Excellent pizza! Great vodka slice and the detroit thick slick is awesome!
Chuck Kravil
Had a slice of the grandma’s pizza and it was the best pizza I have had in almost 45 years. Highly recommend to anyone visiting Red Bank!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Buio
Awful vibes, over priced pizza and then they’ll not treat you nice while they serve it ?? are you kidding? atleast pretend you’re happy to be getting business ???idk
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Renee Dillon
Multiple issues with this place. I gave it 2 tries, as I don't believe in judging a place by once experience. This second attempt was the nail in the coffin. The first time I came here the pizza and rice balls were so bad I threw the entire thing in the garage. It was simply inedible between taste and texture. This second time around I had the pizza and it was edible, just pretty basic. The problem was the management. Every time I had an interaction with the manager who was also the counter help, I felt annoyed. This person was a bit overbearing and did not make me feel comfortable there. She actually asked me to hand her my trash when I was still sitting, barely finished my meal and not ready to leave. In order to do this I would have to get up and hand her my garbage. In what restaurant does the patron gather their own trash and walk their trash to the counter to hand it to the waitress, over the counter glass above the food . If you want to clear the table, come get it and remove it from the table. Then I got a cheeky attitude from her afterward. For a place this expensive and food this mid to poor, the least you can do is be pleasant and accommodating. I will never step foot in this place again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
John DeNatale
We had a private event at Sally's Boys on Friday night, February 9th. It was absolutely fantastic. It was the perfect kickoff for our Son's 21st birthday celebration with 20-22 of his friends.Special thanks to Jeremy and Tracie who made it all possible. Tracie took care of the regular patrons downstairs, while Jeremy focused on getting our excited hungry group well fed. He made multiple trips upstairs-what a champ!We started with the delicious rice balls and they quickly disappeared. The refreshing Nice salad and Caesar salad were served next, accompanied by BBQ and Buffalo wings. Not one wing was left behind.A variety of "16" neighborhood pies followed:ClassicBianca with shaved garlicConcetta's Chicken parmigianaMaria's meatball parmigianaTony's Way (so good, we ordered a second one)Vincent's vodka56 slices gone within minutes. Everyone enjoyed every bite.We are so grateful to Jeremy, Tracie and the entire Sally's Boys staff. Our Son, Giovanni was so happy. That's priceless. We're looking forward to our next visit.Sorry, no photos. I didn't move fast enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Neighbourhood Pizza, Caesar Salad, Nice Salad
Shawn A.
Decent pizza but $6 for a slice of plain cheese!? fugetabowdit!!! Good luck surviving with that business model. I'll go to Mr slice for 2.99 thankyou very much.
Fa P.
This place is waist of time and money. I did my or by phone before 45 minutes, and went there and i waited for more 20 minutes, and the lady was very unprofessional. I will never go there anymore. Even for free food.
chris n
Too much cheese, soggy, burnt, and overpriced.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mike S.
Pros: The staff is friendly, the place is cleanCons: the pizza is terrible, it's very expensive for not great foodI've been three times... Once I had reheated slices, the other times I ordered ahead. All of the pizza I had was borderline bad.
I drive hours for this Amazing food!!! So many delicious slices and more. Buffalo slice with blue cheese is just the right amount of crispy and packed with heft and flavors!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angelica A.
Trash! Not good at all. Tastes like Sbarro Pizza with a hefty price. The only good thing about this spot is that they stay open late to feed a late night cravings. One and done... never returning. 4 slices $28
Danielle Schardinger
I almost cried at paying over $8 for a single slice of cheese Sicilian style. If $6 I still would have been shocked. And pay attention to the placement of percentages for tipping on their machine. Sneaky. I get it, quality ingredients blah blah but that flour better have been milled by the Pope himself, the cow milked for cheese by the Pope himself and the tomatoes picked by the damn Pope himself for prices that high. Never again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
The Mazzuccas
Was very disappointed , first of all $8.53 for a plain slice ??? I almost walked out right there but I wanted to see what slice could cost this much . I was as disappointed in the quality as I was the price !! It was a soggy mess , it was falling apart on me on my first bite !! This will be my first and only time going there .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brandon E.
Ok is exactly right for this. I was excited to try this place. I came in with my daughter on a Wednesday night. I will say the people there were very friendly. But overall I probably won't return. The price here is really just ridiculous. I got 2 slices and a small bar pie for my daughter, it was over $25. The slices were $8 each...are you kidding? Sure they are thicker crust, kind of like a sicilian pie. But, they were small and definitely not worth that price tag. The little bar pie was good for a 6 year old, that was thin crust.The flavor was ok, I got the buffalo and vodka chicken, they were good. Not $8 each good, half that good. I think the hoagies were $18. While they were nice, there's just no way I'd come back here with the rest of the fam when I could get a full meal for the same price. I wish them the best but I'll skip it.
good food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza! Great vodka slice and the detroit thick slick is awesome!
Had a slice of the grandma’s pizza and it was the best pizza I have had in almost 45 years. Highly recommend to anyone visiting Red Bank!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awful vibes, over priced pizza and then they’ll not treat you nice while they serve it ?? are you kidding? atleast pretend you’re happy to be getting business ???idk
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Multiple issues with this place. I gave it 2 tries, as I don't believe in judging a place by once experience. This second attempt was the nail in the coffin. The first time I came here the pizza and rice balls were so bad I threw the entire thing in the garage. It was simply inedible between taste and texture. This second time around I had the pizza and it was edible, just pretty basic. The problem was the management. Every time I had an interaction with the manager who was also the counter help, I felt annoyed. This person was a bit overbearing and did not make me feel comfortable there. She actually asked me to hand her my trash when I was still sitting, barely finished my meal and not ready to leave. In order to do this I would have to get up and hand her my garbage. In what restaurant does the patron gather their own trash and walk their trash to the counter to hand it to the waitress, over the counter glass above the food . If you want to clear the table, come get it and remove it from the table. Then I got a cheeky attitude from her afterward. For a place this expensive and food this mid to poor, the least you can do is be pleasant and accommodating. I will never step foot in this place again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
We had a private event at Sally's Boys on Friday night, February 9th. It was absolutely fantastic. It was the perfect kickoff for our Son's 21st birthday celebration with 20-22 of his friends.Special thanks to Jeremy and Tracie who made it all possible. Tracie took care of the regular patrons downstairs, while Jeremy focused on getting our excited hungry group well fed. He made multiple trips upstairs-what a champ!We started with the delicious rice balls and they quickly disappeared. The refreshing Nice salad and Caesar salad were served next, accompanied by BBQ and Buffalo wings. Not one wing was left behind.A variety of "16" neighborhood pies followed:ClassicBianca with shaved garlicConcetta's Chicken parmigianaMaria's meatball parmigianaTony's Way (so good, we ordered a second one)Vincent's vodka56 slices gone within minutes. Everyone enjoyed every bite.We are so grateful to Jeremy, Tracie and the entire Sally's Boys staff. Our Son, Giovanni was so happy. That's priceless. We're looking forward to our next visit.Sorry, no photos. I didn't move fast enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Neighbourhood Pizza, Caesar Salad, Nice Salad
Decent pizza but $6 for a slice of plain cheese!? fugetabowdit!!! Good luck surviving with that business model. I'll go to Mr slice for 2.99 thankyou very much.
This place is waist of time and money. I did my or by phone before 45 minutes, and went there and i waited for more 20 minutes, and the lady was very unprofessional. I will never go there anymore. Even for free food.
Too much cheese, soggy, burnt, and overpriced.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pros: The staff is friendly, the place is cleanCons: the pizza is terrible, it's very expensive for not great foodI've been three times... Once I had reheated slices, the other times I ordered ahead. All of the pizza I had was borderline bad.
Restaurantji Recommends
I drive hours for this Amazing food!!! So many delicious slices and more. Buffalo slice with blue cheese is just the right amount of crispy and packed with heft and flavors!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trash! Not good at all. Tastes like Sbarro Pizza with a hefty price. The only good thing about this spot is that they stay open late to feed a late night cravings. One and done... never returning. 4 slices $28
I almost cried at paying over $8 for a single slice of cheese Sicilian style. If $6 I still would have been shocked. And pay attention to the placement of percentages for tipping on their machine. Sneaky. I get it, quality ingredients blah blah but that flour better have been milled by the Pope himself, the cow milked for cheese by the Pope himself and the tomatoes picked by the damn Pope himself for prices that high. Never again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Was very disappointed , first of all $8.53 for a plain slice ??? I almost walked out right there but I wanted to see what slice could cost this much . I was as disappointed in the quality as I was the price !! It was a soggy mess , it was falling apart on me on my first bite !! This will be my first and only time going there .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ok is exactly right for this. I was excited to try this place. I came in with my daughter on a Wednesday night. I will say the people there were very friendly. But overall I probably won't return. The price here is really just ridiculous. I got 2 slices and a small bar pie for my daughter, it was over $25. The slices were $8 each...are you kidding? Sure they are thicker crust, kind of like a sicilian pie. But, they were small and definitely not worth that price tag. The little bar pie was good for a 6 year old, that was thin crust.The flavor was ok, I got the buffalo and vodka chicken, they were good. Not $8 each good, half that good. I think the hoagies were $18. While they were nice, there's just no way I'd come back here with the rest of the fam when I could get a full meal for the same price. I wish them the best but I'll skip it.