A birthday dinner for my wife turned out to be almost a private party as there were only two other people in the restaurant. Our server Elaine was attentive and pleasant, service was excellent and our meals were great!
LizA
A beautiful view greets you and wonderful service to accompany a great dinner. The shrimp cocktail was massive! The wine selections by the glass are varied and lovely and the bottle menu is well put together. The best part was the seafood pot pie..
CharlesC
I was glad that the Molly Pitcher Inn has a restaurant. The food was quite good! My Husband was especially impressed with the Black Russian cocktail he ordered. We were impressed with the food and service at the Molly Pitcher Dining Room.
Host area is never very friendly and often come across as snotty. They always seem annoyed and never say “good bye” or “thank you” when we leave. When calling to confirm appointment they seemed almost annoyed. The boys pouring water and clearing tables have exceptional manners. They should be training the hostesses to be honest. We used to come frequently but now only as a last resort due to the poor hostess service. Waitress was fine. Nothing memorable.
KathyL
Was really looking forward to the Eggs Benedict, but the hollandaise sauce was very runny and unappealing. Hoping they just had an off day because I always enjoyed in the past. Otherwise had a lovely time
AudreyL
The Molly Pitcher Inn dining was superb. A bit expensive but I guess you get what you pay for. The Filet Mignon was one of the most tender and delicious filet I ever ate. The onion soup was not salty as I was pleasantly surprised. All and all my three guests enjoyed what they had. Audrey
Bill07731
Another wonderful Sunday Brunch at the Molly Pitcher Dining Room. The food was excellent, with a great menu from which to choose. The service, as always, was "five star." Wonderful ambiance and a fine view of the river. I highly recommend this venue for brunch.
EDcW
I heard about the Molly Pitcher, it had a good reputation. I found it to be very mediocre. We started with the oysters, very small barely there in the shell. My husband drink was the Sangria tasted like fruit punch. I had the scallops, they were very good. My husband ordered the pot pie on par with Marie Collanders. I do recommend the dessert of apple crumble.
Ronjj
This is a beautiful restaurant that serves a varied menu of wonderfully prepared food. Our cocktails were very well made . Service w as excellent an d the wait staff was extremely attentive. All in all a great dining experience in an elegant atmosphere.
Paul
They have both a regular menu and a prix fix menu. My appetizer (salad), main course (lamb chops), and dessert (warm apple cobbler) each had a variety of ingredients with different tastes and shapes, all of which went together wonderfully. Their list of wines by the glass is short, but the Pinot Noir that I had went perfectly with the meal. The meal was accompanied by very nice, but not obtrusive, piano music coming from the bar area.
The Molly Pitcher Dining room never disappoints. The service and food are always wonderful and it has a beautiful view. We celebrated my mother's 95th and 96th birthdays here and she was thrilled.
cookie
Dining room was beautiful, and the view of the water was perfect. Service was good and the food was wonderful with one exception. The gingerbread cake dessert was dry and hard, and the sauce described to come with. It was only painted. On the dish bottom so to speak. If there had been more of it, perhaps the gingerbread would've been more palpable. Otherwise, the experience was wonderful. 
JackieS
I have eaten here for years, and unfortunately it is just passable food now. The chef has some strange ideas about how food should be prepared. We love the ambiance but we're not happy with the food.
Ronjj
This is a lovely dining room that offers a very varied and interesting menu with generous portions. Cocktails were well made and the wine menu is wonderful. Service was impeccable, well paced and the servers were friendly and did an excellent job. The atmosphere and decor are elegant reminders of what older, beautiful dining rooms and bar should be. All in all a wonderful dining experience
MER356
It was a nice selection but not worth the 76.00 per person.Also had to purchase your own soda and ice tea.I can see having to pay additional for alcohol. Service was not great.We sat waiting for someone to come to our table and I had to clear some of the dishes myself The room and view was lovely but doubt we will ever go there again for Christmas dinner.
A birthday dinner for my wife turned out to be almost a private party as there were only two other people in the restaurant. Our server Elaine was attentive and pleasant, service was excellent and our meals were great!
A beautiful view greets you and wonderful service to accompany a great dinner. The shrimp cocktail was massive! The wine selections by the glass are varied and lovely and the bottle menu is well put together. The best part was the seafood pot pie..
I was glad that the Molly Pitcher Inn has a restaurant. The food was quite good! My Husband was especially impressed with the Black Russian cocktail he ordered. We were impressed with the food and service at the Molly Pitcher Dining Room.
Host area is never very friendly and often come across as snotty. They always seem annoyed and never say “good bye” or “thank you” when we leave. When calling to confirm appointment they seemed almost annoyed. The boys pouring water and clearing tables have exceptional manners. They should be training the hostesses to be honest. We used to come frequently but now only as a last resort due to the poor hostess service. Waitress was fine. Nothing memorable.
Was really looking forward to the Eggs Benedict, but the hollandaise sauce was very runny and unappealing. Hoping they just had an off day because I always enjoyed in the past. Otherwise had a lovely time
The Molly Pitcher Inn dining was superb. A bit expensive but I guess you get what you pay for. The Filet Mignon was one of the most tender and delicious filet I ever ate. The onion soup was not salty as I was pleasantly surprised. All and all my three guests enjoyed what they had. Audrey
Another wonderful Sunday Brunch at the Molly Pitcher Dining Room. The food was excellent, with a great menu from which to choose. The service, as always, was "five star." Wonderful ambiance and a fine view of the river. I highly recommend this venue for brunch.
I heard about the Molly Pitcher, it had a good reputation. I found it to be very mediocre. We started with the oysters, very small barely there in the shell. My husband drink was the Sangria tasted like fruit punch. I had the scallops, they were very good. My husband ordered the pot pie on par with Marie Collanders. I do recommend the dessert of apple crumble.
This is a beautiful restaurant that serves a varied menu of wonderfully prepared food. Our cocktails were very well made . Service w as excellent an d the wait staff was extremely attentive. All in all a great dining experience in an elegant atmosphere.
They have both a regular menu and a prix fix menu. My appetizer (salad), main course (lamb chops), and dessert (warm apple cobbler) each had a variety of ingredients with different tastes and shapes, all of which went together wonderfully. Their list of wines by the glass is short, but the Pinot Noir that I had went perfectly with the meal. The meal was accompanied by very nice, but not obtrusive, piano music coming from the bar area.
Restaurantji Recommends
The Molly Pitcher Dining room never disappoints. The service and food are always wonderful and it has a beautiful view. We celebrated my mother's 95th and 96th birthdays here and she was thrilled.
Dining room was beautiful, and the view of the water was perfect. Service was good and the food was wonderful with one exception. The gingerbread cake dessert was dry and hard, and the sauce described to come with. It was only painted. On the dish bottom so to speak. If there had been more of it, perhaps the gingerbread would've been more palpable. Otherwise, the experience was wonderful. 
I have eaten here for years, and unfortunately it is just passable food now. The chef has some strange ideas about how food should be prepared. We love the ambiance but we're not happy with the food.
This is a lovely dining room that offers a very varied and interesting menu with generous portions. Cocktails were well made and the wine menu is wonderful. Service was impeccable, well paced and the servers were friendly and did an excellent job. The atmosphere and decor are elegant reminders of what older, beautiful dining rooms and bar should be. All in all a wonderful dining experience
It was a nice selection but not worth the 76.00 per person.Also had to purchase your own soda and ice tea.I can see having to pay additional for alcohol. Service was not great.We sat waiting for someone to come to our table and I had to clear some of the dishes myself The room and view was lovely but doubt we will ever go there again for Christmas dinner.