They have awesome customer service skills and will customize orders to make it however you ask. Their food is consistently good and they are always kind! They also support the local schools and fundraisers! Thank you very much Red Star Staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jess Peroni
The Caprese Salad is just one of the things that I love from Red Star Pizza! It always made amazingly and they always give me great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Morgan
Great little spot got the buffalo chicken cheese steak it was delicious ?
Not bad but the trick is to ask for thin crust and extra herbs and spices. Otherwise it will be bland.
Tim Casaday
Food is good and quick.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Cheese Pizza
Renée Bowe
The takeout here is the best in new Egypt. Food arrived hot. Large sandwiches are enough for two meals. Soup is good. Chicken parm and cheese steaks are good. Even the small house salad is good. They didn’t cheap out on ingredients and their food is basic, and good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Rich Bendock
Normally, I am not in this area was passing by and pulled in to have a slice.. some of the best pizza ever had
Tiffany Turcotte
Don't order grilled chicken on slow days got food poisoning from a chicken ceser salad.The Eggplant rollatini made with mystery coldcut?? If it ain't pizza it's probly wack af.
Sieglinde “Siggy” Kuehn
It was just an average pizza, not great but not bad. Toppings were well distributed.
Natalie
Delicious! Nice staff too! Their salads are always fresh. Pizza is delicious (and I'm not a huge pizza lover) and wings are awesome! Subs are very good too!
Since Anthony sold the place many years ago I wouldn't have given this place a 2star review let alone a 4star, however, the quality of the food recently has been really good.
Kurt Gibbons
I have been going here about 4 years when I am in the area. This is hands down the best pizza in New Jersey. Perfect sauce, cheese, no flop, fast, service, and great prices. Very happy. The owners and staff are always really nice. I wish there was one of these in my town down in Atlantic County.
Sarah Purcell
Taste wasn’t bad.. but the soup was about 3 full bites then the rest broth and minced veggies. Wasn’t super happy with the sampler platter either..proportions was a rip off with the chicken fingers for (3) chicken fingers (3) poppers (3)wings and (3) mozzarella sticks. Also ordered for delivery..was told 40 minutes…took about 1 and half hours. Which is cool if maybe a phone call was made or the food was hot on arrival.
Michael Dalton
Great food great customer service. Only remark. The old way you used to do your garlic knots rocked. Decent amount of oil and lots of fresh garlic. If the change is due to increased prices, hey I get it. If it’s just bc you changed prep methods….may wanna revert to the old way.
Firefom
The pizza had to much sauce. Otherwise it was decent.
They have awesome customer service skills and will customize orders to make it however you ask. Their food is consistently good and they are always kind! They also support the local schools and fundraisers! Thank you very much Red Star Staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Caprese Salad is just one of the things that I love from Red Star Pizza! It always made amazingly and they always give me great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great little spot got the buffalo chicken cheese steak it was delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Chicken Parm
Not bad but the trick is to ask for thin crust and extra herbs and spices. Otherwise it will be bland.
Food is good and quick.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Cheese Pizza
The takeout here is the best in new Egypt. Food arrived hot. Large sandwiches are enough for two meals. Soup is good. Chicken parm and cheese steaks are good. Even the small house salad is good. They didn’t cheap out on ingredients and their food is basic, and good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Normally, I am not in this area was passing by and pulled in to have a slice.. some of the best pizza ever had
Don't order grilled chicken on slow days got food poisoning from a chicken ceser salad.The Eggplant rollatini made with mystery coldcut?? If it ain't pizza it's probly wack af.
It was just an average pizza, not great but not bad. Toppings were well distributed.
Delicious! Nice staff too! Their salads are always fresh. Pizza is delicious (and I'm not a huge pizza lover) and wings are awesome! Subs are very good too!
Restaurantji Recommends
Since Anthony sold the place many years ago I wouldn't have given this place a 2star review let alone a 4star, however, the quality of the food recently has been really good.
I have been going here about 4 years when I am in the area. This is hands down the best pizza in New Jersey. Perfect sauce, cheese, no flop, fast, service, and great prices. Very happy. The owners and staff are always really nice. I wish there was one of these in my town down in Atlantic County.
Taste wasn’t bad.. but the soup was about 3 full bites then the rest broth and minced veggies. Wasn’t super happy with the sampler platter either..proportions was a rip off with the chicken fingers for (3) chicken fingers (3) poppers (3)wings and (3) mozzarella sticks. Also ordered for delivery..was told 40 minutes…took about 1 and half hours. Which is cool if maybe a phone call was made or the food was hot on arrival.
Great food great customer service. Only remark. The old way you used to do your garlic knots rocked. Decent amount of oil and lots of fresh garlic. If the change is due to increased prices, hey I get it. If it’s just bc you changed prep methods….may wanna revert to the old way.
The pizza had to much sauce. Otherwise it was decent.