Nicola's Pizzeria

627 Hamilton St, Somerset
(732) 246-4141

Recent Reviews

Alissa Caldwell

I stopped in that evening because I was hungry. The man was kind.Vegetarian options: Eggplant parm.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread

Carissma Middleton

Came in on 4/5/2024 with my fiancé and baby and the owner told us he isn’t accepting cash due to internet issues. That was understandable because we did have an earthquake today but when we were leaving my fiancé said to him “we’ll be back” and he proceeded to say “you won’t be back don’t tell me that” with an attitude. We were definitely going to get cash from the chicken shack next door but now we definitely won’t be back ?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rene Quintero

Love the wings extra hot!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

K

Great pizza, the only place I go for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Croissant_Tid [girl]

Some of the best pizza and food on the outskirts of New Brunswick.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak, Regular Round Pizza, Sausage Pizza, French Fries, Meatballs, Grandma

Becky

Taste was decent but bottom of pizza was burnt in some

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Amika Tate

Normal I get a cheese steakbut decided to try something different and got a meatballs parmesan. Very disappointed. Taste horrible!!! Felt like I was chewing leather, no flavor! Straight in the garbage.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

NARVIA TREADWELL

The worst so-called Italian dinner I've ever had! Been coming to this place over 20 yrs. First time ordering a dinner. I paid $18 for a Chicken Francaise dinner that was supposed to include, according to the website, linguine & a salad. What I got: Chicken cutlets that appeared to be frozen, not fresh, heated up, floating in an extremely oily sauce, spaghetti instead of linguine and no salad. When I called to complain, all the owner did was justify the mistakes made. Tried to explain why it looked like that. And then.."Guess we ran out of linguine". "Salad doesn't come with it anymore". Prices went up. The menu plainly says it comes with it.."Next time you call I will give you a couple of dollars off for the spaghetti. No offer to rectify, i.e. credit money back to my debit card, or another dinner..no forget that. Would not want another one! Had that same dish in other places. None EVER like the one I got tonight. Totally blew off a long-time customer. So disappointed, will never go there again. That establishment has really gone down over the years. So sad...

Food: 1

Service: 1

eva.

no thanks. they have bad hygiene. went in there for pizza and witnessed the owner coughing on someone’s food. left immediately.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Yolonda Stover

ASK THE OLD GUY FOR A SHRIMP PERMESAN SANDWICH I ASK HOW MANY SHRIMPS COMES WITH IT HE SAY MAYBE 4 MAYBE 5 OR MAYBE 6 IF YOUR WORK HERE WHY YOU CANT TELL THE CUSTOMER HOW MANY SMH I BEEN LIVING FOR OVER 14YRSAND NEVER TRY THERE FOOD BEFORE I GUESS THIS IS ONE OF THE REASONYOU WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHAT YOUR GETTING BEFORE YOU PAY YOUR MONEY HE WAS VERY RUDE NEVER AGAIN WOW

Mike Saad

Best pizza around! Crust and sauce wow!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Valerie Van Hoosier

If I could give this place a 0, I would. I ordered through DoorDash and NEVER received my order despite calling and checking on the status 3 different times (and got excuses each time... kept telling me the driver would be here in a few minutes. That was 2 hours ago). Got a message saying the food was delivered, and it wasn't. Thankfully DD refunded my money. I wish I would have read the reviews first. With all the really good pizza places around here, don't waste your time or money on this place.

N

Greatest pizza since I was a boy in the early 80's on Byron Place.

Andreas Zapantiotis

I'm not from that area but it's the best pizza for me

Leah V.

I am not sure how this place has any good reviews lol. Everything I ordered wasn't tasty at all. I ordered buffalo wings and received bbq wings. Eggplant parm was so tough and tasted old. Pizza is drenched in dried oregano, sauce is literally just canned tomato paste. Just awful

Load More