Food is fresh and incredible. The quality is 10/10, between the decor of maradona and the pizza, you feel (and taste) like you are in Napoli and southern Italy. The gnocchi is delicious too! It is small inside so I suggest making reservations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrea M.
This restaurant surprised me with how delicious the food was. I liked the atmosphere. It was very elegantly decorated and very modern. The service was decent. It did take a while for the waiter to come. Which definitely gave the feeling of being in Italy lol iykyk lol. The food was a bit pricey but quite delicious! I'd come back for a date for sure or birthday.
Tony E.
Cozy and nice Italian restaurant with good food and a good vibe. The gnocchi was good, the pizza was tasty, the branzino was good, and the spaghetti with the zucchini was great. We had a good time celebrating my dad's birthday and will be back!
Luca De Simone
Among the most original Neapolitan Pizza i ever ate in the NJ/NY area. And I was born and raised in the center of Napoli.Top quality of ingredients and original oven.Service is excellent but not intrusive. The price is fair considering the quality of food.The dough is excellent and the mozzarella is as good as you can find.I absolutely recommend this place if you're looking for a real neapolitan pizza experience outside of Napoli.My wife and I only had margherita and calzone, BUT the pasta menu looks fantastic. I'll go back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone Song'e Napule, Margherita
Luca D.
Among the most original Neapolitan Pizza i ever ate in the NJ/NY area. And I was born and raised in the center of Napoli. Top quality of ingredients and original oven. Service is excellent but not intrusive. The price is fair considering the quality of food. The dough is excellent and the mozzarella is as good as you can find. I absolutely recommend this place if you're looking for a real neapolitan pizza experience outside of Napoli. My wife and I only had margherita and calzone, BUT the pasta menu looks fantastic. I'll go back for more.
Luisa S.
The octopus salad was absolutely amazing. Not pictured here because I was too hungry. Excellent quality, delicious eats. Pizzas are Diavolo y Primavera.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Eltion Meka
Great place right on Park Ave. Pizza is amazing but I would recommend you also try the salads. During summer you can also seat outside. Remember that like most places in Rutherford this is BYOB (there is a liquor store store right across the street).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William Vanderstarre
Very good Neapolitan pizza very traditional really good crust moist center have to eat it with a fork and knife.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Iwa Fujiwara
Perfect Neapolitan pie, done right! The dough is soft, chewy, and bubbly, with right amountof char. NOT burnt and bitter like many other places that claim to be Neapolitan pizza around NY/NJ. Their pizza is light and highly digestible and doesn't weigh you down.Amazing quality of olive oil, which I can't get enough of. Cocktails are well-made, too. Piatachio pizza with Mortdadella is rich, though. I wished they didn't use as much Mozzarella on the pie. It was delicious but quite heavy. I prefer their regular options such as Margherita or Rossa. Great service from weekend afternoon staffs!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MC P
Delicious dishes and cocktails. A must try in the neighborhood!!
Excellent food, 100% Neapolitan pizza, very good Neapolitan craft beer, I will definitely come back. The service definitely is not the best, something to improve for a restaurant like this, the music is too loud, the noise only came from the kitchen, and at times I felt overwhelmed especially with some songs that were turned up, there is no good acoustic
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Calamari Fritti, Tiramisu
Fatima Abbas
The food and drinks are a solid 4 but the prices are way too much for pizza! For 3 people with 3 drinks and 3 pizzas and an app and pasta ended up being $200 with tip for brunch! I don’t think I have ever paid that much for pizza. However the drinks were solid and they were definitely not skimping on the alcohol! The pizza was very good and the calamari was fresh! The pizza is very very very close to pizza from Italy so delicious ! I would go back if it wasn’t for the prices! It’s definitely a treat!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Gabrielle A.
After going to the city location a few times I was excited to give the Rutherford location a try and it didn't disappoint. The pizza is absolutely delicious with fresh and imported ingredients. A truly authentic spot! Our waiter even recommended me a wine he thought I would like better than Pinot Grigio (wish I remember the name of the one he recommended because it was so good) Would go back again !
Claire G.
This evening, my family and I decided to go eat here since I've been here before. Today I don't know what happened, but as soon as I got home, I had diarrhea, and my daughter had diarrhea and vomiting. I had the eggplant, and she had rigatoni & meatballs. We also had a glass of Cabernet, and tiramisu.
Angie Y.
This is such a cute date spot -- the interior is inviting, well decorated, and cozy whether you come during the day or night time. While a lot of things are good here -- I would recommend opting for the pizza or pasta over other dishes. I've been here a few times both in the daytime and evening and would actually recommend coming here during the evening time when it is candlelit over the day time. Pizza is always perfectly cooked, delicious sauce, cheese, and topping over a floppy plush charred crust. We also opted for the burrata appetizer which was really delicious -- however I did wish the arugula it was accompanied with was more dressed. Found the octopus entree to be underwhelming -- and I love octopus. It was very similar to a stew but it wasn't as flavorful as I was hoping and the octopus was a little mushy and boiled. In the past, I was always such a sucker for the bread that was served prior to the meal but unfortunately this time was really hard and cold. Olive oil here is always really high quality and the service is really attentive and friendly. Now that I've tried most of the items I've been hoping to try off the menu -- will stick to some basics moving forward.
Food is fresh and incredible. The quality is 10/10, between the decor of maradona and the pizza, you feel (and taste) like you are in Napoli and southern Italy. The gnocchi is delicious too! It is small inside so I suggest making reservations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This restaurant surprised me with how delicious the food was. I liked the atmosphere. It was very elegantly decorated and very modern. The service was decent. It did take a while for the waiter to come. Which definitely gave the feeling of being in Italy lol iykyk lol. The food was a bit pricey but quite delicious! I'd come back for a date for sure or birthday.
Cozy and nice Italian restaurant with good food and a good vibe. The gnocchi was good, the pizza was tasty, the branzino was good, and the spaghetti with the zucchini was great. We had a good time celebrating my dad's birthday and will be back!
Among the most original Neapolitan Pizza i ever ate in the NJ/NY area. And I was born and raised in the center of Napoli.Top quality of ingredients and original oven.Service is excellent but not intrusive. The price is fair considering the quality of food.The dough is excellent and the mozzarella is as good as you can find.I absolutely recommend this place if you're looking for a real neapolitan pizza experience outside of Napoli.My wife and I only had margherita and calzone, BUT the pasta menu looks fantastic. I'll go back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone Song'e Napule, Margherita
Among the most original Neapolitan Pizza i ever ate in the NJ/NY area. And I was born and raised in the center of Napoli. Top quality of ingredients and original oven. Service is excellent but not intrusive. The price is fair considering the quality of food. The dough is excellent and the mozzarella is as good as you can find. I absolutely recommend this place if you're looking for a real neapolitan pizza experience outside of Napoli. My wife and I only had margherita and calzone, BUT the pasta menu looks fantastic. I'll go back for more.
The octopus salad was absolutely amazing. Not pictured here because I was too hungry. Excellent quality, delicious eats. Pizzas are Diavolo y Primavera.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great place right on Park Ave. Pizza is amazing but I would recommend you also try the salads. During summer you can also seat outside. Remember that like most places in Rutherford this is BYOB (there is a liquor store store right across the street).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good Neapolitan pizza very traditional really good crust moist center have to eat it with a fork and knife.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Perfect Neapolitan pie, done right! The dough is soft, chewy, and bubbly, with right amountof char. NOT burnt and bitter like many other places that claim to be Neapolitan pizza around NY/NJ. Their pizza is light and highly digestible and doesn't weigh you down.Amazing quality of olive oil, which I can't get enough of. Cocktails are well-made, too. Piatachio pizza with Mortdadella is rich, though. I wished they didn't use as much Mozzarella on the pie. It was delicious but quite heavy. I prefer their regular options such as Margherita or Rossa. Great service from weekend afternoon staffs!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious dishes and cocktails. A must try in the neighborhood!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food, 100% Neapolitan pizza, very good Neapolitan craft beer, I will definitely come back. The service definitely is not the best, something to improve for a restaurant like this, the music is too loud, the noise only came from the kitchen, and at times I felt overwhelmed especially with some songs that were turned up, there is no good acoustic
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Calamari Fritti, Tiramisu
The food and drinks are a solid 4 but the prices are way too much for pizza! For 3 people with 3 drinks and 3 pizzas and an app and pasta ended up being $200 with tip for brunch! I don’t think I have ever paid that much for pizza. However the drinks were solid and they were definitely not skimping on the alcohol! The pizza was very good and the calamari was fresh! The pizza is very very very close to pizza from Italy so delicious ! I would go back if it wasn’t for the prices! It’s definitely a treat!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
After going to the city location a few times I was excited to give the Rutherford location a try and it didn't disappoint. The pizza is absolutely delicious with fresh and imported ingredients. A truly authentic spot! Our waiter even recommended me a wine he thought I would like better than Pinot Grigio (wish I remember the name of the one he recommended because it was so good) Would go back again !
This evening, my family and I decided to go eat here since I've been here before. Today I don't know what happened, but as soon as I got home, I had diarrhea, and my daughter had diarrhea and vomiting. I had the eggplant, and she had rigatoni & meatballs. We also had a glass of Cabernet, and tiramisu.
This is such a cute date spot -- the interior is inviting, well decorated, and cozy whether you come during the day or night time. While a lot of things are good here -- I would recommend opting for the pizza or pasta over other dishes. I've been here a few times both in the daytime and evening and would actually recommend coming here during the evening time when it is candlelit over the day time. Pizza is always perfectly cooked, delicious sauce, cheese, and topping over a floppy plush charred crust. We also opted for the burrata appetizer which was really delicious -- however I did wish the arugula it was accompanied with was more dressed. Found the octopus entree to be underwhelming -- and I love octopus. It was very similar to a stew but it wasn't as flavorful as I was hoping and the octopus was a little mushy and boiled. In the past, I was always such a sucker for the bread that was served prior to the meal but unfortunately this time was really hard and cold. Olive oil here is always really high quality and the service is really attentive and friendly. Now that I've tried most of the items I've been hoping to try off the menu -- will stick to some basics moving forward.