Went In for the first time ever this week! The couple who owns the store do it all and the are the kindest, genuine people. Cookies were yummy. Comparable prices to a Crumble cookie but so much better. We got a dozen for about $26. We were not huge fans of OCNJ but the cookies were a favorite!
Max Dee
Crazy Susan's cookies are crazy delicious! I love all of them. The butterfinger one, the sugar one, the Reese's one, but my favorite is the Mayor. The Mayor is a fudge cookie mixed with Snicker Bar and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup and topped with a Rolo candy. It's delicious. I went to OC for vacation. Can't wait to come next year and get more! :)
Trinity K
Honestly the best cookies I’ve ever had!
Hazel G
I did baking lesson with my dad and grandma here,Awesome I'm telling you I had the most fun and Ms.Susan is so nice!!Me and my family love the cookies here 100/10
Kurt B.
I arrived home today from a busy day at work and found the nicest surprise waiting for me at home....cookies! A large box of Crazy Susan's Cookies, assorted flavors and oh boy are they good! Few things in life deliver the love and satisfaction of a great cookie and these absolutely hit the mark. So good in fact I am considering visiting Susan's store just to absorb more of that good cookie vibe. Susan's love of the craft comes shining thru on her products. A perfectly baked balance of crisp sweetness I am forever a fan - great job Crazy Susan!
Malcolm Diggs
Crazy Susan makes some amazing cookie varieties! You don't want to leave the beach without paying her shop a visit. ?
Christine S.
OMG these cookies are AMAZING!!! Susan is super friendly, down to earth, and fun!!! These cookies are sooooo good, thiccc and chunky with amazing flavors! Had the Boardwalk cookie out of the oven and it was sooo warm and gooey! If the cookies are a gift, she puts a cute little bow on the box! Can't wait to go back!
Jean cherry
I ordered a cookie cake for my granddaughter‘s 15th birthday. The whole family absolutely loved it! Susan was wonderful. We also tried a couple more of her specialty cookies and they were amazing! Thank you so much Susan for the excellent service and delicious cookie cake!
Susan may be crazy but she sure can bake. Great variety, cute little shop, very reasonably priced, and decent parking! There are so many great cookies available like oatmeal raisin and chocolate chip but also white chocolate dipped white chocolate chip cookies and reeses and kitkat cookies. There's even cookie sandwiches. There's something for everyone.
Bill D.
Excellent cookies. Lots of different ones to choose from.
Claire H.
If you want mouthwatering good cookies this is the place to go. This Hass to be one of my favorite cookie shops I've ever been to every single cookie is delicious my favorites are snickerdoodle and the sugar cookie!
Logan B.
The cookies are good and the staff is friendly. It's a shame the cookies are so highly priced--you feel guilty walking out the door instead of excited. I suppose if you're coming into town once a year, it's a bit more justifiable, but still difficult to ignore.
Michael Knoop
Delicious cookies, pleasant and friendly, love to try new varieties!
Best cookies and best people .?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yummy!!!!!!
Went In for the first time ever this week! The couple who owns the store do it all and the are the kindest, genuine people. Cookies were yummy. Comparable prices to a Crumble cookie but so much better. We got a dozen for about $26. We were not huge fans of OCNJ but the cookies were a favorite!
Crazy Susan's cookies are crazy delicious! I love all of them. The butterfinger one, the sugar one, the Reese's one, but my favorite is the Mayor. The Mayor is a fudge cookie mixed with Snicker Bar and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup and topped with a Rolo candy. It's delicious. I went to OC for vacation. Can't wait to come next year and get more! :)
Honestly the best cookies I’ve ever had!
I did baking lesson with my dad and grandma here,Awesome I'm telling you I had the most fun and Ms.Susan is so nice!!Me and my family love the cookies here 100/10
I arrived home today from a busy day at work and found the nicest surprise waiting for me at home....cookies! A large box of Crazy Susan's Cookies, assorted flavors and oh boy are they good! Few things in life deliver the love and satisfaction of a great cookie and these absolutely hit the mark. So good in fact I am considering visiting Susan's store just to absorb more of that good cookie vibe. Susan's love of the craft comes shining thru on her products. A perfectly baked balance of crisp sweetness I am forever a fan - great job Crazy Susan!
Crazy Susan makes some amazing cookie varieties! You don't want to leave the beach without paying her shop a visit. ?
OMG these cookies are AMAZING!!! Susan is super friendly, down to earth, and fun!!! These cookies are sooooo good, thiccc and chunky with amazing flavors! Had the Boardwalk cookie out of the oven and it was sooo warm and gooey! If the cookies are a gift, she puts a cute little bow on the box! Can't wait to go back!
I ordered a cookie cake for my granddaughter‘s 15th birthday. The whole family absolutely loved it! Susan was wonderful. We also tried a couple more of her specialty cookies and they were amazing! Thank you so much Susan for the excellent service and delicious cookie cake!
Restaurantji Recommends
Susan may be crazy but she sure can bake. Great variety, cute little shop, very reasonably priced, and decent parking! There are so many great cookies available like oatmeal raisin and chocolate chip but also white chocolate dipped white chocolate chip cookies and reeses and kitkat cookies. There's even cookie sandwiches. There's something for everyone.
Excellent cookies. Lots of different ones to choose from.
If you want mouthwatering good cookies this is the place to go. This Hass to be one of my favorite cookie shops I've ever been to every single cookie is delicious my favorites are snickerdoodle and the sugar cookie!
The cookies are good and the staff is friendly. It's a shame the cookies are so highly priced--you feel guilty walking out the door instead of excited. I suppose if you're coming into town once a year, it's a bit more justifiable, but still difficult to ignore.
Delicious cookies, pleasant and friendly, love to try new varieties!