Today was my first visit and the pizza was amazing especially the buffalo chicken pizza. I met Alex and staff very polite. I live in old bridge but the drive was definitely worth it. I believe I found my new go to for pizza. The sitting area was clean overall a great experience.
Matthew Weisser
Absolutely incredible experience with Michelino's every time. This specific review is regarding a recent order I made for 30 pizzas for a school event (I'm a teacher). John was incredibly helpful, giving, and even stayed open late so I could get all the pizzas and bring them for our overnight event. He cares about the community and he cares about the quality of his food and service. The pizza is amazing, the service is amazing, and I couldn't be more grateful!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alvin S.
The pizza is very good, many varieties of pizza if you like your pizza with different ingredients. The service was very good, the workers have very positive attitude. And there are many condiments if you like to add spices to your pizza.
Adrian Caba
John and the team are amazing genuine people . They really care about the food and service they provide . I will forever go to them for pizza if I live in Rahway or when I’m in the area .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robin D. Sutton
My Son & I love this place! The staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
skł
Awesome Place! Owner was a very sweet and funny guy. God Bless Him! - Aiden and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan G.
Excellent food and above and beyond customer service John did a special order for us. Amazing dinner! can't wait to go back thank you
NoPosts
the workers where very nice and helpful shout out to the workers aaliyah and patrick and there manger alex there where very kind to help me choose what to eat especially this being my first time going here we even took a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jimmy P.
Best Garlic Knots I've ever had, pizza is solid and the staff is really nice. Multiple good pizza places in the area but Michelino's is definitely worth a try!
T Warner
The service and hospitality was spot on. My family visited after a basketball tournament in the area. The pizza was great and the cheesesteak was good. The chicken Ceasars salad was probably one of the best I've ever had. Will definitely return when we're in the area.
Tucked away in Rahway, this charming pizzeria captivated us the moment we stepped in, seeking a slice each. Greeted warmly by who we believe was Michelino, possibly the owner, the ambiance instantly won us over. The decor, quintessentially pizzeria with a touch of elegance, from the thoughtfully placed decorations to the perfectly balanced dim lighting, made for a cozy yet vibrant setting for delightful conversations and dining pleasure. The proprietor, a figure of kindness, humility, and warmth, personally served our food, adding a special touch to the already stellar service. It's rare to find such attentive service in a pizzeria, and it left us pleasantly surprised. Despite a tough crowd, it's bewildering how this gem hasn't secured a 4-star rating at the very least. Our large slices were nothing short of spectacular. The sauce, perfectly seasoned, complemented the high-quality ingredients without being overpowering or overly greasy. While the pricing might be on the higher side, the exceptional service more than makes up for it. We left with a sense of gratitude for having discovered this place and are eagerly looking forward to our next visit. It's a delightful spot that truly deserves recognition. Thanks!
Lisa L.
Love their pizza. Owner is a super nice guy. I always order from them. I'm obsessed with their sauce. Always good!
Vanessa Sprouse
It’s always a great experience and pleasure to eating and working with Michelino’s! I don’t know where to start. My kids and their friends goes here twice a week after school! They enjoy hanging out! And the owner!! Mr John! He loves the kids and community!! We appreciate your donation for the football and cheer banquet!! You went above and beyond!! Thank you so much!!! From the Rahway Chiefs Cheer And Football organization!!
Who would’ve thought that as a vegan, I could find the best vegan pizza, Stromboli and “chicken” parm right in my own backyard? Where I used to visit as a teenager after school? Hands down, John and his team are working magic with their vegan options. I get to enjoy countless vegan options, and my husband gets to live his best life with their massive non-vegan menu. These guys are bringing harmony to my household ? The service is also above and beyond. I’m slightly out of their delivery range but they have been happy to trek out to me since I just had a baby and couldn’t get there myself.Pro tip: get their vegan Stromboli with their vegan sausage ?Next time: I’m investing into the vegan SicilianBonus: I’m using their pizza as my monthly order for my son’s milestone photos.Vegetarian options: If you’re vegan, come here. If you’re not vegan, still come here.Dietary restrictions: Vegan heaven
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan
Natty C.
Came for a slice. Very casual place. It was good. I believe it was $3.75 for a buffalo chicken slice.
Today was my first visit and the pizza was amazing especially the buffalo chicken pizza. I met Alex and staff very polite. I live in old bridge but the drive was definitely worth it. I believe I found my new go to for pizza. The sitting area was clean overall a great experience.
Absolutely incredible experience with Michelino's every time. This specific review is regarding a recent order I made for 30 pizzas for a school event (I'm a teacher). John was incredibly helpful, giving, and even stayed open late so I could get all the pizzas and bring them for our overnight event. He cares about the community and he cares about the quality of his food and service. The pizza is amazing, the service is amazing, and I couldn't be more grateful!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is very good, many varieties of pizza if you like your pizza with different ingredients. The service was very good, the workers have very positive attitude. And there are many condiments if you like to add spices to your pizza.
John and the team are amazing genuine people . They really care about the food and service they provide . I will forever go to them for pizza if I live in Rahway or when I’m in the area .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My Son & I love this place! The staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome Place! Owner was a very sweet and funny guy. God Bless Him! - Aiden and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food and above and beyond customer service John did a special order for us. Amazing dinner! can't wait to go back thank you
the workers where very nice and helpful shout out to the workers aaliyah and patrick and there manger alex there where very kind to help me choose what to eat especially this being my first time going here we even took a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Garlic Knots I've ever had, pizza is solid and the staff is really nice. Multiple good pizza places in the area but Michelino's is definitely worth a try!
The service and hospitality was spot on. My family visited after a basketball tournament in the area. The pizza was great and the cheesesteak was good. The chicken Ceasars salad was probably one of the best I've ever had. Will definitely return when we're in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Tucked away in Rahway, this charming pizzeria captivated us the moment we stepped in, seeking a slice each. Greeted warmly by who we believe was Michelino, possibly the owner, the ambiance instantly won us over. The decor, quintessentially pizzeria with a touch of elegance, from the thoughtfully placed decorations to the perfectly balanced dim lighting, made for a cozy yet vibrant setting for delightful conversations and dining pleasure. The proprietor, a figure of kindness, humility, and warmth, personally served our food, adding a special touch to the already stellar service. It's rare to find such attentive service in a pizzeria, and it left us pleasantly surprised. Despite a tough crowd, it's bewildering how this gem hasn't secured a 4-star rating at the very least. Our large slices were nothing short of spectacular. The sauce, perfectly seasoned, complemented the high-quality ingredients without being overpowering or overly greasy. While the pricing might be on the higher side, the exceptional service more than makes up for it. We left with a sense of gratitude for having discovered this place and are eagerly looking forward to our next visit. It's a delightful spot that truly deserves recognition. Thanks!
Love their pizza. Owner is a super nice guy. I always order from them. I'm obsessed with their sauce. Always good!
It’s always a great experience and pleasure to eating and working with Michelino’s! I don’t know where to start. My kids and their friends goes here twice a week after school! They enjoy hanging out! And the owner!! Mr John! He loves the kids and community!! We appreciate your donation for the football and cheer banquet!! You went above and beyond!! Thank you so much!!! From the Rahway Chiefs Cheer And Football organization!!
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Wings, Sauce, Plain Pizza, Garlic Bread
Who would’ve thought that as a vegan, I could find the best vegan pizza, Stromboli and “chicken” parm right in my own backyard? Where I used to visit as a teenager after school? Hands down, John and his team are working magic with their vegan options. I get to enjoy countless vegan options, and my husband gets to live his best life with their massive non-vegan menu. These guys are bringing harmony to my household ? The service is also above and beyond. I’m slightly out of their delivery range but they have been happy to trek out to me since I just had a baby and couldn’t get there myself.Pro tip: get their vegan Stromboli with their vegan sausage ?Next time: I’m investing into the vegan SicilianBonus: I’m using their pizza as my monthly order for my son’s milestone photos.Vegetarian options: If you’re vegan, come here. If you’re not vegan, still come here.Dietary restrictions: Vegan heaven
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan
Came for a slice. Very casual place. It was good. I believe it was $3.75 for a buffalo chicken slice.