The restaurant was very welcoming. Our server was outstanding - knowledgeable, accommodating, and friendly. The food was delicious, and the staff was willing to cater to my dietary restrictions. However, I was disappointed that the restaurant didn't offer gluten free pasta.
Kathy McLean
Our group went for New Years Eve. They had a prix fix menu that was quite extensive. The food and service was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Richter
phenomenal servicegreat fooda bit crowded for space but great
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Fritta
EricS
Food was wonderful and all done perfectly with beautiful presentation. Our food came out at the perfect pace to allow us conversation and not feel like we were waiting on the food. Everyone was marvelous and very personable, and I liked that they even left a caraf of ice water so there was no waiting for refills. Can't wait to go back.
We had a friend visiting and wanted to be certain of having a great meal, and a great time. Of course, A modo Mio would be our choice. Our meals were terrific the service on point as always. A wonderful meal and a great visit with our friend.
We had an excellent time and food was amazing. A Modo Mio is the best restaurant on the island. Seating immediately at reservations time. Service was outstanding. Could not ask for a better dining experience
Bill Filerino
I ordered the veal saltimbocca. There was no prosciutto, no spinach, no cheese. I don't know what this was, but it was NOT veal saltimbocca. Also, the veal chop parm sauce had a lot of tomato paste.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
You can depend on several things at A Modo Mio. One is great Service, two is a hot Delicious Meal, and because of One & Two they are always busy. We are never rushed always treated like their only customer, and have a great meal and a great time, every visit.
PatandBill
This has been our favorite restaurant for a couple of years. That is an honor considering the number of Byob Italian restaurants in and around SIC. This night we were disappointed a bit with a special they offered which many of us ordered. It was a seafood dish of scallops, shrimp and a lobster tail in a marscapone sauce. The tail was dry and overcooked in most of our meals, making it almost impossible to eat. We will still love this place but wanted you to know for the future.
familyandfriends
The food was exquisite from appetizers through to dessert! The four of us tasted each other's orders, and everything was delicious and no one was disappointed. We had been three times before, but it was the first time our friends had been to your restaurant, and they LOVED it -- which was lucky, because it was their treat! ?
Always an enjoyable and delicious dining experience at A Modo Mio. Fresh and thoughtfully prepared menu maintains the consistence of excellence. Creative special additions are always worthy of the often painful price. Service is friendly and knowledgeable. They and their sister restaurant La Finestra are two of the few who maintain a good level of service even throughout the overly busy summer season.
Wonderful meal. The food at A Modo Mio is always delicious and served piping hot. Great Specials, and Friendly expert service from the entire team make a great meal a great Time. Our guest from out of town, were impressed with the food and the Service.
Ryan
Dined here countless times on our annual family vacation... I've been been in the service industry for over 20 years (most of that being on the fine dining scale). We have never been disappointed or have had anything negative to say about this restaurant, by far the best restaurant in the area!
Historychick
Delicious food! The service was just ok. We sat for a while, eventually pouring our own wine because no one had come to our table. The waiter only told us the specials after we asked if there were any.
QUEENOFPOUNDS
The food is always delicious but the service was absolutely horrible tonight and the atmosphere is pretty bland and extremely noisy but the service was just the worst I could ever imagine anywhere.
The restaurant was very welcoming. Our server was outstanding - knowledgeable, accommodating, and friendly. The food was delicious, and the staff was willing to cater to my dietary restrictions. However, I was disappointed that the restaurant didn't offer gluten free pasta.
Our group went for New Years Eve. They had a prix fix menu that was quite extensive. The food and service was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
phenomenal servicegreat fooda bit crowded for space but great
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Fritta
Food was wonderful and all done perfectly with beautiful presentation. Our food came out at the perfect pace to allow us conversation and not feel like we were waiting on the food. Everyone was marvelous and very personable, and I liked that they even left a caraf of ice water so there was no waiting for refills. Can't wait to go back.
We had a friend visiting and wanted to be certain of having a great meal, and a great time. Of course, A modo Mio would be our choice. Our meals were terrific the service on point as always. A wonderful meal and a great visit with our friend.
We had an excellent time and food was amazing. A Modo Mio is the best restaurant on the island. Seating immediately at reservations time. Service was outstanding. Could not ask for a better dining experience
I ordered the veal saltimbocca. There was no prosciutto, no spinach, no cheese. I don't know what this was, but it was NOT veal saltimbocca. Also, the veal chop parm sauce had a lot of tomato paste.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
You can depend on several things at A Modo Mio. One is great Service, two is a hot Delicious Meal, and because of One & Two they are always busy. We are never rushed always treated like their only customer, and have a great meal and a great time, every visit.
This has been our favorite restaurant for a couple of years. That is an honor considering the number of Byob Italian restaurants in and around SIC. This night we were disappointed a bit with a special they offered which many of us ordered. It was a seafood dish of scallops, shrimp and a lobster tail in a marscapone sauce. The tail was dry and overcooked in most of our meals, making it almost impossible to eat. We will still love this place but wanted you to know for the future.
The food was exquisite from appetizers through to dessert! The four of us tasted each other's orders, and everything was delicious and no one was disappointed. We had been three times before, but it was the first time our friends had been to your restaurant, and they LOVED it -- which was lucky, because it was their treat! ?
Restaurantji Recommends
Always an enjoyable and delicious dining experience at A Modo Mio. Fresh and thoughtfully prepared menu maintains the consistence of excellence. Creative special additions are always worthy of the often painful price. Service is friendly and knowledgeable. They and their sister restaurant La Finestra are two of the few who maintain a good level of service even throughout the overly busy summer season.
Wonderful meal. The food at A Modo Mio is always delicious and served piping hot. Great Specials, and Friendly expert service from the entire team make a great meal a great Time. Our guest from out of town, were impressed with the food and the Service.
Dined here countless times on our annual family vacation... I've been been in the service industry for over 20 years (most of that being on the fine dining scale). We have never been disappointed or have had anything negative to say about this restaurant, by far the best restaurant in the area!
Delicious food! The service was just ok. We sat for a while, eventually pouring our own wine because no one had come to our table. The waiter only told us the specials after we asked if there were any.
The food is always delicious but the service was absolutely horrible tonight and the atmosphere is pretty bland and extremely noisy but the service was just the worst I could ever imagine anywhere.