It cost us $43 for a mediocre pizza with *canned* mushrooms…what a rip off! We are never eating here ever again.
Erica Chidichimo
We love coming to Joey Tomato's! It's icing on the cake to our Jersey Shore day. No one does it better than their incredible & friendly staff. "Aunt" Doreen IS. THE. BEST. We are family every time we walk in. The pizza is perfect every time. We even make special trips in the off season when the boardwalk is chilly & a tasty hot slice is just what you need. Forget the rest, Joey Tomato's is THE BEST!Kid-friendliness: They even use the pizza cutter to slice up my kids pizza before even bringing it to the table. So sweet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Eric Bobowicz
Really delicious pizza with an incredibly friendly staff. Super clean and a great view of boardwalk traffic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Conroy
I came here and bought two slices of pizza was CHARGED and the owner told me to leave that they were closed and I never got my pizza he was so rude. Will never go back here ever again!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kayla W
Absolute scam with their prices. $36 for a plain pie and $7 fountain drinks with no refills is
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
George G.
service was horrible i'm a coptic orthodox christian i'm fasting for church and asked for no cheese and since it was the same price i asked for cheese on the side for the pizza and he yelled at us. I am very mad.
Alyson M.
Marginal pizza (at best) and the staff is unhelpful and unfriendly. So many other choices within walking distance. Choose another. Skip this for sure.
Paul Clayton
Always like go in there. When I go to the beach great pizza staff is always friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Claudia S.
Yes the pizza was good but C'mon $7 for a slice of pizza!! Not even a big slice! Complete rip off!
Not authentic pizza. Basic carnival pizza. $58 for 3 slices, 2 sodas, and a small salad that I had to throw out, because it had such a bad taste that I felt it could cause food poison . On top of that, they said that the bathroom was "out of service", which means..."we dont feel like cleaning it, so we say it's out of order". Never going back again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tajas Bhavsar
Price gouging at the fullest. Whole pie + 1 specialty slice + 1 large drink + 2 medium drinks = $78!!!! You should be ashamed of yourselves. I understand costs will be higher than usual but come on now.You should be ashamed of yourselves.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Robert Zaentz
On 7/8/2023, we ordered (2) standard-sized slices of plain cheese pizza, (2) standard-sized slices of broccoli pizza, and (1) 16oz. bottle of cold Minute-Maid yellow lemonade. On a positive note, the pizza slices arrived fairly quick, and were extremely hot out of the oven. The pizza slices tasted quite good, and were on par as far as quality goes with other reputable pizzerias. Sadly, the down side of Joey Tomato's was the ridiculously high pricing of $32.83 for such a small amount of food. According to their prices which are definitely not consumer friendly, even a plain cheese pizza pie by itself costs over $35.00, and forget about adding extra toppings which will really "break the bank". Talk about "price-gouging". That was the biggest "turn-off" to dining at Joey Tomato's. The 2-STAR rating is not for food quality, but rather for charging astronomical prices for their food. Joey Tomato's really should address this "issue" in order to improve their currently low GOOGLE 3.8 rating score.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tina F.
Listen. Yes it's pricey. Everything is at Jenkinson's. EVERYTHING. The question is, are you going to spend your money at Joey Tomato's or somewhere else?! I'm always going to go to JT. The service is good. These are kids working a summer job 9 times out of ten. I'll never understand the complaints lol. The atmosphere is that of a Jersey boardwalk. If you didn't come for that, you're in the wrong place. The pizza here is EPIC. Pizza Hut is literally gross next to what they serve here. Been eating at Joey Tomato's since I was a kid. We'll def be back. And I live 5 hours away LOL Thank you Joe! See you next time!
Joe K.
Best slice in point pleasant. You can complain about the price, but it's listed for all to see. I don't understand how people order a pie, then complain about how expensive it was. Worth the money. Much better than other pizza you can find at the point pleasant boardwalk. Been 100 times will be back 100 times more!
Very very great pizza.very very good Pizza dough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It cost us $43 for a mediocre pizza with *canned* mushrooms…what a rip off! We are never eating here ever again.
We love coming to Joey Tomato's! It's icing on the cake to our Jersey Shore day. No one does it better than their incredible & friendly staff. "Aunt" Doreen IS. THE. BEST. We are family every time we walk in. The pizza is perfect every time. We even make special trips in the off season when the boardwalk is chilly & a tasty hot slice is just what you need. Forget the rest, Joey Tomato's is THE BEST!Kid-friendliness: They even use the pizza cutter to slice up my kids pizza before even bringing it to the table. So sweet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Really delicious pizza with an incredibly friendly staff. Super clean and a great view of boardwalk traffic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I came here and bought two slices of pizza was CHARGED and the owner told me to leave that they were closed and I never got my pizza he was so rude. Will never go back here ever again!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Absolute scam with their prices. $36 for a plain pie and $7 fountain drinks with no refills is
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
service was horrible i'm a coptic orthodox christian i'm fasting for church and asked for no cheese and since it was the same price i asked for cheese on the side for the pizza and he yelled at us. I am very mad.
Marginal pizza (at best) and the staff is unhelpful and unfriendly. So many other choices within walking distance. Choose another. Skip this for sure.
Always like go in there. When I go to the beach great pizza staff is always friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Yes the pizza was good but C'mon $7 for a slice of pizza!! Not even a big slice! Complete rip off!
Restaurantji Recommends
Not authentic pizza. Basic carnival pizza. $58 for 3 slices, 2 sodas, and a small salad that I had to throw out, because it had such a bad taste that I felt it could cause food poison . On top of that, they said that the bathroom was "out of service", which means..."we dont feel like cleaning it, so we say it's out of order". Never going back again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Price gouging at the fullest. Whole pie + 1 specialty slice + 1 large drink + 2 medium drinks = $78!!!! You should be ashamed of yourselves. I understand costs will be higher than usual but come on now.You should be ashamed of yourselves.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
On 7/8/2023, we ordered (2) standard-sized slices of plain cheese pizza, (2) standard-sized slices of broccoli pizza, and (1) 16oz. bottle of cold Minute-Maid yellow lemonade. On a positive note, the pizza slices arrived fairly quick, and were extremely hot out of the oven. The pizza slices tasted quite good, and were on par as far as quality goes with other reputable pizzerias. Sadly, the down side of Joey Tomato's was the ridiculously high pricing of $32.83 for such a small amount of food. According to their prices which are definitely not consumer friendly, even a plain cheese pizza pie by itself costs over $35.00, and forget about adding extra toppings which will really "break the bank". Talk about "price-gouging". That was the biggest "turn-off" to dining at Joey Tomato's. The 2-STAR rating is not for food quality, but rather for charging astronomical prices for their food. Joey Tomato's really should address this "issue" in order to improve their currently low GOOGLE 3.8 rating score.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Listen. Yes it's pricey. Everything is at Jenkinson's. EVERYTHING. The question is, are you going to spend your money at Joey Tomato's or somewhere else?! I'm always going to go to JT. The service is good. These are kids working a summer job 9 times out of ten. I'll never understand the complaints lol. The atmosphere is that of a Jersey boardwalk. If you didn't come for that, you're in the wrong place. The pizza here is EPIC. Pizza Hut is literally gross next to what they serve here. Been eating at Joey Tomato's since I was a kid. We'll def be back. And I live 5 hours away LOL Thank you Joe! See you next time!
Best slice in point pleasant. You can complain about the price, but it's listed for all to see. I don't understand how people order a pie, then complain about how expensive it was. Worth the money. Much better than other pizza you can find at the point pleasant boardwalk. Been 100 times will be back 100 times more!