, great cheese this is like a real quick bite to eat. Two slices and a soda came up to eight dollars again great pizza don’t do what I do and put your head in the window. They serve pizza out of a shake shack like a window , great pizza great service I’ll be back 5
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a thin crust pizza that arrived Black totally Burned. Called Amore who advised they are extra extra crispy. Burned is beyond extra crispy. Did not offer to replace the pizza. Will NEVER order from them. BEWARE Many other better pizzas near
Food: 1
Service: 1
I have order a regular pie on several occasions, the menu looks great and offers a bunch of different kinds. However, I’ve only got the reg pie…if you were looking for a nice well done pie, this is it. Their sauce is different than any other which makes a statement, it’s slightly sweet like moms Sunday gravy. The cheese is well done not gooey and crust is thin slight crunch to the touch it. Def one of my favs in town at the moment. Also delivery has always been super quick keeping in mind that I usually order weekdays before 5 PM.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
First time, the slice of pizza was small, oily, not enough cheese, all there pizza in thin,
Outstanding- the raider bar pie. The best ingredients they use and the taste of the crust is fantastic!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our new pizza spot. Going to pick up another order in about 20 minutes. Margherita is the best I’ve had in a long time if you’re into thin crust and crispy pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita
Their Palermo pie is among the best pizza I have ever eaten.
Great pizza but do not get delivery. Back to back times it was soupy and floppy as any pizza I've ever had delivered from anywhere. Lost my delivery business but will be back for pick up
Restaurantji Recommends
So I’ve been here several times the first time being the best but after that it’s been disappoint after disappointment. Today I went and ordered the Nutley slice and it literally fell apart in my hand. No structure what so ever, no crisp no anything, just a soggy luke warm mess. Even folding to eat the slice wasn’t working or saving this. Also it seems that the pizzas are made differently every time. Sometimes it was a thick pan crust, other times it was thin or even just a regular basic slice but none the less it’s strange because i ask for the same two slices each time. Also they typically only have 3-4 pies out at a time to choose from and seem to more less try to recreate certain slices with what’s already out. I originally had high praise for this establishment but there seems to be a problem with consistency with how their pizza is made.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
I've been searching for a good pizza spot since I moved here in April and haven't had luck until I passed by this place when I took my daughter to the park nearby. I got 2 slices to go, the Giuseppe and chicken parm, and they were surprisingly delicious! I'm used to the good pizza back in Hoboken, and I have to say this place beats some of the pizza places over there. The crust was thin and crispy yet not droopy. The sauce on the Giuseppe slice was rich and flavorful. They definitely hit the spot, and I'm looking forward to going back again!
Stopped in for a slice (which is apparently is not the way to eat pizza in Nutley). It had all the makings of a great pizza, but it wasn't cooked enough in the first place, and then it wasn't heated enough when I ordered it. The sauce had a great flavor to it. The cheese was high quality - very smooth, rich, melted so evenly, but didn't have much flavor of its own. Despite this, it blended well with the sauce to create a very good flavor, overall. The dough was nice and thin, but not the least bit crispy. It was pale and whitish all around, and the crust was more like bread than a crust. That said, this crust had a good flavor, as well. All in all, I'd give it a 4 for flavor, minus 1 for being undercooked and soft, not crispy.I will give it another try - I'd love to see what this pizza tastes like when it is cooked through.
this pizza is really good and service is great by the way don't go to bell Paese tha place is hot as the owner bipolar and he built like a block
The Giuseppe pizza is absolutely amazing, I've never tasted anythiing like it.The variety of the pizzas, location, and parking are plusses.