Pennington Bagels has a fantastic selection of bagels, sandwiches and salads. They're Asiago, French toast and cinnamon sugar are delicious! Sandwiches made with Boar's Head are delicious and generous in size.
Gabriella
A great local bagel shop with a wide array of classic, out-of-the-box, and seasonal flavors. Above all, however, is their delicious bagel quality. We assessed the quality of their Plain Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese to other local bagel shops, and they came out on top due to their incredible texture and flavor. Service is timely and welcoming, while the food is inexpensive. Would highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jersey Guy
A wide variety of very good bagels and spreads. And very good coffee.! The main problem: no grill. So, an egg sandwich is cooked in a microwave.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Egg Salad, Everything Bagel with Extra Cream Cheese, Sesame Bagel, Egg Everything Bagel, Turkey Sandwich
Valyriansteelproductions
Great service, portions and bagels cinnamon rasin French toast is to die for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Adam Jankos
I ordered a turkey sandwich on a plain bagel, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and bacon.It came with coleslaw and pickles. I also got kettle cooked sea salt chips and got a raspberry Snapple iced tea. I must say the sandwich was incredibly delicious. I’m pretty sure they make their own coleslaw and it was perfect. Not sure what kind of pickles they use, but they were better than your average pickle. And not spears. All the ingredients tasted very fresh, Including the turkey. And for some reason everything didn’t slide out when I took a bite into the sandwich. Although it was Sunday at 1:30 PM, I barely waited 2 minutes. I think they do a great job over there and I will definitely be back.
Earl Grell
Tasty but the porkroll is cut so this you can see through it! Pricey for paper thin porkroll and microwaved eggs. ??♂️
黃郁
It was sometims good but sometimes just ok
Marshall Moses
Love their selection of bagels that they Offer
Robin Sanchez
Food is delicious & well worth it overall store is nice, the husband is friendly & courteous. The wife & sister is very racists towards African Americans & rude with nasty attitudes!
Pretty good, tho they use a little too much cream cheese, like it feels like it's a bust explosion in my mouth every time I take a bite man
Ryan L.
If you feel like waiting 35 minutes in line for a place that microwaves their eggs then this is the place for you!!!
Franci Williams
My fiancé and I stopped in for breakfast this morning and I'm so happy that we did! I got the sugared blueberry bagel with cinnamon raisin walnut cream cheese and my fiancé got an everything bagel with bacon, egg and cheese on it, the bagels were fresh and so flavorful!!! I will definitely be back!!
Steven P.
Bagels are fresh and you can order ahead on their App. Bagels are bugger tan mist places. asiago is a favorite
T J
The food is still good, but charging a 1.15 for lettuce? And a 1.15 for a slice of tomato? I get inflation, but they also make you pay a surcharge for using a card.
Good bagels but prices are very high
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Pennington Bagels has a fantastic selection of bagels, sandwiches and salads. They're Asiago, French toast and cinnamon sugar are delicious! Sandwiches made with Boar's Head are delicious and generous in size.
A great local bagel shop with a wide array of classic, out-of-the-box, and seasonal flavors. Above all, however, is their delicious bagel quality. We assessed the quality of their Plain Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese to other local bagel shops, and they came out on top due to their incredible texture and flavor. Service is timely and welcoming, while the food is inexpensive. Would highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
A wide variety of very good bagels and spreads. And very good coffee.! The main problem: no grill. So, an egg sandwich is cooked in a microwave.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Egg Salad, Everything Bagel with Extra Cream Cheese, Sesame Bagel, Egg Everything Bagel, Turkey Sandwich
Great service, portions and bagels cinnamon rasin French toast is to die for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I ordered a turkey sandwich on a plain bagel, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and bacon.It came with coleslaw and pickles. I also got kettle cooked sea salt chips and got a raspberry Snapple iced tea. I must say the sandwich was incredibly delicious. I’m pretty sure they make their own coleslaw and it was perfect. Not sure what kind of pickles they use, but they were better than your average pickle. And not spears. All the ingredients tasted very fresh, Including the turkey. And for some reason everything didn’t slide out when I took a bite into the sandwich. Although it was Sunday at 1:30 PM, I barely waited 2 minutes. I think they do a great job over there and I will definitely be back.
Tasty but the porkroll is cut so this you can see through it! Pricey for paper thin porkroll and microwaved eggs. ??♂️
It was sometims good but sometimes just ok
Love their selection of bagels that they Offer
Food is delicious & well worth it overall store is nice, the husband is friendly & courteous. The wife & sister is very racists towards African Americans & rude with nasty attitudes!
Restaurantji Recommends
Pretty good, tho they use a little too much cream cheese, like it feels like it's a bust explosion in my mouth every time I take a bite man
If you feel like waiting 35 minutes in line for a place that microwaves their eggs then this is the place for you!!!
My fiancé and I stopped in for breakfast this morning and I'm so happy that we did! I got the sugared blueberry bagel with cinnamon raisin walnut cream cheese and my fiancé got an everything bagel with bacon, egg and cheese on it, the bagels were fresh and so flavorful!!! I will definitely be back!!
Bagels are fresh and you can order ahead on their App. Bagels are bugger tan mist places. asiago is a favorite
The food is still good, but charging a 1.15 for lettuce? And a 1.15 for a slice of tomato? I get inflation, but they also make you pay a surcharge for using a card.