Very nice cozy decor. Fish special was very tasty but very small portion. Crab cakes were just ok but I am really picky. The short ribs were the fave of the table. Server was very attentive. Owner visited tables and was really friendly which today is rare professionalism. Cappuccinos were great. BYOB which we love. We will be back.
lyndacyprus
Congrats on the new room! It is beautiful and soothing...and the noise level is perfect! So many restaurants these days are deafening! The food is exquisite, the wait staff does a phenomenal job and the Marcello is, as always, charming. One of our very favorite places to dine....and that's a short list :)
Cynthia Soriano
Came here to try the place on Valentine's Day to check if it would be a nice place to celebrate my birthday the following week with friends and family. The atmosphere is just okay. The staff is friendly and the service is nothing out of the ordinary and/or as expected of a fancy restaurant but my main issue is that the menu is very limited and unfamiliar. My husband ordered the braised short ribs over mashed sweet potato (the type of potato which he doesn't like and doesn't really go with braised short ribs) and I ordered the steak with blue cheese on top but I expected the blue cheese to be melting and drizzling over the meat but it wasn't the case (it was thick and just sat on top of the meat). Decided not to go back the following week as there wasn't a lot of choice for the guests. Went to RP Prime in Mahwah instead and everyone was happy.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Mark Mazzella
Great BYOB with outstanding dishes from appetizers through main courses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were very pleased with our first visit to Bici. The food was delicious (the homemade pasta is a must), excellent, helpful and friendly service all in a beautiful environment. We will definitely be back.
Jennifer Sedgley
Amazing food and service! I highly recommend Bici, especially if you are looking to host an intimate private event!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food simply put, amazing! You can taste every single ingredient because it is so fresh. We were waited on by Ray, awesome service and dishes were paced adequately. One of the owners, Marcelo,took the time to talk to us and explained how the delivery of fish, meat and vegetables takes place. We went on a Tuesday evening, and all but 2 tables were occupied. Can't wait to go back and try another phenomenal dish!
Once again, we had a terrific meal and the service was gracious all always. It is always a pleasure to dine out on a Monday when sometimes choices are limiting. This is one of the go-to's in the area.
What a terrific restaurant. Great food, service, and atmosphere. We went here on a night where there was a large table. Usually at other restaurants that has not been a good sign, but the owner and the waitress were so attentive and friendly and accommodating that we barely noticed the large group right next to us. The food was phenomenal. I eat gluten and dairy free and they made me one incredible dish after another. I haven't been so full since I used to be at my mother in law's Italian Sunday dinner table. Don't hesitate to book Bici.
ALWAYS a wonderful experience at Bici! Whether it's your first time or you're a regular, you're made to feel welcome. It's top of the line food with a relaxed and comfortable, but elegant, atmosphere. The owner, Marcello, is friendly and warm to everyone, the waiters are wonderful, and the food is perfect! I brought my friend and she equated the Sunday Gravy to the one her Grandmother from Italy makes! Fish is always fresh and cooked to perfection. Salads are delicious. For dessert, the peanut butter semi-fredo is something I dream about.
This restaurant is consistently great! The food quality and service is exceptional. The owner (Marcelo) always checks in at each table. Such personalized service. Can't wait to go back. 
Neil Hertzman
The Risotto and pasta are top notch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Barrata Salad, Braised Short Ribs over Sweet Potato and Halibut w Kalamata Olive Tapenade
Michael R.
We live nearby but had never tried Bici Restaurant. We thoroughly enjoyed dining at Bici. Everything was done correctly and well. We wanted to go to a more upscale restaurant and Bici did not disappoint. We plan to return regularly. 5 of 5 stars.
Chris A.
Dined in at Bici recently with a small group... Bici is definitely 5+ Stars here on Yelp. Cute, warmly decorated, BYOB on Main Street . Loved the lighting! The room was nice & dim but they use this small light that gives plenty of light at the table. Great ambiance. (FYI-- the are expanding by taking over the closed business next door) Our server was very friendly; she knew the menu well, and was happy to suggest options. One of the owners ( Marcelo) stopped by to check on us. Super nice, professional, yet humble which is very refreshing. THE FOOD-- Absolutely fantastic! Menu was not too big and not too small. ( approx 8 apps or salads; 6 HOMEMADE pastas; 5 entrees, 5 desserts) And still I had a hard time choosing as everything sounded so good. so here we go ..... Apps - --Salad of Roasted Beets -- made with goat cheese, baby arugula, shaved fennel, white truffle vinaigrette, & walnuts......is now one of my favorite salads anywhere. I would buy bottles of this salad dressing if they sold it. Nice portion for an app salad. I also heard the meatballs (Polpette) were very good. But what really got the table's praise ( as we shared) was the Polenta fries with a 3-cheese dipping sauce. Perfectly, lightly fried to an airy crisp with a sauce was that decadently satisfying yet not thick and gooey. Our order was perfecto! Entrees- --I had the Chianti Risotto -- made with shaved black truffle, grana padano, & truffle oil after asking the server (they also offered a Spinach & Roasted Garlic Risotto made with warm burrata, marinara, & grana as well. My Chianti Risotto also had porcini mushroom and was excellent. Perfectly cooked and a nice sized portion too. There is one entree I want to get back to try : Cherry Braised Short Ribs --made with honey mashed sweet potato, red wine & sour cherry jus, & fried onions. Now doesn't that sound special? I was told all desserts are made in house;. The carrot cake was a nice de-lish slab of confectionery comfort. The Beignets with a chocolate hazelnut sauce was also the talk of the table. I had the Napolean pastry made with Meyer lemon and Chantilly cream that went great with my perfect cup of coffee Americana. ( other options were a Lavender panna cotta and a version of creme brulee). Bici is great on all major points ( ambiance, service, and food) and I cannot wait to go back. I highly recommend !
MonicaF
Bici is always a delicious meal. And I am so grateful for how well they accommodate and understand my gluten allergy. They make eating out for me enjoyable and delicious. Thank you!!
Very nice cozy decor. Fish special was very tasty but very small portion. Crab cakes were just ok but I am really picky. The short ribs were the fave of the table. Server was very attentive. Owner visited tables and was really friendly which today is rare professionalism. Cappuccinos were great. BYOB which we love. We will be back.
Congrats on the new room! It is beautiful and soothing...and the noise level is perfect! So many restaurants these days are deafening! The food is exquisite, the wait staff does a phenomenal job and the Marcello is, as always, charming. One of our very favorite places to dine....and that's a short list :)
Came here to try the place on Valentine's Day to check if it would be a nice place to celebrate my birthday the following week with friends and family. The atmosphere is just okay. The staff is friendly and the service is nothing out of the ordinary and/or as expected of a fancy restaurant but my main issue is that the menu is very limited and unfamiliar. My husband ordered the braised short ribs over mashed sweet potato (the type of potato which he doesn't like and doesn't really go with braised short ribs) and I ordered the steak with blue cheese on top but I expected the blue cheese to be melting and drizzling over the meat but it wasn't the case (it was thick and just sat on top of the meat). Decided not to go back the following week as there wasn't a lot of choice for the guests. Went to RP Prime in Mahwah instead and everyone was happy.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Great BYOB with outstanding dishes from appetizers through main courses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were very pleased with our first visit to Bici. The food was delicious (the homemade pasta is a must), excellent, helpful and friendly service all in a beautiful environment. We will definitely be back.
Amazing food and service! I highly recommend Bici, especially if you are looking to host an intimate private event!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food simply put, amazing! You can taste every single ingredient because it is so fresh. We were waited on by Ray, awesome service and dishes were paced adequately. One of the owners, Marcelo,took the time to talk to us and explained how the delivery of fish, meat and vegetables takes place. We went on a Tuesday evening, and all but 2 tables were occupied. Can't wait to go back and try another phenomenal dish!
Once again, we had a terrific meal and the service was gracious all always. It is always a pleasure to dine out on a Monday when sometimes choices are limiting. This is one of the go-to's in the area.
What a terrific restaurant. Great food, service, and atmosphere. We went here on a night where there was a large table. Usually at other restaurants that has not been a good sign, but the owner and the waitress were so attentive and friendly and accommodating that we barely noticed the large group right next to us. The food was phenomenal. I eat gluten and dairy free and they made me one incredible dish after another. I haven't been so full since I used to be at my mother in law's Italian Sunday dinner table. Don't hesitate to book Bici.
ALWAYS a wonderful experience at Bici! Whether it's your first time or you're a regular, you're made to feel welcome. It's top of the line food with a relaxed and comfortable, but elegant, atmosphere. The owner, Marcello, is friendly and warm to everyone, the waiters are wonderful, and the food is perfect! I brought my friend and she equated the Sunday Gravy to the one her Grandmother from Italy makes! Fish is always fresh and cooked to perfection. Salads are delicious. For dessert, the peanut butter semi-fredo is something I dream about.
Restaurantji Recommends
This restaurant is consistently great! The food quality and service is exceptional. The owner (Marcelo) always checks in at each table. Such personalized service. Can't wait to go back. 
The Risotto and pasta are top notch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Barrata Salad, Braised Short Ribs over Sweet Potato and Halibut w Kalamata Olive Tapenade
We live nearby but had never tried Bici Restaurant. We thoroughly enjoyed dining at Bici. Everything was done correctly and well. We wanted to go to a more upscale restaurant and Bici did not disappoint. We plan to return regularly. 5 of 5 stars.
Dined in at Bici recently with a small group... Bici is definitely 5+ Stars here on Yelp. Cute, warmly decorated, BYOB on Main Street . Loved the lighting! The room was nice & dim but they use this small light that gives plenty of light at the table. Great ambiance. (FYI-- the are expanding by taking over the closed business next door) Our server was very friendly; she knew the menu well, and was happy to suggest options. One of the owners ( Marcelo) stopped by to check on us. Super nice, professional, yet humble which is very refreshing. THE FOOD-- Absolutely fantastic! Menu was not too big and not too small. ( approx 8 apps or salads; 6 HOMEMADE pastas; 5 entrees, 5 desserts) And still I had a hard time choosing as everything sounded so good. so here we go ..... Apps - --Salad of Roasted Beets -- made with goat cheese, baby arugula, shaved fennel, white truffle vinaigrette, & walnuts......is now one of my favorite salads anywhere. I would buy bottles of this salad dressing if they sold it. Nice portion for an app salad. I also heard the meatballs (Polpette) were very good. But what really got the table's praise ( as we shared) was the Polenta fries with a 3-cheese dipping sauce. Perfectly, lightly fried to an airy crisp with a sauce was that decadently satisfying yet not thick and gooey. Our order was perfecto! Entrees- --I had the Chianti Risotto -- made with shaved black truffle, grana padano, & truffle oil after asking the server (they also offered a Spinach & Roasted Garlic Risotto made with warm burrata, marinara, & grana as well. My Chianti Risotto also had porcini mushroom and was excellent. Perfectly cooked and a nice sized portion too. There is one entree I want to get back to try : Cherry Braised Short Ribs --made with honey mashed sweet potato, red wine & sour cherry jus, & fried onions. Now doesn't that sound special? I was told all desserts are made in house;. The carrot cake was a nice de-lish slab of confectionery comfort. The Beignets with a chocolate hazelnut sauce was also the talk of the table. I had the Napolean pastry made with Meyer lemon and Chantilly cream that went great with my perfect cup of coffee Americana. ( other options were a Lavender panna cotta and a version of creme brulee). Bici is great on all major points ( ambiance, service, and food) and I cannot wait to go back. I highly recommend !
Bici is always a delicious meal. And I am so grateful for how well they accommodate and understand my gluten allergy. They make eating out for me enjoyable and delicious. Thank you!!