Ice Cream Charlie's

200 Park Ave, Rutherford
(201) 939-8133

Recent Reviews

Joe

I was here this past week and had some of the best Oreo ice cream that Ive had in a long time. On top of that the service was very good. My only complaint is that it’s 2024 and they still don’t accept debit card/apple pay . Regardless they get 5 stars & I would take this ice cream over the Dairy Queen down the block any day !!!

Tony G.

Love their ice cream. Much better then that dirty Dairy Queen. Service is great and the people are friendly.

Miluzka Lopez Lavi

Delicious ice cream but only accept

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rob M

Great local ice cream shop with some staple flavors and many seasonal varieties.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cherry Italian Ice, Kiddie Cone with Sprinkles

Kate Herman

NOT FAMILY FRIENDLY!!!! Staff YELLED at my 3-year old child for touching a decoration ONE time during our visit. Appalling behavior toward someone else's child.We used to come here once a week and will never return.There's a sign posted "do not let children run around the store" - very off-putting to be so against children at a town ice cream parlor.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tyler A.

This is the prototypical "mom and pop" ice cream shop of a different time, and I love that. This place knows what it is and what it does well, and that's missing from a lot of places these days. The shop has a vast selection of home-made flavors all neatly displayed, along with in-shop seating. The shop is clean and well-organized and the staff are polite, kind, and helpful. The ice cream is excellent. Very rich and flavorful. There is something for everyone flavor-wise, and I am a huge fan of the Banana Chunk. Prices are relatively similar to other shops of this type. Know going in that they only accept cash. Recommended for your next ice cream fix!

Kate H.

NOT FAMILY FRIENDLY!!! Staff YELLED at my 3-year old child for touching a decoration ONE time during our visit. Appalling behavior toward someone else's child. We used to come here once a week and will never return. There's a sign posted "do not let children run around the store" - very off-putting to be so against children at a town ice cream parlor.

Ryan V.

Awesome little ice cream shop. They use quality ingredients in their handmade custom flavors. I got a regular cup and could barely finish half of it (they really pack it in). It was amazing and in a great location. The customer service was top notch. The only slight drawback is they're a cash only business. Would highly recommend if you're in the area.

Cee Cart

Stopped in on this beautiful day for a strawberry shake. Very tasty!!!

Chanel Brown-Legon (Chanel)

The ice cream here is really delicious.I ordered the seasonal Chocolate Covered Cherries ice cream and asked them to make it a shake. The shake was delicious and there were a lot of thick fresh cherries in the ice cream. I am typically not a chocolate ice cream girl but I wanted to try something different and I was glad that I did. The chocolate was thick, creamy, and rich.Overall a very good experience. Additionally, prices were good and the staff was friendly. If you’re in the area, it’s worth checking out!

Denise D. Gibson

Great flavors. I had cotton candy and vanilla black cherry. Great service. They are cash only.

Müge Sydorovych

Best ice cream birthday cake around. Actually best birthday cake I may say ..

María Virginia Zamora Rodríguez

One of my favorite ice cream place. My mom loves it, she usually orders chocolate ice cream.

Angela Carbone

Very kid friendly. Always have a smile on their faces.

Maggie Manzo

Best ice cream. Love the mint chocolate chip

Load More