Love the pizza! And I love that they have gluten free pizza for my family members with celiac disease. But if I didn't know any better I'd think it was closed. Very dark outside, you can't see the signage.Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free pizza, and it's pretty good ??
Disappointing for sure. My 20 min pizza delivery turned into over an hour. No phone call or explanation. I called to find out that they "couldn't find my address" lol. I live in town but person that answered the phone and took my address, was clearly not the person for that job. Thought $30 was over priced for the service and pizza was just OK. Sorry, but won't be calling again.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Joseph Chiappetta
Great spot for a classic Jersey slice. Hands down the best artichoke heart franchise pizza around! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MD 3.
Pizza sauce had that deep tomato taste, dripping with mozzarella and the crust was perfectly crisp. A perfect slice. And the white pizza with broccoli was equally outstanding. On top of that they could not be friendlier. This place is awesome.
Dori D.
The pizza has a great crust! The owner is pleasant and kind. This is one of our regular " pick up a pizza" places.
Andria F.
Oakhurst Pizza is in a great location right in the heart of a bustling town with such incredible potential.Unfortunately the new owners have a lot to learn about their business and the community they are now a part of .My experience was not a very good one at all but do try to give all new owners a little leeway in every aspect of their new venture.I ordered 2 subs for pick up on a weeknight and was not just disappointed but appalled by the poor quality of the food and lack of service from the owner or employee .Honestly not sure who this person was.A regular Italian sub was so bad we could not eat it .No flavor at all, terrible bread and mayonnaise on all of it when I requested specialty No Mayonnaise. Toppings were not fresh .Simply inexcusable.Upon arrival for pick up I was ignored for several minutes by the person behind the counter.Not one other customer in the place but the man completely ignored me .Finally I found my own way to the refrigerator where my food was waiting.Still no acknowledgment whatsoever.Pizza old & dry lined the counter unappetizing to say the least. Never going back again.Hopefully things will get better soon.
Danielle
Pizza is Excellent!! Subs, sandwiches, etc. extremely good!I'm writing this though because more so are the staff. When I order from Oakhurst I don't just order for one meal. Sometimes I order a pie just to wrap up and freeze. Sometimes I order subs for lunch the next few days to take to work and my wife to bring to work and share with colleagues. I order the kids chicken parm for my dog who loves it! I recently ordered a bunch of stuff and received a half sub instead of whole. No big deal. I called and immediately was told if you stop by we'll make it for you. No question. I couldn't get there it was Christmas Eve, but tonight I put in another order and without question they included it in the delivery when I told them. How nice not to have to spend a year and a day going over the order. Good people, good food, good choice.
Melisa Alexis
Food is not good like b4 .. There new owners they wer great when they first took over now everything has changed . Prices Quality of food and lost good workers. .. Very disappointed
vinder bhandal
Best place & can not wait to visit this pizza place again!! Love the staff
Jeanayrie Adrian
Owner is so very friendly & the food is always amazing! However I recently had a bad experience where I placed an order for delivery and never received it after 2 hours of waiting. When I called the restaurant, the person on the phone was not helpful at all and basically gave me no resolution. I was eventually able to get a refund after a long hassle but this experience alone has deterred me from wanting to order from here again which is a shame.
Owner is so very friendly & the food is always amazing! However I recently had a bad experience where I placed an order for delivery and never received it after 2 hours of waiting. When I called the restaurant, the person on the phone was not helpful at all and basically gave me no resolution. I was eventually able to get a refund after a long hassle but this experience alone has deterred me from wanting to order from here again which is a shame.
Patty Flynn
I ordered a gluten free pizza and steamed broccoli. The pizza was amazing and not all gluten free is good. The broccoli was perfectly steamed with an amazing hint of garlic. The delivery person was very polite. Our order came earlier than expected. Overall a perfect experience!
kscheri
I was charged a 'convenience fee' which I have no idea how convenient picking up your own pizza is. I was also charged a Carryout fee. Its bad enough that a pizza now costs over $23 but then they add an addition $4 in BS fees. Too many other really good places to go who do not fee you for picking up your own pie. Shame on you.
Mike
Went there during my lunch shift and got a cheesesteak and fries and was very happy with it enormous portions and perfect cheese to steak ratio very tasty and great service
Titus
Been living across the street from this place for 5 years. Tried every other pizza spot around me and the pies ranged from alright, to disapointing. Finally got around to trying the pizza and WOW! This is some of the best pizza I've had in the area. The slices are thin yet aren't floppy. When you go to fold the pizza you get a beautiful snap of the nice crispy crust. Gone in here 3 weekends in a row and each time the same great quality. I used to have to drive into Red Bank to get a pizza like this but not any more!
Love the pizza! And I love that they have gluten free pizza for my family members with celiac disease. But if I didn't know any better I'd think it was closed. Very dark outside, you can't see the signage.Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free pizza, and it's pretty good ??
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Disappointing for sure. My 20 min pizza delivery turned into over an hour. No phone call or explanation. I called to find out that they "couldn't find my address" lol. I live in town but person that answered the phone and took my address, was clearly not the person for that job. Thought $30 was over priced for the service and pizza was just OK. Sorry, but won't be calling again.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Great spot for a classic Jersey slice. Hands down the best artichoke heart franchise pizza around! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza sauce had that deep tomato taste, dripping with mozzarella and the crust was perfectly crisp. A perfect slice. And the white pizza with broccoli was equally outstanding. On top of that they could not be friendlier. This place is awesome.
The pizza has a great crust! The owner is pleasant and kind. This is one of our regular " pick up a pizza" places.
Oakhurst Pizza is in a great location right in the heart of a bustling town with such incredible potential.Unfortunately the new owners have a lot to learn about their business and the community they are now a part of .My experience was not a very good one at all but do try to give all new owners a little leeway in every aspect of their new venture.I ordered 2 subs for pick up on a weeknight and was not just disappointed but appalled by the poor quality of the food and lack of service from the owner or employee .Honestly not sure who this person was.A regular Italian sub was so bad we could not eat it .No flavor at all, terrible bread and mayonnaise on all of it when I requested specialty No Mayonnaise. Toppings were not fresh .Simply inexcusable.Upon arrival for pick up I was ignored for several minutes by the person behind the counter.Not one other customer in the place but the man completely ignored me .Finally I found my own way to the refrigerator where my food was waiting.Still no acknowledgment whatsoever.Pizza old & dry lined the counter unappetizing to say the least. Never going back again.Hopefully things will get better soon.
Pizza is Excellent!! Subs, sandwiches, etc. extremely good!I'm writing this though because more so are the staff. When I order from Oakhurst I don't just order for one meal. Sometimes I order a pie just to wrap up and freeze. Sometimes I order subs for lunch the next few days to take to work and my wife to bring to work and share with colleagues. I order the kids chicken parm for my dog who loves it! I recently ordered a bunch of stuff and received a half sub instead of whole. No big deal. I called and immediately was told if you stop by we'll make it for you. No question. I couldn't get there it was Christmas Eve, but tonight I put in another order and without question they included it in the delivery when I told them. How nice not to have to spend a year and a day going over the order. Good people, good food, good choice.
Food is not good like b4 .. There new owners they wer great when they first took over now everything has changed . Prices Quality of food and lost good workers. .. Very disappointed
Best place & can not wait to visit this pizza place again!! Love the staff
Owner is so very friendly & the food is always amazing! However I recently had a bad experience where I placed an order for delivery and never received it after 2 hours of waiting. When I called the restaurant, the person on the phone was not helpful at all and basically gave me no resolution. I was eventually able to get a refund after a long hassle but this experience alone has deterred me from wanting to order from here again which is a shame.
Restaurantji Recommends
Owner is so very friendly & the food is always amazing! However I recently had a bad experience where I placed an order for delivery and never received it after 2 hours of waiting. When I called the restaurant, the person on the phone was not helpful at all and basically gave me no resolution. I was eventually able to get a refund after a long hassle but this experience alone has deterred me from wanting to order from here again which is a shame.
I ordered a gluten free pizza and steamed broccoli. The pizza was amazing and not all gluten free is good. The broccoli was perfectly steamed with an amazing hint of garlic. The delivery person was very polite. Our order came earlier than expected. Overall a perfect experience!
I was charged a 'convenience fee' which I have no idea how convenient picking up your own pizza is. I was also charged a Carryout fee. Its bad enough that a pizza now costs over $23 but then they add an addition $4 in BS fees. Too many other really good places to go who do not fee you for picking up your own pie. Shame on you.
Went there during my lunch shift and got a cheesesteak and fries and was very happy with it enormous portions and perfect cheese to steak ratio very tasty and great service
Been living across the street from this place for 5 years. Tried every other pizza spot around me and the pies ranged from alright, to disapointing. Finally got around to trying the pizza and WOW! This is some of the best pizza I've had in the area. The slices are thin yet aren't floppy. When you go to fold the pizza you get a beautiful snap of the nice crispy crust. Gone in here 3 weekends in a row and each time the same great quality. I used to have to drive into Red Bank to get a pizza like this but not any more!