I stopped by for pizza and wings. Was surprised to see new ownership but decided to give it a try. BIG MISTAKE!The pizza was a disaster: the dough was tasteless, the sauce very salty. I asked for the crust to be crispy but I guess that’s not clear. Not only was not crispy, he out both slices in the same box, on top of one another !The wings were dry! Appears like they were old, fried too many times!Needless to say, I won’t be coming back to this establishment.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Bryan L
That girl Kori is always here. She always eats the slices I have left over. I don't mind it though, great food, great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandeep Panchakarla
Pizza was average, onion rings were bad and their business practice is scammy. I ordered a half Veg/plain pizza over phone and the guy at the counter didn't care to mention about extra charges for veggie toppings and charged me 10$ extra just for toppings. While at the store, another customer in older age also mentioned she paid 22$ for her sandwich and wasn't sure why it was so expensive. There are plenty of other good pizza stores in area, this is a place to stay away from.
Matheus Defarias
I’m kind of upset I took so long to try this spot. Their food is really high quality. Everything always tastes fresh, hot, and delicious. I’ve had them like 4 times now it always hits the spot. Just really good overall.
Wanda Pearson
Honestly, speaking for the first time since the pandemic I can say that the food is decent. Yes, I
Diondra B.
One of the local Pizzeria pizza does the trick for what it is. They also have good chicken tenders and fries
Isabella S.
Awful. The garlic bread was disgusting and had this weird substance on it I had to spit it out. Idk what it was but it did NOT taste edible. Penne vodka was very below average. Avoid.
Vashu Patel
Fantastic slice of pizza and great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don Chepo
New owners. Prices changed. not only that, they stopped delivering on sundays, the busiest day in football season and you wont deliver. Ridiculous. Pizza kinda downgraded in taste. But i mean if theres no other pizzeria around then i guess. But if theyre not gonna deliver, then u can literally pick up a better pie literally up the street.
Elijah Williams
It’s alright, had the pepper, onions, and sausage speciality pizza. The peppers were a little thick and the sauce lacked flavor. Great crust though and sausage was great as well. Threw a little garlic and red pepper on it and it improved the sauce quality.
Love the customer service !! Food is always bomb gotta try the buffalo slice yall?
KevLar Da Don
The other day I got New Pirates Pizza for lunch. I ordered their Philly Cheesesteak Wrap w/ Onions & Peppers; accompanied by their Cheese, Pepperoni, & Buffalo Chicken slices, with a side of Marinara Sauce (For the crust). For a little over $20 total was a steal! Their Philly Cheesesteak Wrap was absolutely phenomenal. Great flavor, great textures, and the cheese was melted perfectly. Their Pepperoni and Cheese Slices, along with their Marinara Sauce, were extremely subpar at best though. But their Buffalo Chicken slice was AMAZING. Honestly probably one of, if not the best, Buffalo Chicken slice I’ve ever had. Usually Buffalo Slices have one specific flavor that sticks out (ie Too much Buffalo sauce, or too much ranch or blue cheese), but it had a perfect blend. I thoroughly enjoyed their Buffalo Chicken Slice. The chicken was cooked perfectly, and it had an excellent balance between the spiciness of the Buffalo sauce, and coolness of the ranch. All of the slices had a mediocre crust though. Very soft and doughy. All in all, absolutely enjoyed their Philly Cheesesteak Wrap & Buffalo Chicken Slice, reason why I ranked them so highly. The other two slices were ok at best though. I would absolutely highly recommend New Pirates Pizza to anyone looking for some really good and affordable food in the South Orange area. They have other phenomenal menu options as well too (Like their Mexican Corner Menu). I just couldn’t highly recommend their pizza slices, unless they are specialty slices.
Brady Good (PuddleJumper)
Made us wait an hour for dry wings and never told us a wait time wouldn’t recommend
Bern Carlton
Today was my 1st time here this is a hidden gem because I've been going down the street to trattoria which prices are ridiculously expensive so I would go all the way to Florham Park to Nonnas This is a new pizza spot pizza is very good crust is crunchy yet soft check this place out for yourself right next to Walgreens
Darrielle Terry
My favorite Pizzeria . I have been going here since I was in highschool, so it has now been 14 years . The pizza has been consistent even throughout all the years . The owner is fantastic ! Loyal customer here!
I stopped by for pizza and wings. Was surprised to see new ownership but decided to give it a try. BIG MISTAKE!The pizza was a disaster: the dough was tasteless, the sauce very salty. I asked for the crust to be crispy but I guess that’s not clear. Not only was not crispy, he out both slices in the same box, on top of one another !The wings were dry! Appears like they were old, fried too many times!Needless to say, I won’t be coming back to this establishment.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
That girl Kori is always here. She always eats the slices I have left over. I don't mind it though, great food, great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was average, onion rings were bad and their business practice is scammy. I ordered a half Veg/plain pizza over phone and the guy at the counter didn't care to mention about extra charges for veggie toppings and charged me 10$ extra just for toppings. While at the store, another customer in older age also mentioned she paid 22$ for her sandwich and wasn't sure why it was so expensive. There are plenty of other good pizza stores in area, this is a place to stay away from.
I’m kind of upset I took so long to try this spot. Their food is really high quality. Everything always tastes fresh, hot, and delicious. I’ve had them like 4 times now it always hits the spot. Just really good overall.
Honestly, speaking for the first time since the pandemic I can say that the food is decent. Yes, I
One of the local Pizzeria pizza does the trick for what it is. They also have good chicken tenders and fries
Awful. The garlic bread was disgusting and had this weird substance on it I had to spit it out. Idk what it was but it did NOT taste edible. Penne vodka was very below average. Avoid.
Fantastic slice of pizza and great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New owners. Prices changed. not only that, they stopped delivering on sundays, the busiest day in football season and you wont deliver. Ridiculous. Pizza kinda downgraded in taste. But i mean if theres no other pizzeria around then i guess. But if theyre not gonna deliver, then u can literally pick up a better pie literally up the street.
It’s alright, had the pepper, onions, and sausage speciality pizza. The peppers were a little thick and the sauce lacked flavor. Great crust though and sausage was great as well. Threw a little garlic and red pepper on it and it improved the sauce quality.
Restaurantji Recommends
Love the customer service !! Food is always bomb gotta try the buffalo slice yall?
The other day I got New Pirates Pizza for lunch. I ordered their Philly Cheesesteak Wrap w/ Onions & Peppers; accompanied by their Cheese, Pepperoni, & Buffalo Chicken slices, with a side of Marinara Sauce (For the crust). For a little over $20 total was a steal! Their Philly Cheesesteak Wrap was absolutely phenomenal. Great flavor, great textures, and the cheese was melted perfectly. Their Pepperoni and Cheese Slices, along with their Marinara Sauce, were extremely subpar at best though. But their Buffalo Chicken slice was AMAZING. Honestly probably one of, if not the best, Buffalo Chicken slice I’ve ever had. Usually Buffalo Slices have one specific flavor that sticks out (ie Too much Buffalo sauce, or too much ranch or blue cheese), but it had a perfect blend. I thoroughly enjoyed their Buffalo Chicken Slice. The chicken was cooked perfectly, and it had an excellent balance between the spiciness of the Buffalo sauce, and coolness of the ranch. All of the slices had a mediocre crust though. Very soft and doughy. All in all, absolutely enjoyed their Philly Cheesesteak Wrap & Buffalo Chicken Slice, reason why I ranked them so highly. The other two slices were ok at best though. I would absolutely highly recommend New Pirates Pizza to anyone looking for some really good and affordable food in the South Orange area. They have other phenomenal menu options as well too (Like their Mexican Corner Menu). I just couldn’t highly recommend their pizza slices, unless they are specialty slices.
Made us wait an hour for dry wings and never told us a wait time wouldn’t recommend
Today was my 1st time here this is a hidden gem because I've been going down the street to trattoria which prices are ridiculously expensive so I would go all the way to Florham Park to Nonnas This is a new pizza spot pizza is very good crust is crunchy yet soft check this place out for yourself right next to Walgreens
My favorite Pizzeria . I have been going here since I was in highschool, so it has now been 14 years . The pizza has been consistent even throughout all the years . The owner is fantastic ! Loyal customer here!