I got a pizza with mushrooms that came out dry and tasted like frozen pizza ! Terrible! I ordered a shrimp cocktail that came warm not cold as usual !Then they charge two dollars to use my card ! This stop is done !
Van Feliciano
DO NOT. I REPEAT. DO NOT. ORDER DELIVERY.This review is ONLY based on pick up or dine in.The sauce is amazing. The well done crust...just superb. This place does not lack in flavor or a local vibe when it comes to delicious local food at an affordable price.I love their daily regular slices with a pepsi or ginger ale. You cant beat $6 every day.I have had the 1/2 trays here and at Harbor Lights for reference and they are both identical. I love the wings and the regular spaghetti w/ garlic is a great side dish for any picky eater.I often stop in on weekdays and NEVER order delivery on the weekends.I made the mistake of ordering a marg pie on an early Saturday afternoon.As I finish these last sentences, Ive been outside for 120 minutes and my pizza still hasnt arrived.
chuck kII
Pizza is always good and i live in ny just drive here for work and the meatballs were some of the best I ever had pasta is also a good choice
Richard Sladek
Slowest service I have ever had for a pizza we were dining in arrived at 7.32 it is now 854 still not out and we were only tables when we walked in..bunch kids that are clueless
tony baloney
Pizza was terrible and horrible very soft like a sponge wasn't my money & time when I was there ? 6.1 zero stars ? taste no taste Crust the like a super soft sponge ?
Yamilla wallace
Their large pie is only 14” I’m very disappointed especially due to the pricing.
Patrick Blacer
The pizza is terrible it's a precooked pie with this sweet sauce not for me or the other 7 ppl that was eating this pizza everybody was in agreement & asked me where i order from so we dont make the same mistake again !!!!! I order-(5)- pies-(2)-with chicken it was like they just threw the chicken in the air & wherever it landed it stayed !!! This was like ordering from Pizza Hut but more expensive for the size of there so called large pies !!! The worst $95.00 I ever spent for pizza !!! Absolutely Terrible
J Rod
Very good pizza. Tastes sweet
Jean wiegmann
Ordered food to go. The girl taking the order could not get the order right. I made her repeat it three times. When we picked it up three employees said we all checked it. It’s correct. We drove home and of course I was missing two dinners. Unbelievable. TheBest part is when I called them they tried to give me A gift certificate to make it up. Are you kidding me you charged me for meals I didn’t even receive. Then she had a problem apparently getting the credit back on my credit card. And after all that is said and done you think they would’ve given me a free meal or something for the inconvenience. They did nothing. Her response was I did all I can. No you didn’t. The customer service is terrible. And food has gone downhill. Don’t order.
Absolutely delicious pizza, has a sweet traditional Italian sauce. BARSTOOL PIZZA WAS WRONG on his grading!...........I give it 9 only because if the pizza was made the original way (it was charcoal fired pizza) it would be a 10, but still tasty.............I had a plain cheese with onions. The onions taste great with this type of pizza. Delicioso?
Aaron H.
Even though it's a 20 minute drive, I always come here when I need to pick up a pizza or two. The sauce is distinctly sweet, and the crisp thin crust really sets this pie apart from the typical strip mall fare you'll find in Edison. That being said, on certain occasions (only sometimes!) the crust has been a bit thin and saturated in the middle of the pie. Overall though, this place is worth a visit.
Maritza Tejada
Today 10/06/21 @ 1:15pm, worst person taking orders. I leave the date and time so if the owners were to read this, they will know exactly who the person was answering the phone and taking orders on this day. Rude doesn’t begin to cover it. She sounded like this was a chore and bothersome to have to do her job. Shame because the young man who usually takes the phone orders is so nice; a total 180. Been a great customer of them since the original Scorintino’s. Won’t order from there until either she is retrained or doesn’t answer the phone at all. But if you are looking for great pizza this is your place.
xo.erika
very unprofessional i placed a order at 5:25 they said a 40 minute wait, i called again at 7:03 and they said supposedly “the driver left” i never got a call or my food. don’t eat here.
Michealene Roberts
I don’t like that all their pizzas are precooked.They just warm um in the oven. You can see them all on the carts .I ordered one they took it off the cart warmed it in oven for that I could buy a frozen one. South Amboy does the same .Ordered a pie it was out in 4 minutes you don’t cook a pie in four minutes!!
I got a pizza with mushrooms that came out dry and tasted like frozen pizza ! Terrible! I ordered a shrimp cocktail that came warm not cold as usual !Then they charge two dollars to use my card ! This stop is done !
DO NOT. I REPEAT. DO NOT. ORDER DELIVERY.This review is ONLY based on pick up or dine in.The sauce is amazing. The well done crust...just superb. This place does not lack in flavor or a local vibe when it comes to delicious local food at an affordable price.I love their daily regular slices with a pepsi or ginger ale. You cant beat $6 every day.I have had the 1/2 trays here and at Harbor Lights for reference and they are both identical. I love the wings and the regular spaghetti w/ garlic is a great side dish for any picky eater.I often stop in on weekdays and NEVER order delivery on the weekends.I made the mistake of ordering a marg pie on an early Saturday afternoon.As I finish these last sentences, Ive been outside for 120 minutes and my pizza still hasnt arrived.
Pizza is always good and i live in ny just drive here for work and the meatballs were some of the best I ever had pasta is also a good choice
Slowest service I have ever had for a pizza we were dining in arrived at 7.32 it is now 854 still not out and we were only tables when we walked in..bunch kids that are clueless
Pizza was terrible and horrible very soft like a sponge wasn't my money & time when I was there ? 6.1 zero stars ? taste no taste Crust the like a super soft sponge ?
Their large pie is only 14” I’m very disappointed especially due to the pricing.
The pizza is terrible it's a precooked pie with this sweet sauce not for me or the other 7 ppl that was eating this pizza everybody was in agreement & asked me where i order from so we dont make the same mistake again !!!!! I order-(5)- pies-(2)-with chicken it was like they just threw the chicken in the air & wherever it landed it stayed !!! This was like ordering from Pizza Hut but more expensive for the size of there so called large pies !!! The worst $95.00 I ever spent for pizza !!! Absolutely Terrible
Very good pizza. Tastes sweet
Ordered food to go. The girl taking the order could not get the order right. I made her repeat it three times. When we picked it up three employees said we all checked it. It’s correct. We drove home and of course I was missing two dinners. Unbelievable. TheBest part is when I called them they tried to give me A gift certificate to make it up. Are you kidding me you charged me for meals I didn’t even receive. Then she had a problem apparently getting the credit back on my credit card. And after all that is said and done you think they would’ve given me a free meal or something for the inconvenience. They did nothing. Her response was I did all I can. No you didn’t. The customer service is terrible. And food has gone downhill. Don’t order.
Went downhill. Horrible customer service
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely delicious pizza, has a sweet traditional Italian sauce. BARSTOOL PIZZA WAS WRONG on his grading!...........I give it 9 only because if the pizza was made the original way (it was charcoal fired pizza) it would be a 10, but still tasty.............I had a plain cheese with onions. The onions taste great with this type of pizza. Delicioso?
Even though it's a 20 minute drive, I always come here when I need to pick up a pizza or two. The sauce is distinctly sweet, and the crisp thin crust really sets this pie apart from the typical strip mall fare you'll find in Edison. That being said, on certain occasions (only sometimes!) the crust has been a bit thin and saturated in the middle of the pie. Overall though, this place is worth a visit.
Today 10/06/21 @ 1:15pm, worst person taking orders. I leave the date and time so if the owners were to read this, they will know exactly who the person was answering the phone and taking orders on this day. Rude doesn’t begin to cover it. She sounded like this was a chore and bothersome to have to do her job. Shame because the young man who usually takes the phone orders is so nice; a total 180. Been a great customer of them since the original Scorintino’s. Won’t order from there until either she is retrained or doesn’t answer the phone at all. But if you are looking for great pizza this is your place.
very unprofessional i placed a order at 5:25 they said a 40 minute wait, i called again at 7:03 and they said supposedly “the driver left” i never got a call or my food. don’t eat here.
I don’t like that all their pizzas are precooked.They just warm um in the oven. You can see them all on the carts .I ordered one they took it off the cart warmed it in oven for that I could buy a frozen one. South Amboy does the same .Ordered a pie it was out in 4 minutes you don’t cook a pie in four minutes!!