Hearthly Burger

520 Broad St, Shrewsbury
(732) 704-3447

Recent Reviews

Jennifer

WOW! The Burgers here are AMAZING! Everything here is organic and the beef is grass fed. You can tell the burgers here are high quality. I had the Mushroom Shroom Burger, and it was so delicious! The burger was so juicy. Even the bun was fresh and melted in my mouth along with the burger. The hand cut fries were very good, but wish they were served hot. I was shocked when the girl at the register said the truffle fries were $12 and a small milkshake is $10! You can end up spending $40-$50 just for a burger, truffle fries, and a shake here which is overpriced. The 5 stars is because everything was so delicious! I recommend Hearthly Burger in Shrewsbury!

Aimee Thomas

I inhaled my Truffle Burger....the food is super good and I loved the fries! So glad I tried this place it's delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger and Fries

Cory Schifter

The service, food and staff were amazing. I am a vegan and had a delicious burger with vegan cheese, bread and Beyond Burger. Highly recommend. Will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sweet Potato Fries

Michael G.

Great burger. The beef is organic- the bun, the lettuce, cheese, bacon all sustainably sourced and/or local farm to table. Healthy choice if you're going fast/casual. Love the OG sauce! Very fresh and the premises are bright and new and the staff young and friendly. I understand the burger meat comes from The Butchers Block!!

Richard D.

Usually excellent, but tonight we got there at 7:35 and the girl who took our order told us after we ordered that they were closing early tonight. The people who work there are usually very nice, but not tonight. The burger was charred and inedible. I took one bite and knew I couldn't eat it. I asked for a refund and was told I couldn't have one. I asked why not and I was told because there was nothing wrong with the burger. For $16, the burger should be mouth-watering. I spend close to $100 each time I go with my 3 kids, once a month or more. It will be a while before I go again.

HARRY SOOD

One of the best burgers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger

Kari Aponte

Insanely expensive. $50 for two burgers (not even doubles) and fries. Burgers were extremely average, fries were great though. The cashier had the nastiest attitude even though we barely interacted with her. Ambiance is just like any other fast casual restaurant. Just save your money.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Fries

Greek M.

Had the fried chicken burger - it was a bit messy and bland but the worst thing about it is that halfway into it-tasted uncooked. Could not finish it - at these prices ($16 for a sandwich). It better be damn near perfection.

Sunny Youn

Excellent, juicy mushroom burgers and delicious crispy fries, served with a smile in a sunny spot with casual reggae music. What's not to love! The mushrooms were braised and reduced before being added back to the burger . You can't lose with that choice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyler J.

This places is by far the tastiest sandwiches I've ever had with unrivaled quality. 10/10 recommend the food here, everything being all organic and locally sourced. It's pricey, but that's expected when food is quality!

Bianca P.

It was so good!! Amazing burgers, all around it was delicious, such friendly service. Definitely going back!

Samantha

0 stars. Was looking forward to visiting. Just arrived today (Sunday) at the door at 4:20pm. They close at 5pm yet the door was already locked, no one inside. Incredibly disappointing. No sign on the door to say why they were closed 40 minutes before the actual closing time.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Bogachan Ozdemir

Burger is good but if you are in any hurry, forget about this place. Manager is more about modelling her body and the cashier thinks he is in a sitcom show. Last time it took me 10 minutes to wait for a woke couple in front of me and I left. If you have time and ok to deal with woke people, it is a good burger joint.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Jeff D.

When it comes to burgers, I am pretty basic. I will typically go for a greasy burger at hole in the wall over a trendy burger spot but there's no denying that Hearthly Burger makes a solid burger. The concept is simple. You order at the counter and they bring your food to you. I ordered the double cheeseburger which came with 2 patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and OG sauce. My fiance ordered the cauliflower fries tossed in buffalo sauce. The burgers are made from grass fed beef and all of the ingredients are extremely fresh. We were part of a group of 6 and opted to eat outside since the restaurant is pretty small and most of the tables were occupied. The food and service were great. I'd like to try their fries and milkshakes on my next visit. I don't see myself coming back super often as I find a $17 burger to be too expensive, especially if it doesn't come with fries or a drink but for a tasty burger, you can't go wrong here.

Eleanor A.

I got the cheeseburger, truffle fries, cauliflower bites, and regular fries to share and let me tell you... everything was AMAZING. The OG sauce was phenomenal, and my friend who's vegan got the beyond burger and said it was incredible. I also love that they serve olipop. Will be returning !

Load More