This pizzaria is a local NJ chai with multiple family owned locations in central Jersey. They have great options for pizza by the slice, with their square slices standing out. In this they have a few varieties - grandma with fresh garlic, jersey that's slightly tangy from the tomatoes and spicy from the crushed peppers in the sauce and margarita which is tomato basil mozzarella. The crust on the square slice gets nice and crispy when heated. The garlic knots with sauce are also very tasty full of fresh garlic and parsley. Service is friendly and prompt, and ambiance is typical of a NJ pizza spot.
Amir golpoor
Charged 8$ for 2 plain slices , that says it all
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Samurai Buddies
Very tasty pizza with an amazing staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
David Ambio
Panatieri's Piscataway stands out with an extensive selection of slices, including standout options like Cheesesteak and Buffalo Chicken. While some slices might lean towards the drier side, a simple request for extra sauce easily elevates the experience. The diverse range of choices, from Sicilian to sausage or meatball, ensures there's something for everyone. Despite potential lunchtime crowds, the variety and unique touch Panatieri's brings make it a worthwhile dining experience.Parking: Plenty of parking
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak Pizza
M M
Paid $30 for a large Stromboli and Snapple. Picked up the box to leave and the box was flimsy and couldn’t hold the weight of the sauce container they put inside and the large Stromboli so it bent and the food and sauce container fell on the floor. They refused to make another one. The woman saw the box bend. Just poor service. Me and my family won’t ever order from here again.
Service: 1
D S.
I ordered a large Stromboli, and when I was walking out the door, the flimsy box bent, and it fell to the floor. The sauce container and large Stromboli was too heavy for the box and they would not make me another one. Literally just spent $30 on a Stromboli and Snapple super poor customer service. Lost a customer...Won't be coming back
Zee C.
Wanted to try a new place so on my lunch went to this place and thought the pizza would be good. Not the case . Had a slice of pepperoni,sausage and it look like ham on it . It had no flavor tasteless. Ran me bout $5.16 for the slice. Was not impressed wont be back .
Farzin Motamedi
Small town pizzeria with big city pizzeria attitude (in the price department)!Pizza is good but $5/slice is too much for anywhere in Jersey unless you have some truffle hidden under the cheese, which I doubt.Slices are thin crust (I like) so if you usually eat two, here you’d need minimum of 3 slices to be full.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Peter Habib
I almost never write reviews for places I go to but this time I feel I have to. I found this place on Doordash and I found a dish that I liked. So I call in to make a simple order with one entree. A couple minutes later, I get a call back from them saying that they substitute one of the main ingredients. This was the first things that pissed me off. Next, I go to the place to get my food. They charge me almost ten dollars more than what it said on Doordash! Instead of paying $14, I ended up paying $23!! She didn't say the price on the phone. If she did, I would not have made the order. To make matters worse, they made it with a ton of sauce and they put it in an aluminum container in a brown bag. The sauce leaked out of the bag into my car. By the time I got home, the sauce was spilling onto the floor. I called her about the price and the woman was rude and impatient while I kept calm the whole time. In the end, after all that, the food wasn't even that good... I eat takeout every day and have been for years and I can say confidently, it is by far the worst experience I've ever ever had!!!Edit: they gave me two tiny loaves of white bread that appear to be burnt. Just gets worse and worse...Edit#2: The bread was so awful I actually spit it out. Never remember spitting out bread before in my life. Ugh.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Allison Curras
Instead of ordering two plain slices, I orders a "personal pie" to go figuring it would be fresh AND a bit more pizza. What I received was more like a "kids" size pizza (about 9" across)..... Was caught off-guard when I got back to my office with it intending to share with a coworker and this little pie was almost $13.85 and less than/MAYBE barely equal to 2 slices worth of pizza....Pizza was tasty but for the value, definitely not worth it.
Never going here ever again. big disappointment.. i even asked for a fork and the lady in the glasses looked at me like disgusted or something and i did not like her attitude at all. I suggest you guys improve your customer service..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Aurelia Blount
I just received my pie that was ordered and brought home. This has to be thee worst pizza pie I've ever seen. I definitely will not order from them anymore!!!
Gera Cruz
Very expensive 23 $for 4 slices and a drink , cold pizza , not friendly , rushing , never again respectfully . No hospitality . Just a hard no for me . Did not like my experience . Don’t
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
John Ahn
This place has changed so much. It used the be great pizza and busy. Now they charge $5 a slice for a 1 topping pizza that was just ok.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Starr O'Pearl
Although the cashier was quite sweet and attentive, the food tasted quite disgusting. It wasn’t fresh and reeked of old oil. The Buffalo chicken wings were tough and rubbery…almost inedible like they had been refried or reheated multiple times and the sauce tasted rancid. The burger…although it looked nice…the patty was atrocious…hard rubbery and again, inedible. The fries tasted like they were fried in weeks old oil.Stick to having a slice of pizza and beware of the other food items. Others in my party had ill reviews as well and after eating it, I even felt sick to my stomach. A waste of over 30.00 for a burger/fries and wings.
This pizzaria is a local NJ chai with multiple family owned locations in central Jersey. They have great options for pizza by the slice, with their square slices standing out. In this they have a few varieties - grandma with fresh garlic, jersey that's slightly tangy from the tomatoes and spicy from the crushed peppers in the sauce and margarita which is tomato basil mozzarella. The crust on the square slice gets nice and crispy when heated. The garlic knots with sauce are also very tasty full of fresh garlic and parsley. Service is friendly and prompt, and ambiance is typical of a NJ pizza spot.
Charged 8$ for 2 plain slices , that says it all
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Very tasty pizza with an amazing staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Panatieri's Piscataway stands out with an extensive selection of slices, including standout options like Cheesesteak and Buffalo Chicken. While some slices might lean towards the drier side, a simple request for extra sauce easily elevates the experience. The diverse range of choices, from Sicilian to sausage or meatball, ensures there's something for everyone. Despite potential lunchtime crowds, the variety and unique touch Panatieri's brings make it a worthwhile dining experience.Parking: Plenty of parking
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak Pizza
Paid $30 for a large Stromboli and Snapple. Picked up the box to leave and the box was flimsy and couldn’t hold the weight of the sauce container they put inside and the large Stromboli so it bent and the food and sauce container fell on the floor. They refused to make another one. The woman saw the box bend. Just poor service. Me and my family won’t ever order from here again.
Service: 1
I ordered a large Stromboli, and when I was walking out the door, the flimsy box bent, and it fell to the floor. The sauce container and large Stromboli was too heavy for the box and they would not make me another one. Literally just spent $30 on a Stromboli and Snapple super poor customer service. Lost a customer...Won't be coming back
Wanted to try a new place so on my lunch went to this place and thought the pizza would be good. Not the case . Had a slice of pepperoni,sausage and it look like ham on it . It had no flavor tasteless. Ran me bout $5.16 for the slice. Was not impressed wont be back .
Small town pizzeria with big city pizzeria attitude (in the price department)!Pizza is good but $5/slice is too much for anywhere in Jersey unless you have some truffle hidden under the cheese, which I doubt.Slices are thin crust (I like) so if you usually eat two, here you’d need minimum of 3 slices to be full.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I almost never write reviews for places I go to but this time I feel I have to. I found this place on Doordash and I found a dish that I liked. So I call in to make a simple order with one entree. A couple minutes later, I get a call back from them saying that they substitute one of the main ingredients. This was the first things that pissed me off. Next, I go to the place to get my food. They charge me almost ten dollars more than what it said on Doordash! Instead of paying $14, I ended up paying $23!! She didn't say the price on the phone. If she did, I would not have made the order. To make matters worse, they made it with a ton of sauce and they put it in an aluminum container in a brown bag. The sauce leaked out of the bag into my car. By the time I got home, the sauce was spilling onto the floor. I called her about the price and the woman was rude and impatient while I kept calm the whole time. In the end, after all that, the food wasn't even that good... I eat takeout every day and have been for years and I can say confidently, it is by far the worst experience I've ever ever had!!!Edit: they gave me two tiny loaves of white bread that appear to be burnt. Just gets worse and worse...Edit#2: The bread was so awful I actually spit it out. Never remember spitting out bread before in my life. Ugh.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Instead of ordering two plain slices, I orders a "personal pie" to go figuring it would be fresh AND a bit more pizza. What I received was more like a "kids" size pizza (about 9" across)..... Was caught off-guard when I got back to my office with it intending to share with a coworker and this little pie was almost $13.85 and less than/MAYBE barely equal to 2 slices worth of pizza....Pizza was tasty but for the value, definitely not worth it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Never going here ever again. big disappointment.. i even asked for a fork and the lady in the glasses looked at me like disgusted or something and i did not like her attitude at all. I suggest you guys improve your customer service..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I just received my pie that was ordered and brought home. This has to be thee worst pizza pie I've ever seen. I definitely will not order from them anymore!!!
Very expensive 23 $for 4 slices and a drink , cold pizza , not friendly , rushing , never again respectfully . No hospitality . Just a hard no for me . Did not like my experience . Don’t
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
This place has changed so much. It used the be great pizza and busy. Now they charge $5 a slice for a 1 topping pizza that was just ok.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Although the cashier was quite sweet and attentive, the food tasted quite disgusting. It wasn’t fresh and reeked of old oil. The Buffalo chicken wings were tough and rubbery…almost inedible like they had been refried or reheated multiple times and the sauce tasted rancid. The burger…although it looked nice…the patty was atrocious…hard rubbery and again, inedible. The fries tasted like they were fried in weeks old oil.Stick to having a slice of pizza and beware of the other food items. Others in my party had ill reviews as well and after eating it, I even felt sick to my stomach. A waste of over 30.00 for a burger/fries and wings.