I know it's a thing, presitation is everything but food is piled up too much. I don't want a diner like serving, a dish for everything, something in between. So when you cut into that scrumptious pock chop you don't smush the potatoes. You need room to work your plate. I think you all know what I'm talking about, all the good places are doing it. Get some bigger dishes.
Great atmosphere. Solid selection and options for cocktails and beer. The menu has varied options; any we've had have always been delicious. The specials offer new surprises and never fail to be equally as good. Excellent service and they can pour a perfect pint of Guinness.
StuBytheSeaKofsky
First opening of the season. Terrific service. Probably should have kept with the specials as short rib was a bit dry. Wife had a decent steak. Rather loud but a good casual experience on the island.
Steven Brochstein
Parking: Street parking is the only parking and is free during winter months.Kid-friendliness: It's more of a pub atmosphere. It's geared towards adult clientele.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Broiled Salmon Fillet
Michael Kuntzmann
Place mostly sells seafood. Very limited menu. Only non Seafood item that I saw was a burger made one way and a chicken sandwich with too much slaw.. It was good but would have liked more choices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
MaggieS
Food was amazing as always! Always a great time seeing friends and saying Hi to the chefs. We had a reservation for 2 but saw friends at the bar and wanted to have dinner with them. We were switched to a larger table with no problem. Service is always top-notch!
Patrick Love
Great service and food I just don't give them stars always room for
It's a very good restaurant in Sea Isle City, known by everybody it's decent and the pro why did go for the service and drinks
HeatherT
My husband has several food allergies and O'Donnell's always accommodates his needs without any issues. O'Donnell's is our go-to spot in Sea Isle. The specials are always delicious and the prices are reasonable. The wait staff is friendly and helpful...especially Anthony.
Liane
I went for the Braised Short Ribs and was not disappointed! Delicious! They had a swordfish special that sounded awesome too with a ginger soy sauce and pineapple salsa, but we did not try that. I enjoyed a key lime martini, husband had a Guinness and bangers and mash which was also great. Maura was our server and she was delightful. Water was filled throughout our stay and plates were cleared in a timely manner.
Our first time back in a couple of years. Once again, great food and service. It's loud, but a great place to have dinner. We only go in the shoulder seasons when parking is easy.
Michael Barbuto
Fantastic dinner and excellent service, looking forward to our next trip back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Damian
One of the best dinners we had in sea isle city. Very cool spot with outdoor seating available
Jim McQ
Great atmosphere. Good live music, cold beverages .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Andrew
Good atmosphere and great apps. Blackened scallops.
I know it's a thing, presitation is everything but food is piled up too much. I don't want a diner like serving, a dish for everything, something in between. So when you cut into that scrumptious pock chop you don't smush the potatoes. You need room to work your plate. I think you all know what I'm talking about, all the good places are doing it. Get some bigger dishes.
Great atmosphere. Solid selection and options for cocktails and beer. The menu has varied options; any we've had have always been delicious. The specials offer new surprises and never fail to be equally as good. Excellent service and they can pour a perfect pint of Guinness.
First opening of the season. Terrific service. Probably should have kept with the specials as short rib was a bit dry. Wife had a decent steak. Rather loud but a good casual experience on the island.
Parking: Street parking is the only parking and is free during winter months.Kid-friendliness: It's more of a pub atmosphere. It's geared towards adult clientele.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Broiled Salmon Fillet
Place mostly sells seafood. Very limited menu. Only non Seafood item that I saw was a burger made one way and a chicken sandwich with too much slaw.. It was good but would have liked more choices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Food was amazing as always! Always a great time seeing friends and saying Hi to the chefs. We had a reservation for 2 but saw friends at the bar and wanted to have dinner with them. We were switched to a larger table with no problem. Service is always top-notch!
Great service and food I just don't give them stars always room for
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Shepherd's Pie, Crab Bisque, Chicken Milanese
It's a very good restaurant in Sea Isle City, known by everybody it's decent and the pro why did go for the service and drinks
My husband has several food allergies and O'Donnell's always accommodates his needs without any issues. O'Donnell's is our go-to spot in Sea Isle. The specials are always delicious and the prices are reasonable. The wait staff is friendly and helpful...especially Anthony.
I went for the Braised Short Ribs and was not disappointed! Delicious! They had a swordfish special that sounded awesome too with a ginger soy sauce and pineapple salsa, but we did not try that. I enjoyed a key lime martini, husband had a Guinness and bangers and mash which was also great. Maura was our server and she was delightful. Water was filled throughout our stay and plates were cleared in a timely manner.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our first time back in a couple of years. Once again, great food and service. It's loud, but a great place to have dinner. We only go in the shoulder seasons when parking is easy.
Fantastic dinner and excellent service, looking forward to our next trip back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best dinners we had in sea isle city. Very cool spot with outdoor seating available
Great atmosphere. Good live music, cold beverages .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Good atmosphere and great apps. Blackened scallops.